Massey Dyna VT v Dyna 6.

Richard Smyth

Member
Arable Farmer
Strewth!

We've watched outback truckers! That guy that hauls up to the northern territories goes through hell and high water to make deliveries.

Most European trucks wouldn't last a day.

Steve's a legend!

Yeah I’m not sure I’d have the patience Steve has. Got to see yogi kendals truck at a local roadhouse couple months back.
7414778E-720A-490F-A8F1-CB2859A589E9.jpeg

Looks pretty cool in person
 
Try maneuvering a truck around in a feild. You can have all the power u want but it is useless without traction management. Getting a semi load of grain out of soft feild consists of bottom gear, engine at idle, and feathering the clutch. Loosely translated all these concepts come together in tractor with vario trans.
Vt or vario every time for us. If I want to shift gears I'll go drive a truck.

My buddy drives trucks in the states and says most of the trucks these days are all automatics anyway?! :ROFLMAO:
 
Playing devils advocate here.. what if you have a big displacement engine in a tractor? with enough grunt to almost elimate downshifts. Rather than a little high performance engine with a high tech transmission.. not suitable for loader/ tattie/ round baler work i guess. Tractors are so underpowered compared to a lorry. With a lorry you have a wide choice of engine hp ratings in a similar chassis.

In the truck world the trend is for big displacement engines that run at relatively low speeds.

The engine in a tractor has to be flexible, pulling a plough all day one minute where it's all low revs and big torque and the next minute on a mower wound up to get the necessary PTO speed and power output. What is more you have a choice of basically 3 industry accepted input speeds as well so you can't just fudge it with a cheating gearbox.
 

Spud

Member
Arable Farmer
Location
YO62
Playing devils advocate here.. what if you have a big displacement engine in a tractor? with enough grunt to almost elimate downshifts. Rather than a little high performance engine with a high tech transmission.. not suitable for loader/ tattie/ round baler work i guess. Tractors are so underpowered compared to a lorry. With a lorry you have a wide choice of engine hp ratings in a similar chassis.
A truck only achieves economy by low revs and constant gear changes. Be a pain in a tractor wouldn't it? I wonder what instigated vario:unsure:
 

Edgey22

Member
Mixed Farmer
Location
Pembrokeshire
Must be more to it than that. Wheels turning is wheels turning. Engine revs and gearbox ratio's make no difference as far as I can see.
Power and torque delivery is totally different using a vario or powershift box. When you downshift a manual/powershift you instantly disconnect drive, move/change clutch packs and then slam all the torque back to the wheels causing wheel slip. Ive got a claas vario up a bank that the other hexashift/dyna 6 couldn't do it. Identical engines, weight and trailers. The vario changes the ratio gently as not to shock the system, allowing engine to stay in peak torque/power rpm range while maintaining traction.
 

daveydiesel1

Member
Livestock Farmer
Location
Co antrim
Power and torque delivery is totally different using a vario or powershift box. When you downshift a manual/powershift you instantly disconnect drive, move/change clutch packs and then slam all the torque back to the wheels causing wheel slip. Ive got a claas vario up a bank that the other hexashift/dyna 6 couldn't do it. Identical engines, weight and trailers. The vario changes the ratio gently as not to shock the system, allowing engine to stay in peak torque/power rpm range while maintaining traction.
Finally some1 that has a claas vario. Iv wondered for ages about them but no1 seems to know about them. Whats it like compared to other brands? Is it thier own tranny in it?
 

Edgey22

Member
Mixed Farmer
Location
Pembrokeshire
Finally some1 that has a claas vario. Iv wondered for ages about them but no1 seems to know about them. Whats it like compared to other brands? Is it thier own tranny in it?
Drove mainly a Arion 660 for about 3 months earlier this year. 185hp with boost above 15kph to 205hp. The 600 series c-matic I think is claas built and the larger axions 800-900 are zf boxes.

Pros -

As simple to use as any other vario, no selectable ranges as such but 3 set speeds can be set with cruise in each 'range'
Smooth delivery of power
3 months no issues pulling silage trailers, slurry tankers and a grassland subsoiler

Cons -

Can be quite tardy at times, pulling away with load from a junction the ratio it picks can sometimes be too much so a little jolt as it winds down to pull away.
If you set a speed ie 2 mph the screen makes it 2.01mph instead, which to me is bizarre
 

Fendtbro

Member
In the truck world the trend is for big displacement engines that run at relatively low speeds.

The engine in a tractor has to be flexible, pulling a plough all day one minute where it's all low revs and big torque and the next minute on a mower wound up to get the necessary PTO speed and power output. What is more you have a choice of basically 3 industry accepted input speeds as well so you can't just fudge it with a cheating gearbox.
Not exactly. The sisu high torque engine seems to sit about 1600 rpm. Pretty low revs. And pto's can have any amount of gears you like. I thought lorry engines ran generally faster than ag stuff. At least the governor is set higher..
 

tr250

Member
Location
Northants
I’d love a vt but have got dyna 6 as they are 10 grand more to buy and the same to sell so they cost more per hour to run and do no job any faster.
 

Fendtbro

Member
A truck only achieves economy by low revs and constant gear changes. Be a pain in a tractor wouldn't it? I wonder what instigated vario:unsure:
My local haulier went back to manual gears after an automatic. Says there is no issue shifting gears and cheaper to run. Much less shifting when the engine is on top of the job, possibly no shifting required on some field work if the engine has enough power. The truck is efficient largely as the transmission has minimal losses. I would bet my
Fendt slip control using gps is unbelievable what it can do. Never seen a tractor control a subsoiled like they can.
So they lift the subsoiler as it starts to spin? It's a nightmare to plough this place, plough ends up 2 inches in the ground with the tractor still stuck.. and that's working the lift manually.
 

Fendtbro

Member
A truck only achieves economy by low revs and constant gear changes. Be a pain in a tractor wouldn't it? I wonder what instigated vario:unsure:
My local haulier went back to manual gears after an automatic. Says there is no issue shifting gears and cheaper to run. Much less shifting when the engine is on top of the job, possibly no shifting required on some field work if the engine has enough power. The truck is efficient largely as the transmission has minimal losses. I would bet my
A truck only achieves economy by low revs and constant gear changes. Be a pain in a tractor wouldn't it? I wonder what instigated vario:unsure:
And also an efficient transmission. I would bet that my old synchro transmission high speed tractor would use less diesel on hard haulage than a vario. The fastrac feels like 220 hp in, 120hp at the wheels. Easy to drive but slow and thirsty.
 

Deerefarmer

Member
Location
USA
So they lift the subsoiler as it starts to spin? It's a nightmare to plough this place, plough ends up 2 inches in the ground with the tractor still stuck.. and that's working the lift manually.
What do think we've been trying to tell you?! Of course it does. It's the ultimate machine for that type of work
 

SFI - What % were you taking out of production?

  • 0 %

    Votes: 111 38.5%
  • Up to 25%

    Votes: 109 37.8%
  • 25-50%

    Votes: 41 14.2%
  • 50-75%

    Votes: 6 2.1%
  • 75-100%

    Votes: 4 1.4%
  • 100% I’ve had enough of farming!

    Votes: 17 5.9%

May Event: The most profitable farm diversification strategy 2024 - Mobile Data Centres

  • 3,227
  • 54
With just a internet connection and a plug socket you too can join over 70 farms currently earning up to £1.27 ppkw ~ 201% ROI

Register Here: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/the-mo...2024-mobile-data-centres-tickets-871045770347

Tuesday, May 21 · 10am - 2pm GMT+1

Location: Village Hotel Bury, Rochdale Road, Bury, BL9 7BQ

The Farming Forum has teamed up with the award winning hardware manufacturer Easy Compute to bring you an educational talk about how AI and blockchain technology is helping farmers to diversify their land.

Over the past 7 years, Easy Compute have been working with farmers, agricultural businesses, and renewable energy farms all across the UK to help turn leftover space into mini data centres. With...
Top