Lots of veg growers packing up

What's Brexit got to do with it? Did they export?
I wonder why they stopped and what they're going to do now. Maybe they've made their money and want an easier life?
Unless you are both blind and deaf you must realise that getting a supply of pickers and packers has been severely impacted by our political masters and their pseudo democratic dogma.
 

7610 super q

Never Forgotten
Honorary Member
The other thing is the veg market is fickle. Caulies always seem to be a glut, or shortage. We grew leeks on an off for 20 years. Never made much money. One year we made £80 / acre. Neighbours were doing twice that growing SB :X3:. Whilst grain prices aren't up to much either, it's easier sitting on a combine than cutting cabbage...........
 

kiwi pom

Member
Location
canterbury NZ
Ah but Boris has an answer for that
Robotics are going to save the day
Lol
I think it will solve a lot of problems. Having a steady trickle of seasonal foreign labour doesn't encourage innovation. Turn the taps off and you have to look elsewhere.
Unless you are both blind and deaf you must realise that getting a supply of pickers and packers has been severely impacted by our political masters and their pseudo democratic dogma.
I'm sure it has. I'm not sure a business model that requires casual foreign labour is a great idea though, especially if the end product can be imported cheaper.
That importing may end of course which will then force change.
 

Lowland1

Member
Mixed Farmer
I concur Rob. But you run a business and its no good having folk work for you unless they want to - as they will not perform and will not be thoughtful enough, even if it is just 'picking veg and fruit'. I do hate this middle class term I hear and read in the media 'just picking fruit and veg', as it is a skilled manual task.

I concur that we have told a generation manual work is beneath them. But I ponder if that is totally a new phenomenon. My family are ex farm labourers. I say ex as none of my cousins, nephews and nieces are involved in Agriculture. I can recall my mother and aunts 55 years ago determined we would all not be 'slogging around in the cold mud'. My brother for example is a welder by trade. Though he is driving HGV at the moment.

But I take your point about manual work - there is manual work and manual work. Cheers,
When i first came to Kenya you just shouted and a gang of people appeared to dig or pick now whilst you can still get people they aren’t as good as they were. People want to work in offices or shops or warehouses here too there probably aren’t the choices of jobs or unemployment benefits but people have smart phones and computers and they know there’s an easier life out there. Everyone wants their kids to go to University so they don’t have the same drudgery as they do. It’s worldwide
 

Bobby D

Member
Don't forget farmers are public too. Not many produce all their own food, so they'll see the difference at the shops too.
This is something farmers seem to forget. Grand you'll be making more profit and hence be able to afford the increases in food costs. But at the end of the day you're still paying the extra cost that the man on the street is forking out for. Going back to the old ways of a garden full of veg for eight months of the year, saving your own seed from said veg and keeping costs low/out of it is the only way to really save money here.
 

SteveHudd

Member
The demand for veg isn’t what it was. Growers are fighting over a smaller market and the supermarkets want it as cheap as possible. The supermarket specs have widened to keep the price low. Growers have fought for extra buisness for economies of scale. It’s common for one grower to supply a whole supermarket, sometimes several. This means veg is sat about on transport and in the supply chain for days.

The result is crap old veg in store with no flavour. New varieties have been bred for yield and shelf life often at the expense of flavour. Its a vicious circle as less people pick it up. Less demand. Less market share. Lower quality.

A lot of the growers that have packed up recently were renowned for their quality. I imagine part of the reason they packed up was due to the higher costs they incurred from producing higher quality. Im sure they had pride in what they produced and didn’t want to see themselves producing lesser quality. It’s sad as far too much knowledge has been lost already.

People aren’t eating traditional veg, we’ve changed our diets as migrants have arrived over the past 50 years and brought their diets with them which we all enjoy. Much of the fruits and vegetables used in these dishes unsurprisingly come from abroad.

Coincidently a lot of these imported fruit and veg are a lot easier to prepare. As disposable incomes have increased people value their leisure time more and don’t want to be peeling swedes, peeling sprouts, podding fresh peas, chopping up and boiling carrots and parsnips.

When the supermarkets were growing across the country they wanted the best produce to attract people into store as vegetables and fruit were more valued by the consumer back then. The second best then went to the wholesale markets which wasn’t much good for the greengrocer trying to compete with the supermarkets, hence why we’ve got the dominance of the supermarkets today.

More recentf you go to the wholesale market the quality is far superior to that in the supermarket you can smell the freshness. As disposable incomes have increased people are eating out more and restaurants want quality produce which they buy from the wholesale market.

Unfortunately I think due to a changing diet the consumer doesn’t want vegetables on their plate anymore. How often do you go out to eat and the only greenery on your plate is a couple of pea shoots sprinkled on the top of your meat and carbs? A lot of farmers I know don’t want to eat veg.

I think we’re in for a major health crisis. Much more needs to be done in education in schools on how to cook healthy nutritious meals. It’ll be an uphill battle as we’re two generation away from those that are eating most of the traditional vegetables.

Its a shame especially when you compare the nutrient value and carbon footprint of say a potato grown a couple of miles away to an iceberg in Spain or mangetout from Africa. We’ve got a great story to tell.

I love growing veg, hopefully quality veg which I find rewarding although it’s hard work. I want to grow more but no one wants to eat it. As a family farm it’s ever more difficult as generally speaking across all industry’s government policy suits big corporate business.
 

Kidds

Member
Horticulture
The demand for veg isn’t what it was. Growers are fighting over a smaller market and the supermarkets want it as cheap as possible. The supermarket specs have widened to keep the price low. Growers have fought for extra buisness for economies of scale. It’s common for one grower to supply a whole supermarket, sometimes several. This means veg is sat about on transport and in the supply chain for days.

The result is crap old veg in store with no flavour. New varieties have been bred for yield and shelf life often at the expense of flavour. Its a vicious circle as less people pick it up. Less demand. Less market share. Lower quality.

A lot of the growers that have packed up recently were renowned for their quality. I imagine part of the reason they packed up was due to the higher costs they incurred from producing higher quality. Im sure they had pride in what they produced and didn’t want to see themselves producing lesser quality. It’s sad as far too much knowledge has been lost already.

People aren’t eating traditional veg, we’ve changed our diets as migrants have arrived over the past 50 years and brought their diets with them which we all enjoy. Much of the fruits and vegetables used in these dishes unsurprisingly come from abroad.

Coincidently a lot of these imported fruit and veg are a lot easier to prepare. As disposable incomes have increased people value their leisure time more and don’t want to be peeling swedes, peeling sprouts, podding fresh peas, chopping up and boiling carrots and parsnips.

When the supermarkets were growing across the country they wanted the best produce to attract people into store as vegetables and fruit were more valued by the consumer back then. The second best then went to the wholesale markets which wasn’t much good for the greengrocer trying to compete with the supermarkets, hence why we’ve got the dominance of the supermarkets today.

More recentf you go to the wholesale market the quality is far superior to that in the supermarket you can smell the freshness. As disposable incomes have increased people are eating out more and restaurants want quality produce which they buy from the wholesale market.

Unfortunately I think due to a changing diet the consumer doesn’t want vegetables on their plate anymore. How often do you go out to eat and the only greenery on your plate is a couple of pea shoots sprinkled on the top of your meat and carbs? A lot of farmers I know don’t want to eat veg.

I think we’re in for a major health crisis. Much more needs to be done in education in schools on how to cook healthy nutritious meals. It’ll be an uphill battle as we’re two generation away from those that are eating most of the traditional vegetables.

Its a shame especially when you compare the nutrient value and carbon footprint of say a potato grown a couple of miles away to an iceberg in Spain or mangetout from Africa. We’ve got a great story to tell.

I love growing veg, hopefully quality veg which I find rewarding although it’s hard work. I want to grow more but no one wants to eat it. As a family farm it’s ever more difficult as generally speaking across all industry’s government policy suits big corporate business.
Well said.
You obviously know what you are talking about which is unusual on this topic on this forum full of farmers.
The changes in the wholesale markets over the last decade or so are incredible in terms of volume and quality, one has nosedived and the other improved massively.
 

steveR

Member
Mixed Farmer
It's not Brexit, it's covid. People just don't want to bend their backs these days. It is reckoned that around 900,000 people from the workforce have not returned to it since the first lockdown. They have retired or do cash in hand type stuff. Obviously a lot of foreign nationals have returned home. And to be honest, with the cost of living being as it is, I should think many would have gone just from that.

Fruit and veg have been too cheap for years anyway and the supermarkets take the shine out of the job. Too much waste, faffing and plastic involved and the general public are not without blame either as they don't select their veg and fruit any more so anything too large/too small or blemished is never viewed by them. I would hate to think what percentage of veg never leaves the field.

I read this and it took me back to my first Ag placement as an apprentice. The farm grew quite a lot brassicas, and very little was "wasted", as the suckler cow herd would usually go in first to tidy up after picking. Again, not an option these days with small work forces and land not geared up for stock.
 

Muddyroads

Member
NFFN Member
Location
Exeter, Devon
Perhaps there's a need for more farmers like @Muddyroads ? He seems able to think differently and use locals.
Thank you. I’ve been reading this with interest but don’t really feel qualified to comment compared to the experienced @Kidds, @SteveHudd And @7610 super q. But since when have qualifications stopped anyone on here? 😁
We‘re only in our 3rd year growing veg, the vast majority of which goes to Riverford. We’re small, growing around 22 acres but I think this is one of our advantages. All labour is local and part time. By growing a range of crops we spread the planting, weeding and picking work as well as reducing the risk from individual crop failures. Typically our pickers will do 4-5 hours work on the days we need them and this is key. They come from a variety of backgrounds from students through to part time office workers and retirees. Would anyone here want to pick veg 5+ days per week for 8 hours + per day? I doubt it, especially if they were employed and it wasn’t their own business, so if we wouldn’t want to do it, why should we expect others to?
The problems I see are two fold.
Firstly, growers have become too big, needing full time staff doing hard unattractive work. Small mixed farms like our/s are seen as inefficient, yet we function when others are struggling.
Secondly, markets. If Riverford don’t want one some of our highly perishable veg (they’re predicting a drop of 10-20% demand this year) what do we do with it? As said elsewhere here, many wholesale markets have gone, meaning we’d have to go from Exeter to Bristol, only for some of it to probably head back down the M5 again.
So ideally we’d have small mixed family farms growing for local markets, but unless someone has a magic wand…..
 

Oldmacdonald

Member
Mixed Farmer
Location
Scotland
Thank you. I’ve been reading this with interest but don’t really feel qualified to comment compared to the experienced @Kidds, @SteveHudd And @7610 super q. But since when have qualifications stopped anyone on here? 😁
We‘re only in our 3rd year growing veg, the vast majority of which goes to Riverford. We’re small, growing around 22 acres but I think this is one of our advantages. All labour is local and part time. By growing a range of crops we spread the planting, weeding and picking work as well as reducing the risk from individual crop failures. Typically our pickers will do 4-5 hours work on the days we need them and this is key. They come from a variety of backgrounds from students through to part time office workers and retirees. Would anyone here want to pick veg 5+ days per week for 8 hours + per day? I doubt it, especially if they were employed and it wasn’t their own business, so if we wouldn’t want to do it, why should we expect others to?
The problems I see are two fold.
Firstly, growers have become too big, needing full time staff doing hard unattractive work. Small mixed farms like our/s are seen as inefficient, yet we function when others are struggling.
Secondly, markets. If Riverford don’t want one some of our highly perishable veg (they’re predicting a drop of 10-20% demand this year) what do we do with it? As said elsewhere here, many wholesale markets have gone, meaning we’d have to go from Exeter to Bristol, only for some of it to probably head back down the M5 again.
So ideally we’d have small mixed family farms growing for local markets, but unless someone has a magic wand…..

What is the reason for Riverfords forecasted drop in demand? Recession?
 

Muddyroads

Member
NFFN Member
Location
Exeter, Devon
What is the reason for Riverfords forecasted drop in demand? Recession?
I think so. Everyone has to eat but it doesn’t have to be organic or delivered in a box to your door. However, as I would imagine that a lot of their customers are probably amongst the wealthier in society I’m not sure that the impact will be as hard as they’re fearing.
 

7610 super q

Never Forgotten
Honorary Member
Recession hit organics hard in 1991/ 1992/93. Our first crop of organic spuds in 1993 we got £120/ ton.:eek: But it was short lived, by 1995 things took off again. The recession hit again in 2007, longer lasting, and I still don't think some sectors really recovered. Organic dairy never seems to get affected for some reason.
 

solo

Member
Location
worcestershire
I think so. Everyone has to eat but it doesn’t have to be organic or delivered in a box to your door. However, as I would imagine that a lot of their customers are probably amongst the wealthier in society I’m not sure that the impact will be as hard as they’re fearing.
I can see where you are coming from with regards customers of organic produce. I have had 2 different tenants in the farm cottages over the last few years which have both chosen to buy Riverford and Abel and Cole vegetable boxes regularly. Neither of those would fit your wealthy demographic. It was a life choice for healthier food. Whether or not an economic squeeze will change this, only time will tell.
 

Kidds

Member
Horticulture
I’ve been reading this with interest but don’t really feel qualified to comment compared to the experienced @Kidds, @SteveHudd And @7610 super q.
You are more than qualified to comment. You are doing it, I used to do it and there is a big difference. Those that used to do it are very often stuck in the old ways and unable to progress as a result. New blood is the future, learn from the past but remember that it has gone.

Typically our pickers will do 4-5 hours work on the days we need them and this is key. They come from a variety of backgrounds from students through to part time office workers and retirees. Would anyone here want to pick veg 5+ days per week for 8 hours + per day? I doubt it, especially if they were employed and it wasn’t their own business, so if we wouldn’t want to do it, why should we expect others to?
I always thought that 9am-3.30pm was a good days work. You have got the best out of your workers in those hours and they can do both school runs (although Happy Hour was more likely than a school run for my crew)
 

Bobby D

Member
Thank you. I’ve been reading this with interest but don’t really feel qualified to comment compared to the experienced @Kidds, @SteveHudd And @7610 super q. But since when have qualifications stopped anyone on here? 😁
We‘re only in our 3rd year growing veg, the vast majority of which goes to Riverford. We’re small, growing around 22 acres but I think this is one of our advantages. All labour is local and part time. By growing a range of crops we spread the planting, weeding and picking work as well as reducing the risk from individual crop failures. Typically our pickers will do 4-5 hours work on the days we need them and this is key. They come from a variety of backgrounds from students through to part time office workers and retirees. Would anyone here want to pick veg 5+ days per week for 8 hours + per day? I doubt it, especially if they were employed and it wasn’t their own business, so if we wouldn’t want to do it, why should we expect others to?
The problems I see are two fold.
Firstly, growers have become too big, needing full time staff doing hard unattractive work. Small mixed farms like our/s are seen as inefficient, yet we function when others are struggling.
Secondly, markets. If Riverford don’t want one some of our highly perishable veg (they’re predicting a drop of 10-20% demand this year) what do we do with it? As said elsewhere here, many wholesale markets have gone, meaning we’d have to go from Exeter to Bristol, only for some of it to probably head back down the M5 again.
So ideally we’d have small mixed family farms growing for local markets, but unless someone has a magic wand…..
Has Riverford got too big?
 

SFI - What % were you taking out of production?

  • 0 %

    Votes: 105 40.5%
  • Up to 25%

    Votes: 94 36.3%
  • 25-50%

    Votes: 39 15.1%
  • 50-75%

    Votes: 5 1.9%
  • 75-100%

    Votes: 3 1.2%
  • 100% I’ve had enough of farming!

    Votes: 13 5.0%

May Event: The most profitable farm diversification strategy 2024 - Mobile Data Centres

  • 1,735
  • 32
With just a internet connection and a plug socket you too can join over 70 farms currently earning up to £1.27 ppkw ~ 201% ROI

Register Here: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/the-mo...2024-mobile-data-centres-tickets-871045770347

Tuesday, May 21 · 10am - 2pm GMT+1

Location: Village Hotel Bury, Rochdale Road, Bury, BL9 7BQ

The Farming Forum has teamed up with the award winning hardware manufacturer Easy Compute to bring you an educational talk about how AI and blockchain technology is helping farmers to diversify their land.

Over the past 7 years, Easy Compute have been working with farmers, agricultural businesses, and renewable energy farms all across the UK to help turn leftover space into mini data centres. With...
Top