Easy to harvest soybean varieties

Bogweevil

Member
A new study has shown that soybean could be more widely farmed in the UK.

The report’s authors from Rothamsted Research say the crop, which is currently only grown in very limited quantities, could be more successful across southern England. Climate change will mean it could also be grown for profit as far north at the Scottish borders within just a few decades.

Lead author, Kevin Coleman said: “Our results suggest that by 2050 soybean should be a viable crop across most of England and south Wales.

“Yields would be enough to make it an economically attractive option for farmers, with the added benefits of reduced nitrogen fertiliser needs and the fact that soybean has very few pests or diseases here.”

Agriculture in the UK lacks diversification, say the authors, and would greatly benefit from an economically viable, nitrogen fixing legume that breaks the pest, competitor or disease cycles in the main cash crops that dominate current rotations.

Most of the world’s soybean is currently grown in the Americas and 3.2M tonnes are imported into the UK each year, where it is mainly used to feed livestock.

It is also processed into popular vegan diet staples such as meat-free sausages and burgers, milk substitutes and tofu.

Recent advances in plant breeding have produced easy to harvest soybean varieties suitable for the UK’s cold, wet climate – overcoming what were the main barriers to take up by farmers.

Over three years the researchers grew 14 different varieties at two sites in England, and then used modelling to extrapolate the results to 26 sites across the UK.

In addition, the model was used to predict how soybean would mature and the associated yield using weather data under current, near-future (2041-60), and far-future (2081-2100) climate scenarios.

The analysis revealed that under current climate, early developing varieties will mature in the south of the UK, but the probability of failure increases with latitude.

“Under climate change some of these varieties are likely to mature as far north as southern Scotland,” said Coleman. “With greater levels of CO 2, yield is predicted to increase by as much as half a tonne per hectare at some sites in the far future, but this is tempered by other effects of climate change meaning that for most sites no meaningful increase in yield is expected.

“However, with climate change, varieties that mature later will become viable in the south and this will also have positive implications on yield potential.”

Based on the estimated price of soybean and associated variable costs a 2 tonne per hectare crop could result in a profit comparable to that of field beans.

“Soybean is likely to be a viable crop in the UK and for similar climates at similar latitudes in Northern Europe in the future,” said Coleman. “The right variety must be selected for the local climate and growing season characteristics. Providing those varieties can match the quality of imported soybean, local markets should be found. The financial attractiveness of the crop will be determined by the margin achieved over growing costs, which is dependent upon how the grower values the additional benefits of the crop such as spreading workload, weed control and the benefit to rotation.”

 

Brisel

Member
Arable Farmer
Location
Midlands
Yeah it doesn't have any pests or diseases here. Yet.

You haven’t done any agronomy on UK soyabeans! Delia bean fly, pigeons, sclerotinia. Not bad in comparison to other crops, but not a case of drill and forget. Not exactly sparkling performance in Britain yet either, but given time and good plans breeding it should become more popular. Look at how maize has been developed to thrive here.
 
You haven’t done any agronomy on UK soyabeans! Delia bean fly, pigeons, sclerotinia. Not bad in comparison to other crops, but not a case of drill and forget. Not exactly sparkling performance in Britain yet either, but given time and good plans breeding it should become more popular. Look at how maize has been developed to thrive here.

I'm quoting what these geniuses mentioned by the OP stated. I've never grown it but I can imagine that it will get more and more issues as the climate changes.
 

Michael S

Member
Arable Farmer
Location
Matching Green
I grew them in 2001, got 2t/ha in early October. As I see it there hasn't been much change in the last 20 years, maybe harvest dates have crept forward. I have a neighbour who was the biggest grower in the country, but now doesn't grow any.

I see the attraction of growing soya but our climate isn't hot and dry enough yet IMO.
 

Simon Chiles

DD Moderator
Moderator
I grew them in 2001, got 2t/ha in early October. As I see it there hasn't been much change in the last 20 years, maybe harvest dates have crept forward. I have a neighbour who was the biggest grower in the country, but now doesn't grow any.

I see the attraction of growing soya but our climate isn't hot and dry enough yet IMO.

In 2001 the only variety of Soya suitable in the UK would have been Elena. since then of all the arable crops Soya has easily made the greatest improvements in both yield and harvest date. Last year, because of the weather my Soya was a bit disappointing ( as was most spring crops) however, although the seed was £55/ acre, I’d be exaggerating if I said the herbicide cost £3 an acre each time ( I did it twice ) and it had a sniff of bittersaltz each time I did a herbicide. Now reglone has gone I couldn’t use it as a desiccant, fortunately Soya naturally senesces fast none was necessary.
91FA48F0-9131-4256-A409-67D98B81D36C.jpeg


at £370/tonne I’d challenge anyone to better that margin last year with Spring Barley.
 

marshbarn

Member
Location
shropshire
In 2001 the only variety of Soya suitable in the UK would have been Elena. since then of all the arable crops Soya has easily made the greatest improvements in both yield and harvest date. Last year, because of the weather my Soya was a bit disappointing ( as was most spring crops) however, although the seed was £55/ acre, I’d be exaggerating if I said the herbicide cost £3 an acre each time ( I did it twice ) and it had a sniff of bittersaltz each time I did a herbicide. Now reglone has gone I couldn’t use it as a desiccant, fortunately Soya naturally senesces fast none was necessary.
91FA48F0-9131-4256-A409-67D98B81D36C.jpeg


at £370/tonne I’d challenge anyone to better that margin last year with Spring Barley.
Can you give a bit more details please , drilling date ? Herbicides? harvest Date?
TIA
 

Simon Chiles

DD Moderator
Moderator
Can you give a bit more details please , drilling date ? Herbicides? harvest Date?
TIA

Drilling date was the 3rd week in April, maybe a bit earlier than you would in a normal year, herbicide was pinnacle, I didn’t waste my money on a pre em as it was never going to do anything in those conditions. Obviously dd’ed. Harvest date was 21st September which was a bit later than normal.
 

Simon Chiles

DD Moderator
Moderator
You haven’t done any agronomy on UK soyabeans! Delia bean fly, pigeons, sclerotinia. Not bad in comparison to other crops, but not a case of drill and forget. Not exactly sparkling performance in Britain yet either, but given time and good plans breeding it should become more popular. Look at how maize has been developed to thrive here.

Sclerotinia is only a problem if you grow rape in a tight rotation with Soya, even then it’s only a case of giving it a sniff of fungicide if you thinkit’s going to be a problem. Pigeons are a nightmare in the first few weeks, you have to be aware of the potential problem and keep on top of them, once it’s got it’s true ( hairy ) leaves you’ve got through the worst of the problem. Personally I’ve never had a problem with Delia bean fly ( although I’ve heard of some that have ) drilling date, weather conditions and an insecticide if you’re worried can sort them out.
 

California

Member
Arable Farmer
Location
South Lincs
We have grown soya (a variety called Siverka) for the last four years along with a neighbour. 2020 was the last. They are great in theory but the last two years we have had to combine them in November and it's been touch and go as to whether we would even get them in the shed.
Last year we got them but due to the harvest conditions and basically having to combine them at stupid percent moisture we had to spend lots of time and money drying them. It was a real hassle and though they were spread out thinly on a heated drying floor we struggled to get them to keep. There were sizeable deductions for pod etc. in the sample.
The first year we harvested them in mid October, the second year it was late September which wasn't bad at all (shame about the yield). Generally 1-1.2t/ha has been the norm though we have had up to 2t/ha on invdividual fields. We have also had complete crop failures on individual fields. Last year they looked really well but disappointingly only yielded 1t/ha
Often we have had the problem of dry conditions at drilling which has made them slow to get away and then the pigeons cane them.
Maybe further south they have more potential and there is a lot to like about them in theory but after 2 years of mid-November combining for us we wont be trying them again in a hurry. They have been anything but easy to harvest.
 

Lewis821

Member
Mixed Farmer
Location
norfolk
Doesn’t look like much there. ☹
It wasn’t great tbh. Drilled into dust, rained on for weeks when it was Fit to cut. The first year we grew them was fine, drilled into a decent seed bed followed by showery rain then a warm dry end of sept made combining a treat. The picture below is a friends 780 after they cut theirs last year, they aren’t growing any this year
65FD4EA3-7670-4CB1-BC93-2F5391B8F93D.jpeg
02A2008F-898A-4B15-9E07-E633C58405D4.jpeg
A7AFE85F-0D67-4F7B-ADC4-50E8BD4D2AC5.jpeg
 

Will you help clear snow?

  • yes

    Votes: 70 32.0%
  • no

    Votes: 149 68.0%

The London Palladium event “BPR Seminar”

  • 14,000
  • 224
This is our next step following the London rally 🚜

BPR is not just a farming issue, it affects ALL business, it removes incentive to invest for growth

Join us @LondonPalladium on the 16th for beginning of UK business fight back👍

Back
Top