Pound for Pound worst tractor resale values!!

[bluegreen]

We all know Fendt are top of the tree but whose in the relegation zone? It strikes me that CASE/ New Holland are popular because they aren't the most expensive but traditionally they have good secondhand residuals and demand.
Claas and Valtra are good machines but I notice their residuals aren't so good secondhand, maybe that's just in my area. Opinions?

 

[Sharny dubs]

Where have you seen cheap 2nd hand valtras? Usually the command good money even at higher hours due to generally good reliability. Depends more than u would realise on local trends and fashions. I think claas would be one of the worst. Prices new would be up there with john Deere in bigger models but the used values would be much less. Unless you are trading in for another claas in which case the claas dealer will value it high to make it look like value to change.

 

[daveydiesel1]

Belarus? Armatrac? Practically unsaleable second hand lol

 

[Greythundercloudys]

Claas, zetor, not great. Landini. I used to think deutz aswell

 

[Lincsman]

Sort of depends how you look at it, a Fendt might not lose too much Percentage wise, but money wise it can lose more than a very cheap one costs and is scrapped.

 

[teslacoils]

Big horsepower NH dropped money like nothing I've seen. Second hand prices for anything modern (adblu) with high hp out of warranty are awful.

 

[texelburger]

Sort of depends how you look at it, a Fendt might not lose too much Percentage wise, but money wise it can lose more than a very cheap one costs and is scrapped.

Very true it's all relative .

 

[Drillman]

Last 2 tractors I sold the depreciation was none existent.

 

[Nearly]

Last 2 tractors I sold the depreciation was none existent.

Bet you can't do it again.

 

[Drillman]

Bet you can't do it again.

Hmmm depends how long I keep em?

 

[Lincsman]

Big horsepower NH dropped money like nothing I've seen. Second hand prices for anything modern (adblu) with high hp out of warranty are awful.

Or were they sold with a big discount and lost little? hard to know unless you are the person who bought it new.

 

[SilliamWhale]

Most of the time the most expensive ones will lose the most money.

 

[stevedave]

We lost more money on NewHollands than anything else but to be fair the cost to change any make is becoming crippling at the moment. We would have kept the NH but it was out of warranty and I wasn't confident in having to pick up the bill myself.

 

[kiwi pom]

Unless you're the one buying and selling or you some how get to see all the deals, how do you know what's good and bad?
Surely we're not going by list price and the advertised second hand prices?

 

[glasshouse]

They are all too fecking dear

 

[ARW]

Recent McCormick?
who wants them second hand?
It’s not what you paid for it or what you sell it for it’s the cost to swap which is the actual cost.
You could run new jd’s then swap for a new class and get what looks like a great deal, however swapping the class back to jd will cost you double!

 

[marshbarn]

We all know Fendt are top of the tree but whose in the relegation zone? It strikes me that CASE/ New Holland are popular because they aren't the most expensive but traditionally they have good secondhand residuals and demand.
Claas and Valtra are good machines but I notice their residuals aren't so good secondhand, maybe that's just in my area. Opinions?

I dont think fendt can be concidered good on depreciation, There was a fendt in the classified thread a couple of months back that was 140 k new and trying to sell at 100k 12 months old 1000hours no takers .
lossing 40 k must hurt anybody

 

[thorpe]

Recent McCormick?
who wants them second hand?
It’s not what you paid for it or what you sell it for it’s the cost to swap which is the actual cost.
You could run new jd’s then swap for a new class and get what looks like a great deal, however swapping the class back to jd will cost you double!

why on earth would you want to go back to jd?

 

[Fendtbro]

I dont think fendt can be concidered good on depreciation, There was a fendt in the classified thread a couple of months back that was 140 k new and trying to sell at 100k 12 months old 1000hours no takers .
lossing 40 k must hurt anybody

The first 1000 hours will hurt on any make.. you have to get 6000-8000 hours to level out deprecation.

 

[Adeptandy]

Anything I have that I want to trade in generally