Strip till versus no till

@Brisel @Clive ,so how do we do it ,intensive root cropped land harvested in less than ideal conditions at times , but are doing some covers gets some muck ,some structureless sand some grade one silt and black and every thing inbetween , doing less cultivation and is slowly working but the spuds undo it all , drilled 100 acre is other day with combi ,after beans and rape its in good order ,like a giant sponge as you keep going on about structure superb ,we want to go to the next step with different drill but want to stay on narrow spacing .?
Build your own tine drill?
 

Heathland

Member
Arable Farmer
Location
Lincolnshire
@Brisel A quick question you might know is why do Claydon drills take so much hp,got the option of a used tool bar with front hopper and they tell me I need 200hp on the front,the machine has only got 14 tines.
IMG_20191103_171712.jpg

Also what are they like for drilling OSR probably the main job for the above machine.

Had a Claydon sermon on Friday making me interested.

I've hopefully got a 6m Claydon Hybrid coming on demo if it will stay dry for long enough which will be interesting in OSR stubble,lots of volunteer OSR at a 1' high in places I've been told it will drill it due to having a front discs,but what you are saying it could be interesting.

What Claydon are you running.
 
Have just emailed dale and Simtech to hopefully have a look at machines.im sure in my opinion anyway that strip till is the way to go as a seed bed is made as opposed to a direct drill where seed can sit on a dry bench.hopefully I’ll get to hear from several companies I’ve emailed.i think a disc is important to slice through trash like a cover crop.i saw a Claydon demoed in a cover crop at cereals 2 years ago and with just one leg it was getting trash,mustard stalks, wrapped around it it which I’m sure would eventually block.im open to anyone’s opinions thanks
Nick...

I don't want to persuade you one way or another on drill choice but I don't think that is a correct analysis
 
Strip till, in no particular order;
Claydon Hybrid
Mzuri Pro Till
Sumo DTS (can you swap the rear toolbar for a DD gang on a trailed machine in future??)
Horsch Focus TD

No till tine;
Dale
Seedhawk (rare older machines over here)
Aitchison T Sem
Modified Horsch CO/Sprinter
Virkar Dynamic with leading disc
Amazone Cayena, Primera, Condor

No till disc;
JD 750A
Horsch Avatar
Moore Unidrill/Sumo Versadrill/Sky Easydrill
Weaving GD
Ryetec MAAG SSP
Kuhn SD/Aurock
Primewest Cross Slot
Novag T Force Plus
MF130
Bettinson TC3 (showing my age here!)


Cough cough - Triton will see you outside...
 

Brisel

Member
Arable Farmer
Location
Midlands
@Brisel A quick question you might know is why do Claydon drills take so much hp,got the option of a used tool bar with front hopper and they tell me I need 200hp on the front,the machine has only got 14 tines.View attachment 841853
Also what are they like for drilling OSR probably the main job for the above machine.

Had a Claydon sermon on Friday making me interested.

I've hopefully got a 6m Claydon Hybrid coming on demo if it will stay dry for long enough which will be interesting in OSR stubble,lots of volunteer OSR at a 1' high in places I've been told it will drill it due to having a front discs,but what you are saying it could be interesting.

What Claydon are you running.

Who gave the sermon? The man himself? That looks like a SR toolbar. Not much different to a Hybrid but the leading legs are different.

Horsepower requirement? At least 50 hp/m on light land. I have 370hp on 6m and needed every single horse last week putting beans 4" into clay cap soils with the 1" wide leading leg in 6" deep. Look at your stubble cultivator and count the legs on it. That's a lot of steel in the ground. Not sure what the spacing is on that SR toolbar. The Hybrids have an odd number to help with a straight pull on autosteer. 9 on 3m, 13 on 4m, 15 on 4.8m and 19 on 6m. Ok, so on well structured soils with the legs 4" deep on spring barley the Autopower tractor revs die back but any kind of clay or slope and it pulls harder. What have you got for the 6m demo? A trailed one?

You can swap the leading leg for a disc which will slice trash well but it will put a lot of strain on the coulter leg. I'd only advise that on soil that is very well structured otherwise you'll be walking fields looking for snapped off legs.

If you fancy a look at mine, you're always welcome down here.
 
Last edited:

Heathland

Member
Arable Farmer
Location
Lincolnshire
@Brisel
Sharmans have taken on the franchise,and the sales reps have been down and had a look at what Claydons have managed to achieve on their own farm and they were all very impressed,the guys at Sharmans know I need to change things but I'm. not to sure which way to jump.
I do have sugar beet but its mainly grown on the heathland which is very forgiving,but that doesn't fit with DD'ing.
Thats the main reason at looking at strip till,some where in between.
They have a 6m trailed hybrid which will come with a 7310R on the front,I don't think they have done many demos this back end for some reason????????????????????

Thanks for the invite,I might take you up on that when I get a bit quieter ?
 

Brisel

Member
Arable Farmer
Location
Midlands
The T6C has a smaller hopper than the regular T6. My mounted 6m Hybrid has a tiny hopper barely able to hold a tonne. I'd go for the bigger one if you can - easier to put less bags in than regret not buying the right size when you start. I'd say 310hp is at the bottom end of the scale for a drill like that. Your stronger land will have that on its knees, especially on slopes. I'm sure the heath will be easier.

A day with Jeff Claydon at his place will be good, though he's a very good salesman, so leave your chequebook at home! Best to go and talk to other users on similar farms to your own IMO.

842094
 

Badshot

Member
Location
Kent
@Brisel
Sharmans have taken on the franchise,and the sales reps have been down and had a look at what Claydons have managed to achieve on their own farm and they were all very impressed,the guys at Sharmans know I need to change things but I'm. not to sure which way to jump.
I do have sugar beet but its mainly grown on the heathland which is very forgiving,but that doesn't fit with DD'ing.
Thats the main reason at looking at strip till,some where in between.
They have a 6m trailed hybrid which will come with a 7310R on the front,I don't think they have done many demos this back end for some reason????????????????????

Thanks for the invite,I might take you up on that when I get a bit quieter ?
@Bill Turtle has planted wheat after beet with a claydon with good success I believe.
 

Brisel

Member
Arable Farmer
Location
Midlands
@Bill Turtle has planted wheat after beet with a claydon with good success I believe.

@Daniel too

I wouldn't want to run a Claydon directly into deep ruts left by a beet gang as seed depth will be very uneven. The coulters are fixed, not floating - if you're looking at a Claydon, forget about even seed depth unless you're drilling into a billiard table flat field.
 

Alistair Nelson

Member
Mixed Farmer
Location
E Yorks
@Brisel A quick question you might know is why do Claydon drills take so much hp,got the option of a used tool bar with front hopper and they tell me I need 200hp on the front,the machine has only got 14 tines.View attachment 841853
Also what are they like for drilling OSR probably the main job for the above machine.

Had a Claydon sermon on Friday making me interested.

I've hopefully got a 6m Claydon Hybrid coming on demo if it will stay dry for long enough which will be interesting in OSR stubble,lots of volunteer OSR at a 1' high in places I've been told it will drill it due to having a front discs,but what you are saying it could be interesting.

What Claydon are you running.

that toolbar is an SR as mentioned above and the man who can tell you everything about it is Mathew Bowe who now works at Claydons he operated that particular unit when it was new in a previous job so is the only man fully qualified to tell you what it can achieve and can’t.
 

SFI - What % were you taking out of production?

  • 0 %

    Votes: 103 40.7%
  • Up to 25%

    Votes: 92 36.4%
  • 25-50%

    Votes: 39 15.4%
  • 50-75%

    Votes: 5 2.0%
  • 75-100%

    Votes: 3 1.2%
  • 100% I’ve had enough of farming!

    Votes: 11 4.3%

May Event: The most profitable farm diversification strategy 2024 - Mobile Data Centres

  • 1,237
  • 21
With just a internet connection and a plug socket you too can join over 70 farms currently earning up to £1.27 ppkw ~ 201% ROI

Register Here: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/the-mo...2024-mobile-data-centres-tickets-871045770347

Tuesday, May 21 · 10am - 2pm GMT+1

Location: Village Hotel Bury, Rochdale Road, Bury, BL9 7BQ

The Farming Forum has teamed up with the award winning hardware manufacturer Easy Compute to bring you an educational talk about how AI and blockchain technology is helping farmers to diversify their land.

Over the past 7 years, Easy Compute have been working with farmers, agricultural businesses, and renewable energy farms all across the UK to help turn leftover space into mini data centres. With...
Top