How many farmers have had a formal university education?

Discussion in 'Brexit & Politics' started by Bomber_Harris, Feb 8, 2019.

  1. Bomber_Harris

    Bomber_Harris Member

    Location:
    London
    I ask because yesterday I was on the way to Cheltenham and I drove past what looked like a farming university, so I was wondering if anyone on this forum has ever had any kind of university education doesn't have to be specific to farming

    I'm going to take a punt and suggest around 35% but I'm not a farmer so that's a very speculative guess

    #justasking
     
    Last edited: Feb 8, 2019
  2. alex04w

    alex04w Member

    Location:
    Co Antrim
    BSc(Hons) in Applied Accounting - first class pass.
     
  3. BA Hons in History 2:1
    Post Grad Diploma in Peace and Conflict Studies
    FdSc in Agriculture with Commendation
     
  4. Suffolk Serf

    Suffolk Serf Member

    Location:
    Bury/Thetford
    CSE metalwork. Grade 2.
     
    kfpben, Walter R, Henarar and 12 others like this.
  5. caveman

    caveman Member

    Location:
    East Sussex.
    GCSE Maths A (?). Night school.
    Think I'll stand against Dianne Abbot.
     
  6. 7610 super q

    7610 super q Member

    Location:
    Crapweathershire
    You can't educate pork ( or gammon ).:ROFLMAO:
     
  7. wanton dwarf

    wanton dwarf Member

    Just another snide comment inferring farmers are thick.

    The average age of farmers is 59 .. so the expected University education will be around the average for that age group depending on their social profile.

    Their wives, husbands, sons and daughters will have a different profile.

    I'm more interested in how efficient the very expensive Tony Blair experiment has turned out and whether those with degrees are able to return a profit to tax payers .. for example how many with degrees are in dead end low paid jobs.
     
  8. Walterp

    Walterp Member

    Location:
    Pembrokeshire
    35% is a vast over-statement - most farmers rise to their position by inheritance, not education.

    As I cast my eye around my locality, I can think of only one, plus me.

    Out of hundreds.

    (And, yes, Brexit supporters tend to be poorly-educated as a rule, according to the polling research. It is an uncomfortable fact.)
     
    red likes this.
  9. Bomber_Harris

    Bomber_Harris Member

    Location:
    London
    hmm I should have added a poll. This doesn't appear to be possible after a thread has been created?
     
  10. linga

    linga Member

    Location:
    Ceredigion
    Are you assuming qualification equals education ?
     
  11. Agrivator

    Agrivator Member

    It is beyond dispute that there is no positive correlation between academic qualifications and ability to farm efficiently.

    Agricultural science and access to sound advice has immense benefits, but actual farming is an art which cannot be taught by academics. And my advice to all new entrants or novice farmers is to find out who are the able, respected but usually reticent farmers in the locality, and try to get them to offer guidance.
     
  12. wanton dwarf

    wanton dwarf Member


    So what have you actually done in your life ?
     
    ollie989898 and Old McDonald like this.
  13. 7610 super q

    7610 super q Member

    Location:
    Crapweathershire
    What about the Nissan workers at Sunderland ? How many went to UNI ?
    Must be a correlation.....turkeys......small brains.......leave voters......

    Or is this just more racist clap trap....:whistle:
     
  14. Walterp

    Walterp Member

    Location:
    Pembrokeshire
    Well, let's examine cases.

    Everyone knows my background and how I paid (twice over, in one case) for my farms. I earned the right to practise, and farm, thru' education and hard work. I have only ever been left one legacy - £500.

    By all means disclose yours, so we can reach a few conclusions.

    (And, while you're at it, let's hear from that pretend barrister who can't even spell 'practise' properly).

    (and those liars who claim to have voted 'remain' last time, when it's obvious to a blind man that they are Brexiters.)
     
    red likes this.
  15. Walterp

    Walterp Member

    Location:
    Pembrokeshire
    The hard truth is that doing stupid things is not the preserve of the stupid - look at you, and me, both of us have done stupid things in our time, but neither of us is stupid.

    And so with the Nissan workers.

    But they are not stupid, either - just like you, and me, they will not make the same mistake next time.

    (A different one, maybe...)
     
  16. Danllan

    Danllan Member

    Location:
    Sir Gar / Carms
    BSc(Hons); Dip. Law; Barrister. I 'escaped' farming and then came back when I realised my mistake, and could afford to... :whistle:

    I know of lots on here with a degree, most not in Ag. Of my five immediate farming neighbours, two have degrees, one Ag. and one in history. In the wider area, most of those on the bigger farms have degrees,' HA don't you know' ;), most of the smaller ones don't.


    I am guilty of typos Wally, I admit that but, unlike you, not lies and hypocrisy, nor moral cowardice*... Hey @alex04w he's calling me - in fact us - liars again... someone irrelevant has written something that doesn't matter, oh how will we survive... :rolleyes:


    *All my offers to you are still open, but you never do or will come up to proof. Funny little fellow. :)
     
    Old McDonald likes this.
  17. linga

    linga Member

    Location:
    Ceredigion
    I simply posed the question.
    What you did and what I did to achieve our present positions are hardly grounds to generalise surely ?
     
  18. Bomber_Harris

    Bomber_Harris Member

    Location:
    London
    strangely enough I wasn't considering Brexit when I asked the question. I don't think it would be possible to obtain sufficient data to do a study on what percentage of farmers voted Leave and if there was co-relation between higher and lower education so it's pointless even debating it

    the question was literally a passing wonderment triggered by driving past what looked like a magnificent and enormous campus dedicated to farming

    but do carry on :)
     
  19. The Agrarian

    The Agrarian Member

    Location:
    Co Antrim
    BAgr from Queen's Belfast 2001

    I do know quite a few full-time farmers with degrees, though most of those degrees are actually in or around agriculture or veterinary. But the majority do not, as you suspect. I wouldn't like to put a number on it. And I wouldn't like to link the success of the farms to the degree either, though it's unlikely to be a hindrance.
     
  20. Walterp

    Walterp Member

    Location:
    Pembrokeshire
    That's very shy of you.

    The problem is, now, that if you don't disclose your info we can never judge - we will just be left to assume that you had to inherit a place (in society, as well in the countryside) rather than earn it.
     

Share This Page