WHY IS THERE SUCH A SHORTAGE OF LABOUR IN EVERY INDUSTRY IN THIS COUNTRY?

E6B02BB4-DE2D-4122-B609-E47F14DB7DCA.jpeg
 
To be totally honest mate, I’ve done it, so yea, I know it sucks. But maybe I’m different, I don’t expect to be given what I want, feel like I’ve got to graft for it.

Interesting you mention being the key worker who stops gran lying in her own sh*t, in this country, low pay, low skill. In say Scandinavia, same position pays much better and is more respected, but the employee would be expected to hold a uni degree in social pedagogy, to hold the same position.

Also, just for the record, who was even talking about minimum wage ? Very very few folk in ag will be offering minimum wage. I don’t think anyone has been complaining about what they have to pay to get good employees, they are complaining that whatever you pay, you get dross.

You get a little excited about the idea that every employee is being shafted by employers paying under what they should. I pay good money and I’ve been stolen from, lied to, they’ve tried to steal ground off me etc, not to mention being fairly useless at the job and more interested in snap chat and looking cool. I could have doubled the money and they still would have been little weasels.

The OP mentions how so many industries are having trouble finding staff. I thus naturally discussed businesses in general but didn't specifically mention agriculture as I know you rarely, if ever, see any job adverts for anything agricultural involving mention of minimum wage. I know some people do earn a very reasonable salary from the industry and are far from what I would class as unskilled.

Interesting that you would describe key worker type stuff as unskilled. I personally wouldn't say it was totally unskilled: rather more noggin involved than working in a bar or cinema by my estimation. I'm very proud of what I have learned and achieved in my time whilst doing it, I'm fortunate that I can afford to work for that kind of wage in the short term though and would say that there are very few people of my age bracket doing it- as I said, most of my colleagues are either much younger or much older than me.

I've no issue whatsoever with employers offering whatever they like, I've written at length that private enterprise should be left to get on with making money (within the realms of the law)- I've merely said that I find it curious they are complaining there is no decent staff about yet they are offering minimum wage. I also outlined that I felt £8.91 is basically a non-starter for anyone who doesn't fit the school leaver/uni student or semi-retired bracket because most of us have substantial everyday living expenses.

As for employees being dishonest, fraud, theft and the like, unfortunately that is part and parcel of the everyday public and happens in all walks of life and at all levels. Human nature is an interesting thing.
 
Problem I’ve found is the lack of self awareness in that some people have very little concept of their own limitations and lack of skills/knowledge, often coupled with an assumption that they are always right.

I’m open to investing in people if it’s returned in a good attitude and interest in the job. Skills are an irrelevance in my opinion, they can be taught, good attitudes can’t.

The OP asks why is there shortages of home grown labour?

In my opinion a lot of it is simply down to bad attitudes and an inflated sense of self importance brought about by weak parenting created, in turn, by woolly, hand wringing, short term, populist politics.

as to how to fix it, haven’t a clue.

I would agree with much of what you have written. It is cultural and also a by product I think, of the Blair years. Government grew massively over time and people basically won't do anything for themselves and expect to be spoon fed all their lives.

I would hazard a guess that the majority of us here know what a 100 working week feels like and know how to graft if we want to. With that kind of mindset (and also the stamina/health to do it) you can probably earn a reasonable living doing virtually anything in the UK as there is actually a lot of opportunity in the UK for people with even no skills, experience or qualifications.
 

kiwi pom

Member
Location
canterbury NZ
On local tv news this evening prepared ve
I honestly don’t think I agree. Yes you’re right, you get a bigger pool of choice in theory. What I’m saying is that there is a fairly major attitudinal issue with regard to work these days. There are lots and lots of folk offering good, higher than average wages, and struggling to get anyone decent or anyone at all. I don’t think that £12-15 an hour for driving about checking sheep or standing about a race shoving a few sheep up, is bad at all! Yer sure you could say if you offered £35 a hour you’d get better folk. Well if you offered £75 k a year you’d get better etc but there has to be some kind of sense.

We're back to the same problem again, no one really wants to be an employee. Many people with the desire to crack on these days want to be their own boss, so spend as little time as possible being an employee before starting out by themselves. I'm guessing you're another example of this?
Big companies employ sub contractors now, because they think it saves money (maybe it does) the kind of person that becomes a contractor is the same person who would have been the employee in the old system. Now they see a chance to get out and be a 'boss', so they set up as a sub contractor and hire staff to do the job they would have been doing, in the old system. I think it makes things more inefficient, but what do I know.
Anyone good, who does not want to be their own boss, has more options regarding pay, hours, job description etc and can quickly become quite comfortable without the stress of running a business or doing a crap job.
Take out those that won't work as well and you end up with quite a small group of people to do the lower paid, less desirable but essential jobs
When I was a kid just getting a job was a big deal but now there's more choice, so you can be more selective. Can't really blame people for that.
 

Bury the Trash

Member
Mixed Farmer
He's building natural immunity so he doesn't need a covid jab.
not surprised considering some of the reports iveheard from , of people whove had them...:unsure:
few thistles here unfortunately, this year , bit of orf yesterday i noted, when drenching against nemo, , i give them 🤚🖐a good scrub whilst singin happy birthday:sneaky: last night that's fer sure.:cautious:(y)
 

unlacedgecko

Member
Livestock Farmer
Location
Fife
not surprised considering some of the reports iveheard from , of people whove had them...:unsure:
few thistles here unfortunately, this year , bit of orf yesterday i noted, when drenching against nemo, , i give them 🤚🖐a good scrub whilst singin happy birthday:sneaky: last night that's fer sure.:cautious:(y)
Good idea. Giving the Mrs orf on her fanny will not help marital relations!
 

unlacedgecko

Member
Livestock Farmer
Location
Fife
We're back to the same problem again, no one really wants to be an employee. Many people with the desire to crack on these days want to be their own boss, so spend as little time as possible being an employee before starting out by themselves. I'm guessing you're another example of this?
Big companies employ sub contractors now, because they think it saves money (maybe it does) the kind of person that becomes a contractor is the same person who would have been the employee in the old system. Now they see a chance to get out and be a 'boss', so they set up as a sub contractor and hire staff to do the job they would have been doing, in the old system. I think it makes things more inefficient, but what do I know.
Anyone good, who does not want to be their own boss, has more options regarding pay, hours, job description etc and can quickly become quite comfortable without the stress of running a business or doing a crap job.
Take out those that won't work as well and you end up with quite a small group of people to do the lower paid, less desirable but essential jobs
When I was a kid just getting a job was a big deal but now there's more choice, so you can be more selective. Can't really blame people for that.

FB_IMG_1623888870497.jpg


This chap is keen for a job at least.
 

bluebell

Member
i truely blame the countries education system, from primary schools right through to univercities, children , young people are continualy told promised that a so called educated qualificationaled way to go ? doing work with your hands getting dirty is wrong, all this has done is lend to the growth of further educational uninis ? teaching cources that only benifit the poorly educated lecturers ? letting down and demolishing the hopes of the young students? many many of which would have been better off both finacially and of getting a job if they had gone straight in to a job at leaving school or as they have in america going on to to trade school ? p.s. some of the best workers, sucessful business people i know didnt have any what you would call a proper education ?
 

kiwi pom

Member
Location
canterbury NZ
i truely blame the countries education system, from primary schools right through to univercities, children , young people are continualy told promised that a so called educated qualificationaled way to go ? doing work with your hands getting dirty is wrong, all this has done is lend to the growth of further educational uninis ? teaching cources that only benifit the poorly educated lecturers ? letting down and demolishing the hopes of the young students? many many of which would have been better off both finacially and of getting a job if they had gone straight in to a job at leaving school or as they have in america going on to to trade school ? p.s. some of the best workers, sucessful business people i know didnt have any what you would call a proper education ?

Plenty of people do VERY well after a university education though.
My brothers mate left school with bugger all exams and worked on farms for the summer but then decided to re do GCSE's and work up to the university thing.
He was the only person at Manchester Uni milking cows at the weekends:LOL:
As soon as he graduated he started work in IT and cracked on up the ladder. Tripping over money now, his lifetime income so far is very different to my brothers, who carried on doing farm work.
 

theboytheboy

Member
Arable Farmer
Location
Portsmouth
As soon as my boys are old enough they will "earn" any pocket money they get.

Of course they will also get gifts on occasions, but on the whole if they want something, they need to learn its got to be earned.

Once they are teenagers if they don't find a part time/weekend job I will send them to work. I will happily subsidize or cover their wages working as a labourer for a tradesman if nothing is available. bumping tiles / blocks up a ladder onto scaffold or washing dishes in a pub etc

I will also try to teach them about saving a portion of wages, and compound interest etc as I wish my parents had attempted to give me a financial education as a young lad! I dread to think what I frittered away that could have been building up a nice pot.

God I sound like miserable old git!
 

SFI - What % were you taking out of production?

  • 0 %

    Votes: 102 41.6%
  • Up to 25%

    Votes: 89 36.3%
  • 25-50%

    Votes: 36 14.7%
  • 50-75%

    Votes: 5 2.0%
  • 75-100%

    Votes: 3 1.2%
  • 100% I’ve had enough of farming!

    Votes: 10 4.1%

May Event: The most profitable farm diversification strategy 2024 - Mobile Data Centres

  • 636
  • 2
With just a internet connection and a plug socket you too can join over 70 farms currently earning up to £1.27 ppkw ~ 201% ROI

Register Here: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/the-mo...2024-mobile-data-centres-tickets-871045770347

Tuesday, May 21 · 10am - 2pm GMT+1

Location: Village Hotel Bury, Rochdale Road, Bury, BL9 7BQ

The Farming Forum has teamed up with the award winning hardware manufacturer Easy Crypto Hunter and Easy Compute to bring you an educational talk about how AI and blockchain technology is helping farmers to diversify their land.

Over the past 7 years, Easy Crypto Hunter have been working with farmers, agricultural businesses, and renewable energy farms all across the UK to help turn leftover space into...
Top