Using a Penetrometer for soil compaction

Firstly I get the instrument but I dont understand the results. I cant find anything on this. I have searched and searched.

Been around a field that needs serious work reseeding, lime etc. Been asked to push the penetrometer into the ground all around the field to gauge depth. To the red line where compaction is 30cm on average. The soil has good structure and on a gentle hill.

So we need to reseed this asap where do we go on what machinery is best on this? Im clueless dont get subsoiler, ploughing, mole etc all out of my lil zone. Im not a machinery girl.

I cant find anything on depths on when issues are a concern or am I totally confused?

Help
 

Hesstondriver

Member
Livestock Farmer
Location
Huntingdon
Dig a hole with a spade , try to keep one side upright and smooth, then you will either see the compact area in the profile or feel it by pushing knife in say every 5 cm , I would expect that you will find different levels of difficulty in digging as you go down through the profile
 

Guleesh

Member
Livestock Farmer
Location
Isle of Skye
Firstly I get the instrument but I dont understand the results. I cant find anything on this. I have searched and searched.

Been around a field that needs serious work reseeding, lime etc. Been asked to push the penetrometer into the ground all around the field to gauge depth. To the red line where compaction is 30cm on average. The soil has good structure and on a gentle hill.

So we need to reseed this asap where do we go on what machinery is best on this? Im clueless dont get subsoiler, ploughing, mole etc all out of my lil zone. Im not a machinery girl.

I cant find anything on depths on when issues are a concern or am I totally confused?

Help
I'm not machinery orientated so can't help much there, 30cm before compaction seems quite deep to me (by standards here at least) Are you planning to do the works yourself? or get a contractor in?
 

som farmer

Member
Livestock Farmer
Location
somerset
completely disagree with above, we can spot the compacted areas here, by eye, but, to be fair, soils differ from farm to farm, we get a lot of surface compaction by cows, in a wet time. The easiest thing to do, is to dig a hole, and see what is there, how far down, do the grass roots go, is there any horizontal lines through, this can tell you, if you have a pan or not. The pressure instrument, shows you, the easy bits, and the hard bits, as you push it down, and gives you an idea there may be a problem. Digging your hole will tell you. If you are getting 'resistance' at 30 cm, unless the field has been heavily, and frequently worked, that seems to be rather deep, for a pan, dig your hole, and if not sure, ask someone who knows, Here, it's dead easy, you get a horizontal layer of red oxide deposit, so no doubt, go in with the sub-soiler, surface pan, aerator, soil structure, to us, is very important, the better your structure, the more it produces, the more profit potential.
 

Kiwi Pete

Member
Livestock Farmer
Just push it in when the soil to be tested is at field capacity or below. You can generally speaking feel where your roots stop with a standard rod but a penetrometer puts numbers to it.
Some huge learning opportunities exist, eg where to concentrate stock in future or specific areas to rip.
 
I meant now. Is it permanent pasture or is it cultivated land
Pasture but had it.
completely disagree with above, we can spot the compacted areas here, by eye, but, to be fair, soils differ from farm to farm, we get a lot of surface compaction by cows, in a wet time. The easiest thing to do, is to dig a hole, and see what is there, how far down, do the grass roots go, is there any horizontal lines through, this can tell you, if you have a pan or not. The pressure instrument, shows you, the easy bits, and the hard bits, as you push it down, and gives you an idea there may be a problem. Digging your hole will tell you. If you are getting 'resistance' at 30 cm, unless the field has been heavily, and frequently worked, that seems to be rather deep, for a pan, dig your hole, and if not sure, ask someone who knows, Here, it's dead easy, you get a horizontal layer of red oxide deposit, so no doubt, go in with the sub-soiler, surface pan, aerator, soil structure, to us, is very important, the better your structure, the more it produces, the more profit potential.
Yeah I did with to see the roots (and worms) and they are shallow and there is little grass to talk of. The soil is good it has loose structure 15 - 20cm no lines but didnt go down to 30. I will do that later.
 

Bury the Trash

Member
Mixed Farmer
There are some people (me included) that says a lot of compaction is overstated and there's never been much evidence that it is a yield harmer....
Just spotted yr post.
That's actually what I've thought for a long time.
Not really sure why other than gut feeling sort of thing, trouble is it's made such an issue of one feels one should take heed and do some remedial..... I never do tho :sneaky:
 
Just spotted yr post.
That's actually what I've thought for a long time.
Not really sure why other than gut feeling sort of thing, trouble is it's made such an issue of one feels one should take heed and do some remedial..... I never do tho :sneaky:

Sells stuff. Remember most "experts" have never grown a crop...

Certainly lots of people making subsoilers etc won't have grown a crop.
 

Jerry

Member
Mixed Farmer
Location
Devon
Just spotted yr post.
That's actually what I've thought for a long time.
Not really sure why other than gut feeling sort of thing, trouble is it's made such an issue of one feels one should take heed and do some remedial..... I never do tho :sneaky:

Soil here goes "tight" as it dries, whether it is cultivated or perm pasture thats not seen a tractor in 20 years.

Im having enough fun treading in electric fence posts at the moment let alone a potentiometer.....give it an inch of rain (yes I know Im joking).....and it will be a different matter!
 

som farmer

Member
Livestock Farmer
Location
somerset
If the compaction is at 30cm deep I wouldn't worry about sorting it.
compaction here, can be a game changer, usual plough pan is around 8-10'' as shown by a line of red ochre, but we can very easily cap ground, whether by cows, or overworking, pre drilling, always say when we are 2 cultivations from an ideal seedbed, thats the time to drill, you then end up 'just right'. To many times having to re-plough/cultivate, because heavy rain has caused it to set like concrete ! The aerator, has been a really good implement here, yet not far away, rubbish ! I am hoping, that by using non turning cultivator, we will increase the soil structures ability, to retain more water, and worms and bugs, fungi etc, and increasing fertility
 

Bury the Trash

Member
Mixed Farmer
Soil here goes "tight" as it dries, whether it is cultivated or perm pasture thats not seen a tractor in 20 years.

Im having enough fun treading in electric fence posts at the moment let alone a potentiometer.....give it an inch of rain (yes I know Im joking).....and it will be a different matter!
Yes similar here devil of a job to.get fence posts in the ground atm and no theres no rain about I'm fairly sure.
 

SFI - What % were you taking out of production?

  • 0 %

    Votes: 79 42.2%
  • Up to 25%

    Votes: 65 34.8%
  • 25-50%

    Votes: 30 16.0%
  • 50-75%

    Votes: 3 1.6%
  • 75-100%

    Votes: 3 1.6%
  • 100% I’ve had enough of farming!

    Votes: 7 3.7%

Red Tractor drops launch of green farming scheme amid anger from farmers

  • 1,289
  • 1
As reported in Independent


quote: “Red Tractor has confirmed it is dropping plans to launch its green farming assurance standard in April“

read the TFF thread here: https://thefarmingforum.co.uk/index.php?threads/gfc-was-to-go-ahead-now-not-going-ahead.405234/
Top