Kuhn FBP 3135 v Mc Hale Fusion

Discussion in 'Machinery' started by icanshootwell, May 23, 2019.

  1. stevedave

    stevedave Member

    The wrapper will speed up the table to give you 5 layers is that right.
     
  2. Selectamatic

    Selectamatic Member

    Location:
    North Wales
    You can’t unless you have a Kuhn. :)
     
  3. Boohoo

    Boohoo Member

    Location:
    Newtownabbey
    3D wrapping is a good system and I'm assuming Kuhn have improved on it since the Vicon days when there were complaints that it was slow, but I can't see anyone in my area moving away from Fusions.
     
  4. Boohoo

    Boohoo Member

    Location:
    Newtownabbey
    It slows down the table for the first rotation to give a 67% overlap rather than a 50% overlap.
     
    Selectamatic likes this.
  5. stevedave

    stevedave Member

    Ok but most people now want at least 6 layers, we are now getting asked more often to do 8 layers and very rarely 4 layers.
     
    kill likes this.
  6. James

    James Member

    Location:
    Comber, Down
    Same here most want 6 now only dairy farmers want 4
     
  7. Jenks6910

    Jenks6910 Member

    Location:
    West Wales
    The 3D wrapping system on the Kuhn definitely makes a difference. Carting bales from field last week were a mchale Fusion and Kuhn FBP worked side by side. Birds had been at both sets of bales, you could see grass tufts been pulled out from fusion bales everywhere, were as the Kuhn bales hardly had a mark on them due to more film on the round of the bale (were you need it). You could also see the difference in the better shape and weight of the Kuhn bales over the mchale bales. Mchale is a good proven baler (Iv used them a lot), but the Kuhn is definitely one to give it a run for its money, if not beat it in my opinion.
     
    bumkin, kill, mtx.jag and 1 other person like this.
  8. Mickeymatbro

    Mickeymatbro Member

    Had the fusion before fbp kuhn and I moved purely because of problems I had with the mchale and in my area mchale backup not as good as the kuhn dealer , in fact there is no comparison between the two in terms of backup!
    But running the kuhn last year on plastic ( not film ) like the mchale has I could see the difference in bale quality, baler also has far superior intake system especially notable in short grass , still packs it in very tightly
    As jenks6910 said the protection on the bales in the field is noticeable side by side with fusion and bales holding there shape , would tell me there is more grass in the bales that hold there shape
    Ps they were my bales jenks6910 was moving
     
    davedb, kill, mtx.jag and 2 others like this.
  9. Boohoo

    Boohoo Member

    Location:
    Newtownabbey
    With the Kuhn you could do 7 layers. One rotation of the bale at 67% overlap to apply 3 layers then 2 more rotations at 50% to apply another 4 layers.
     
  10. Boohoo

    Boohoo Member

    Location:
    Newtownabbey
    The ones with the higher quality grass want to apply the least wrap?
     
  11. Mickeymatbro

    Mickeymatbro Member

    Think the dairy farmers are using the bales up within 6 months before they open there clamps
     
    mtx.jag likes this.
  12. Galcam

    Galcam Member

    But are you comparing like for like? I mean a Fusion 3 equipped same as Kuhn With 1000 speed gearbox, same pickup width and camless and are operators applying NRF at same stretch, running on same density etc. Are the bale weights been checked as opposed to perception? I had my kuhn out yesterday and the noise and rattling out of it and it’s only done 17k bales would drive u mad, had the fusion out in the afternoon and played iPhone through radio and chillaxed. I don’t think Mchales have anything to worry about Kuhn. I think Fusion are market leaders for a reason and that is they are designed to handle tough rough terrain with heavy crops. They are not perfect especially in the NRF area but I would not touch anything else unless it was say 40% cheaper. A new Fusion is 94k depending on spec, well that Kuhn would want to be max 60k for me to bother changing from something that works.
     
  13. James

    James Member

    Location:
    Comber, Down
    Won't spend the money on the extra wrap
     
  14. James

    James Member

    Location:
    Comber, Down
    Not always some will be 18 months before use. Must be cause they're used to lots of waste from clamps :rolleyes:
     
  15. Boohoo

    Boohoo Member

    Location:
    Newtownabbey
    They've got too much money so don't worry about wasting a bit of silage
     
  16. Barmyfarmer

    Barmyfarmer Member

    Or much younger leafy grass with not the same strong stem that can puncture wrap as more mature grass?
     
  17. Boohoo

    Boohoo Member

    Location:
    Newtownabbey
    What spec is a 94k Fusion? Gold plated? Or are you not in the UK?
     
    Chae1 likes this.
  18. Mickeymatbro

    Mickeymatbro Member

    They run cling film over bales the mchale system kuhn run same film front as back 750mm rolls
    I don't need to weigh them when a bale holds its shape and next to it is fusion running max density and bales lost shape , mchale will always out sell everything else , all I'm saying is im happy I made the move and so are my customers
     
  19. Mickeymatbro

    Mickeymatbro Member

    on a bale weight I have compared in straw kuhn 230kg against fusion VARIO ( belt should really be the superior in straw ) vario 240kg the fusion 3 would be 200kg If you're lucky
     
    KB6930 likes this.
  20. stevedave

    stevedave Member

    We have found it the other way round with dealers backup from Mchale and the dealer has been first class where as the Kuhn dealer has not been great in the past. We have never run a Kuhn baler but have run other Kuhn kit and we were happy with it but the local dealer put us off Kuhn for as long as they sell it. If Kuhn was with the old dealer we would still probably be running Kuhn mowers and firt spreader and maybe more Kuhn kit.
     

Share This Page