The rise of biodynamic farming: a return to 'the way farmers farmed for millennia'

The Guardian 5 March 2017

When John Chester, a filmmaker from California, quit his job to become a farmer, he didn’t do it out of a desire to “feed the world”. Instead, he says: “I’m trying to feed my neighbors – and if everyone did that, we would be able to replicate this.”

He is referring to Apricot Lane Farms, a 213-acre biodynamic and organic farm in Moorpark, California, that Chester runs with his wife, Molly. The couple nurtures 100 different types of vegetables, 75 varieties of stone fruit, and countless animal residents: Scottish highland cattle, pigs, chickens, sheep, ducks, hens, horses and livestock dogs. Last year, Apricot Lane Farms was recognized by the National Wildlife Federation and the North American Butterfly Association for supporting so much wildlife – not a recognition typically given to farms.

Apricot Lane is part of a growing movement in biodynamic farming. The number of biodynamic farms in the US is rapidly increasing, according to Elizabeth Candelario, co-director of Demeter USA, the nonprofit certifier of biodynamic farms and consumer products in the US. According to Demeter, the total acreage for biodynamic farming in the US increased by 16% last year, totaling 21,791 acres.

Earlier this year, Demeter began collecting topsoil samples from biodynamic farms. This will help the organization determine if the soil quality is improving year after year on certified biodynamic farms. According to Candelario, Demeter is the only national farming organization implementing this practice. “This will provide a tool for farmers who continue to focus on building healthy soil, and give voice to power about biodynamic agriculture’s role in mitigating the impacts of climate change,” she says.

So what distinguishes biodynamic farming from organic? Austrian philosopher Rudolf Steiner, the godfather of organic and biodynamic farming, encouraged farmers to look to the cosmos before planting and harvesting crops. The biodynamic calendar is based on the positioning of the stars and the moon, meaning a seasonal crop cycle. Many biodynamic farmers utilize the lunar calendar, although it is not a requirement for certification.

The National Organic Program (Nop) standard forms the base to the Demeter standard – so if it’s not allowed in organic, it’s not allowed in biodynamic. If a farm is certified biodynamic, it means it has met the requirements of organic, with some additional measures. For example, while organic permits imported organic fertilizers and pesticides, biodynamic requires that a farm system itself produce its own fertility – meaning compost and nutrients – as much as possible through the integration of livestock and the rotation of crops. There are limits to the amount that can be imported from the outside – for example, no more than 36lbs of nitrogen per acre, per year.

Also, while organic certification allows for organic feed imported to the farm from anywhere in the world, biodynamic requires 50% of livestock feed be grown on the farm. Biodynamic also requires that a farm set aside 10% of the total farm acreage for biodiversity, and strive for a balanced predator/prey relationship.

Where a conventional farm would bring in synthetic fertilizers, and an organic farm would substitute inputs that are allowed under the Nop, a biodynamic farmer would think: “Why is my farm needing this additional fertility, and how can I come up with a solution out of the farm system itself instead of being imported from the outside?”

“Biodynamic agriculture treats the farm like a living organism, self-contained and self-sustainable,” Candelario says. “Biodynamic is what organic farming has emerged from. It’s the way farmers have farmed for millennia, before the advent of industrial agriculture.”

For example, on Chester’s farm, the wildlife is vital in dealing with infestations. Last year, the farm had a slug problem. “I could have poured Sluggo and that would have killed them off,” Chester says. “But instead, I let the wildlife sort it out. As a result, I’m producing duck eggs that have been enriched by an escargot diet.”

580.jpg

Molly and John Chester, who run Apricot Lane Farms. Photograph: Yvette Roman
Biodynamic principles were first introduced in the US after 1924, when Rudolf Steiner first delivered his agricultural lectures. In 1938, the Biodynamic Association was established, making it the oldest sustainable agriculture nonprofit organization in North America. Still, there are only about 300 certified biodynamic farms in the US today, compared to 21,781 certified organic operations, representing a growth of almost 12% between 2014-2015, according to data released in 2016 by the Agricultural Marketing Service’s National Organic Program. This is the highest growth rate since 2008, with an increase of nearly 300% since the count began in 2002. The total retail market for organic products is now valued at more than $39bn in the US, compared to $75bn worldwide.


Candelario says the reason for the slower growth in biodynamic farms is that although its principles were adopted in the 1930s, they’ve been slow to catch on. It was really winemakers that caught on first. “Winemakers couldn’t help but notice that some of the finest wines in the world are made from grapes grown in biodynamic vineyards. Vineyard and winery adoption has occurred so quickly that [the US] now has the third largest number of biodynamic vineyards and wineries in the world, following France and Italy.”

Now, Candelario says the natural food industry is beginning to recognize that “you can’t have a sustainable business model if the farming that stands behind your products is unsustainable”. More than a dozen US food companies, including Republic of Tea, Back to The Roots, Amy’s Kitchen, Lakewood Juices and Lundberg Family Farms, are now sourcing from biodynamic farms, citing commitments to sustainable practices.

Last year, Demeter worked with more than 50 US brands to bring biodynamic products to the market. Errol Schweizer can attest to the demand; he was the lead merchandiser and negotiator at Whole Foods for nearly a decade and now consults at numerous health food retailers across the US. When Schweizer joined Whole Foods, the company was carrying few biodynamic brands. Schweizer added more to the shelves, not only because of the farming practices but because of one basic test: taste.

“Customers want it, even if they don’t recognize the biodynamic certification on a box,” he said. “What they want is food that tastes good and is grown ethically.”


FacebookTwitterPinterest
Apricot Lane Farms sells its grass-pastured, soy-free eggs to local health food stores such asErewhon. Photograph: Apricot Lane Farms
Biodynamic foods are more nutritious than conventionally farmed vegetables and fruits, according to research. Like organic farming, biodynamic farming prohibits the use of chemical pesticides, allowing plants to produce more of their own antioxidants to fight damage. These antioxidants are not only beneficial to humans, but they also impact taste and flavor, resulting in more flavorful food.

But, while it may be healthier and taste better, critics of biodynamic farming raise questions about its ability to feed the masses. Nikhil Arora runs Oakland-based Back to the Roots, which sells biodynamic cereal. Arora sources the wheat from Fred Kirshenmann’s 1800-acre farm in Windsor, North Dakota, which is certified organic and biodynamic. Kirshenmann was an early adopter of Steiner’s methodology; in 1975, the farm was organic but by 1981, he had become one of the first biodynamic farms in the country.

Launched in January 2016, Back to the Roots biodynamic cereal sells in Whole Foods and Krogers for about $5 a box, on par with health food cereals such as Kashi and Nature’s Path. The company’s cereals are also in 2300 schools across the country. The demand has been tricky to manage. “We want to scale but we have to be mindful of how much supply we have,” Arora says. “We’re working directly with the farmer, not a commodities market. We pre-purchase the wheat before he even harvests it. So it’s a different model.”

Apricot Lane Farms likes to keep it local, selling eggs to local health food stores such as Erewhon. Some of the vegetables and fruits are sold to LA restaurants and the rest are sold at specialty markets as well as online.

“What people don’t understand is that biodynamic farming is about responding to the farm, living, breathing it,” Chester says. “If you have a problem, you have to think of three solutions that come from the farm itself. Those so-called problems are part of the art of farming, which has been lost in this rat race to produce cheap food.”

Chester argues that buyers have to change the equation by voting with their purchases. Candelario agrees.

“Consumers need to continue to demand transparency in the food they purchase and support the brands, and the farms, that are bringing products to market in the most ecological way possible. The beautiful short term reward in all of this is that our food is only as good as the farming that stands behind it.”

https://www.theguardian.com/sustain...riculture-organic-food-production-environment
 

PSQ

Member
Arable Farmer
'the way farmers farmed for millennia'


Hmmm. I was shown around a 'Biodynamic' farm about 20 years ago, and left a few hours later with the sense that the people involved were completely hoodwinked by Rudolf Steiner's 'Spiritual Science' cult. It is not "the way farmers have farmed for millennia", but a cod scientific re-imagination of 'paganistic' rituals designed to reconnect farming with imagined 'ancient practices'.
I have no doubt that farmers in ancient times maybe did some whacky stuff to appease the farming gods, but I doubt that Steiner's approach of 'filling old horns with dung and burying them on a full moon' have any real practical benefits to modern agriculture, organic or otherwise.
 

KMA

Member
Location
Dumfriesshire
If customers wanted it that much they'd pay a premium, they don't, end of story.

"I've failed miserably in the city, I know I'll buy a farm, watch granny suck eggs, give it a fancy new name, publicise it, dream up a certification scheme and charge and make my fortune from the certification scheme and lecture tours."
 

The_Swede

Member
Arable Farmer
Be very interesting to hear others views on this, I'm with @PSQ , the cosmic stuff is just too far 'out there' for my taste and relative scientific sensibilities - and I would consider myself pretty open minded especially where soil processes and alternative production systems are concerned!
 
I'm pretty opened minded and beleive in a lot of it there will be a allotment holders who swear by the magnetic force of the moon and I am no way in a position able to dismiss any of this. Well apart from the crystals and the spiritual stuff (but hey whats wrong with a bit of spiritual perhaps its something we could all benefit from?). The ways are not that wacky these are using holistic methods of management, less plastic (hence cow horn as a natural material - compost tea), organic, community growing, recycling nutrients, herbal lays, working with the lunar calendar. Conventional farmers wouldnt have any of it and there are no impartial scientists out there to prove otherwise. I also beleive just because someone/something is different slating them for being weird, wacky or losing the plot proves that we cant bare for anyone to be different from us and sadly shows our intolerance.

There is also a lot of biodynamic wine growers out there so its working for them????

Being organic here, going down the more holistic management, permaculture, working more to enhance nature and getting the community involved in what we are doing as a local farm is surely partly 'biodynamic' anyway?
 

PSQ

Member
Arable Farmer
I'm pretty opened minded and beleive in a lot of it there will be a allotment holders who swear by the magnetic force of the moon and I am no way in a position able to dismiss any of this. Well apart from the crystals and the spiritual stuff (but hey whats wrong with a bit of spiritual perhaps its something we could all benefit from?). The ways are not that wacky these are using holistic methods of management, less plastic (hence cow horn as a natural material - compost tea), organic, community growing, recycling nutrients, herbal lays, working with the lunar calendar. Conventional farmers wouldnt have any of it and there are no impartial scientists out there to prove otherwise. I also beleive just because someone/something is different slating them for being weird, wacky or losing the plot proves that we cant bare for anyone to be different from us and sadly shows our intolerance.

There is also a lot of biodynamic wine growers out there so its working for them????

Being organic here, going down the more holistic management, permaculture, working more to enhance nature and getting the community involved in what we are doing as a local farm is surely partly 'biodynamic' anyway?

Well, I'm glad you're open minded. Here's a diagram from the Oregon Biodynamic group to show you how it works:


fig4-2.gif
 
I'm pretty opened minded and beleive in a lot of it there will be a allotment holders who swear by the magnetic force of the moon and I am no way in a position able to dismiss any of this. Well apart from the crystals and the spiritual stuff (but hey whats wrong with a bit of spiritual perhaps its something we could all benefit from?). The ways are not that wacky these are using holistic methods of management, less plastic (hence cow horn as a natural material - compost tea), organic, community growing, recycling nutrients, herbal lays, working with the lunar calendar. Conventional farmers wouldnt have any of it and there are no impartial scientists out there to prove otherwise. I also beleive just because someone/something is different slating them for being weird, wacky or losing the plot proves that we cant bare for anyone to be different from us and sadly shows our intolerance.

There is also a lot of biodynamic wine growers out there so its working for them????

Being organic here, going down the more holistic management, permaculture, working more to enhance nature and getting the community involved in what we are doing as a local farm is surely partly 'biodynamic' anyway?
Lot of time for many of the organic ways but Demeter and biodynamic are in the 'just visiting' category if you ask me.
They are so convinced that they are right but really barking mad.
Biodynamic wine is popular true but the better vines are on shitter hungry soil so lack of fertility from biodynamic helps.
 
Im not sure whether some of these world class wineries are on poor ground this excerpt is taken from Forbes in 2016.

“In France, biodynamic wine certifications are growing very fast, about 10% to 15% increase a year for the past 10 years,” she said. “This year it was 20%. At first it was in the Alsace region, and now I’m seeing it more in Bordeaux and all other wine regions.”

With biodynamics, agricultural landscapes are viewed as intertwined ecosystems to be regarded whole, rather than as a collection of disparate components—soil, sunlight, grapes—considered separately. The aim of the principles is to create healthy self-sufficient ecosystems, to farm with respect to cycles of the sun and moon, and to maintain equilibrium between pests that are predators and prey.


“Of course biodynamics will increase,” said Mathilde Bocquillon, a guide who leads curious tourists around the vineyards of Château Pontet-Canet in the Médoc region of Bordeaux. “In the Médoc, Pontet-Canet is still the only château to be biodynamic. But today a lot of winemakers want to meet our estate manager to understand his philosophy and work. We respect biodiversity and prepare infusions which are not dangerous compared to pesticides.”

https://www.forbes.com/sites/tmullen/2016/10/26/why-biodynamic-wine-is-the-future/#4226e1d67141
 

Tim W

Member
Livestock Farmer
Location
Wiltshire
There are some very impressive biodynamic farms about (Tablehurst etc) which produce well by any standards--yield/economic etc
I can handle the moon phase bit and I think trying to be self sustainable in terms of farm fertility etc is great
But I do struggle with the formulas/horn burying etc

I once went to look at a farm owned by the Biodynamic Ass. with a view to renting it ---I was interviewed by the secretary and treasurer of the ass. and neither of them could explain the thinking behind the potions/horns etc
My conclusion was that it was a belief system they had chosen to take on board and I came away with the impression it was drivel
Always willing to be educated though if anyone can explain the whys and wherefores ?
 

York

Member
Location
D-Berlin
sorry, I see more poor biodynamic farms over here than good once.
If they would have needed to comply to the AU Biodynamic standart in certification process,
see here:
http://demeter.org.au/application.htm
To receive Australian DEMETER Bio-Dynamic Certification a farm must demonstrate soil structure development
I wonder how many of them would be certified over here in the "homeland of Steiner".
In NL however there is a run on biodynamic farming. Why? because farm value is increased quite a bit so the next generation, which takes the farm over, has to pay a much higher price for it. Most conversions are done by farmers which are at the "landing stripp" or retirement.
York-Th.
 
I think trying to be self s
ustainable in terms of farm fertility etc is great

So do I, but it is impossible. Itis possible to mine whatever minerals are in the soil (for an unknown period of time) but eventually something would run short. Successful farmers bring in nutrients - go back to Sir Albert Howard, Newman Turner or currently Iain Tolhurst. They know it is not possible to produce all your own needs.
 
They are so convinced that they are right but really barking mad.

A quote from me about Lady Eve Balfour:
Lady Eve was firmly of the opinion that organic farming with Indore Compost was the answer, but she was prepared to let her views be tested, realising that other biological farmers were not open minded for she wrote “When they become convinced that their biological approach to the soil is right in the interests of the soil itself, any soil treatment which runs counter to this becomes such heresy to them that they cease to be capable of a detached and purely scientific attitude to the problems involved.”
 

linga

Member
Location
Ceredigion
for example, no more than 36lbs of nitrogen per acre, per year.

Also, while organic certification allows for organic feed imported to the farm from anywhere in the world, biodynamic requires 50% of livestock feed be grown on the farm.

So it wouldnt be allowed if I wanted to import feed from neighbouring farm however if I rented or bought that farm I could use that produce on my existing farm ? !
 

York

Member
Location
D-Berlin
A quote from me about Lady Eve Balfour:
Lady Eve was firmly of the opinion that organic farming with Indore Compost was the answer, but she was prepared to let her views be tested, realising that other biological farmers were not open minded for she wrote “When they become convinced that their biological approach to the soil is right in the interests of the soil itself, any soil treatment which runs counter to this becomes such heresy to them that they cease to be capable of a detached and purely scientific attitude to the problems involved.”
very well put.
Just give them some time. It's interesting to compare what Demeter International is allowing & what Demeter is allowing on inputs. Demeter is much more "down to Earth" than Demeter Germany. Have just a discussion about S sources.
When they base their decisions on Chroma testing I start to have some questions. As the outcome of a Chroma testing is also influenced on the spiritual "set up" of the person doing the Chroma. Asked one of the leading Chroma people over here to do a comparison us both taking the sample from the same tube, same time & location to see how the result would be. His reply was: "don't need to do, you have a negative attitude on Choma which will change the output".
http://www.biodynamic-research.net/ras/rm/pfm
However as their are more and more farmers going to Biodynamics, in NL also due to increase land value, there are more and more outsiders which have not inhaled the spiritual side tooo much. I expect some changes.
York-Th.
 

SFI - What % were you taking out of production?

  • 0 %

    Votes: 103 40.6%
  • Up to 25%

    Votes: 93 36.6%
  • 25-50%

    Votes: 39 15.4%
  • 50-75%

    Votes: 5 2.0%
  • 75-100%

    Votes: 3 1.2%
  • 100% I’ve had enough of farming!

    Votes: 11 4.3%

May Event: The most profitable farm diversification strategy 2024 - Mobile Data Centres

  • 1,315
  • 23
With just a internet connection and a plug socket you too can join over 70 farms currently earning up to £1.27 ppkw ~ 201% ROI

Register Here: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/the-mo...2024-mobile-data-centres-tickets-871045770347

Tuesday, May 21 · 10am - 2pm GMT+1

Location: Village Hotel Bury, Rochdale Road, Bury, BL9 7BQ

The Farming Forum has teamed up with the award winning hardware manufacturer Easy Compute to bring you an educational talk about how AI and blockchain technology is helping farmers to diversify their land.

Over the past 7 years, Easy Compute have been working with farmers, agricultural businesses, and renewable energy farms all across the UK to help turn leftover space into mini data centres. With...
Top