CIPC contamination in grain stores

Bob lincs

Member
Arable Farmer
The latest red tractor/ crop assurance booklet clearly states that a cipc risk assessment must be carried out on all buildings where grain is stored ( either short or long term ) . My understanding is that if cipc has ever been applied to a potatoe crop stored in the building no matter how long ago cipc will be detected if the fabric of the store is tested . The level of contamination is set at zero as grain has not got an mrl for cipc . Am I the only person that thinks this is potentially a huge problem to many farms that is just being over looked ? I am now renewing my red tractor assurance and have been told under no uncertain terms that unless I take my grain store out of my storage plan ( as I know it wil be contaminated ) I will be suspended from the scheme . This means that I have an 800 ton drier (Ex potatoe store ) that I can't use and I will have a lot of wheat unassured !!!!!!!
 

rob1

Member
Location
wiltshire
You should have done what everyone else does and lie/say I havent ever used it in that shed, either that or just put some plastic sheets up against the walls so the crop is "segregated" from the fabric of the store
 

Whynot

Member
Location
Rugby
You should have done what everyone else does and lie/say I havent ever used it in that shed, either that or just put some plastic sheets up against the walls so the crop is "segregated" from the fabric of the store

We have at least 3 current stores used for "temporary storage" of grain which have also had CIPC used recently. During our last Assured Produce check we were told to put up CIPC signage.
I couldn't believe it when told of new grain storage rules. I suggested plastic sheeting or even fresh concrete if no longer using for spuds. Was told CIPC can still seep out!!
Are we really condemning 1000's of perfectly good stores just because no work has been done on MRL's??
Think I'll need to be very careful which samples of concrete/insulation I send off to be tested!!
It's fine to store grain in Cattle yards after a quick wash down. MADNESS!!
 

Clive

Staff Member
Arable Farmer
Location
Lichfield
are there any proven health risks form CIPC ? after all we all eat potatoes treated with it ? why does it suddenly become dangerous on grain but is harmless on a spud ??

makes little sense to me - either its dangerous and should be totally banned from all food or it's not ??
 

Bob lincs

Member
Arable Farmer
You should have done what everyone else does and lie/say I havent ever used it in that shed, either that or just put some plastic sheets up against the walls so the crop is "segregated" from the fabric of the store
You could lie when you fill out the forms but then if you sell to somone like wheatabix they find trace of cipc intheir product and trace it to you your stuffed . Also don't think your insurance will sort it out as they will just walk away if you knowingly broke the rules .
 

Bob lincs

Member
Arable Farmer
are there any proven health risks form CIPC ? after all we all eat potatoes treated with it ? why does it suddenly become dangerous on grain but is harmless on a spud ??

makes little sense to me - either its dangerous and should be totally banned from all food or it's not ??
It's not dangerous Clive we all know that it just doesn't have clearance for wheat .
 

Bob lincs

Member
Arable Farmer
It does not matter how well you seal your store walls , floor ,roof etc etc if you say yes to the question about the store previously having been treated with cipc you then have to have the fabric of the store tested it almost defiantly will come back positive so you cannot use that building
This is a huge problem why is it not being talked about more ?? Or are people just ignoring it and hope it goes away .
 

Bob lincs

Member
Arable Farmer
How about this for another scenario . Your local co operative / central store has a 10,000 ton store 50 different people tip grain in it , 1 man lies on his forms and takes in grain he has reloaded out of his old potatoe store . Traces are found in grain = 10.000 tons of grain in land fill and some very unhappy coop members !!!!!!!
 

Clive

Staff Member
Arable Farmer
Location
Lichfield
It's not dangerous Clive we all know that it just doesn't have clearance for wheat .

so surely rather than write off millions of tonnes of UK grain storage a organisation that claims to represents farmers should SPEND money and get testing done that proves its no more harmful on wheat than it is on potatoes , can't surely be impossible to do if tests and research doubtless exist for safety of potatoes ? (@Guy Smith can you think of anyone that SHOULD be doing and spending on such things ??)
 

llamedos

New Member
From http://assurance.redtractor.org.uk/resources/000/999/224/CROPS_newsletter_SEP14_web.1.pdf

upload_2015-4-17_7-49-34.png
 

Brisel

Member
Arable Farmer
Location
Midlands
@Bob lincs - relax! Do the risk assessment, having cleaned out the store. Assessment says no CIPC contamination. File away in the filing cabinet. Job done. YOU HAVE ASSESSED THE RISK AND TAKEN ALL REASONABLE STEPS TO MINIMISE THE RISK.

If you do actually test the store for CIPC & it comes back as being contaminated AND you do nothing about it THEN you are stuffed. How long ago was it last used for spuds? Who actually told you it was contaminated? What qualifications do they have to say so? Have they actually tested it or are they making a sweeping statement?
 

llamedos

New Member
This is the most up to date data I can find for the actual testing. Note it may have altered since.

http://assurance.redtractor.org.uk/...ng_of_Store_Fabric_for_Residues__May_2012.pdf

Chlorpropham (CIPC) Sampling of Store Fabric for Residues Background Chlorpropham (CIPC) is used to inhibit the sprouting of potatoes. It is applied post-harvest to bulk or boxed potatoes by fogging in store. It is volatile at ambient temperatures and during treatment some of the chemical will be absorbed into the materials (e.g. wood, concrete) used in the construction of the building.
The more treatments that are applied, the greater can be the build- up. CIPC is quite stable and will persist in the structure for many years.
Issue:- Any store in which CIPC treatments have taken place or has contained CIPC treated potatoes for any period of time is extremely unlikely to be suitable for the future storage of crops where no approval for the use of CIPC exists. This is because the risk of CIPC contamination of the crop is extremely high and is likely to lead to illegal residues contaminating the stored crop.
Because CIPC is volatile, any stored crop can be contaminated from the atmosphere within the store without any necessity for physical contact with the floor or walls.
Vacuuming and steam cleaning a contaminated store may reduce the concentrations of CIPC on the materials that make up the structure of the store.
However, it will be extremely difficult to remove traces of CIPC that have penetrated into the fabric materials. In order to avoid the risk of having a valuable crop contaminated with CIPC it is essential to check the history of the store before use. If a comprehensive record of storage is not available and you cannot be sure that CIPC has not been used, then testing of the fabric of materials within the building must be carried out before any other crops are stored.

Sampling method for residue analysis
1. A sample can be made up from dust, chippings of concrete from the floor, scrapings from bricks, pointing mortar, slivers of wood from the fabric, plaster board, insulation material etc. Ensure hands are washed clean before the samples are taken.
2. About 10-15 grams is required for analysis (a pile in the palm of a hand), but it is vitally important that this is as representative as possible and made- up of random sub-samples taken from all around the store.
3. Contact your chosen analytical laboratory to check they can test for CIPC from fabric material and the cost. The analytical cost should be approximately £100 per sample.
4. Put the sample in small marked and sealed plastic freezer bag in an outer jiffy bag with your contact details and post to the laboratory. A number of analytical laboratories will be able to undertake this test. An example would be the Food and Environment Research Agency (Fera), Sand Hutton, York. YO32 9UW. Address for the attention of Ella Patel, email: [email protected]
 

Clive

Staff Member
Arable Farmer
Location
Lichfield
@Bob lincs - relax! Do the risk assessment, having cleaned out the store. Assessment says no CIPC contamination. File away in the filing cabinet. Job done. YOU HAVE ASSESSED THE RISK AND TAKEN ALL REASONABLE STEPS TO MINIMISE THE RISK.

If you do actually test the store for CIPC & it comes back as being contaminated AND you do nothing about it THEN you are stuffed. How long ago was it last used for spuds? Who actually told you it was contaminated? What qualifications do they have to say so? Have they actually tested it or are they making a sweeping statement?

i reckon if you sample you would find it ? in the stores at our old yard the insulation and concrete smelt of CICP many years after we had stopped storing spuds in them, it soaks into porous surfaces

the solution might be to seal insulation with a paint layer and concrete with a sealant maybe ?
 

llamedos

New Member
i reckon if you sample you would find it ? in the stores at our old yard the insulation and concrete smelt of CICP many years after we had stopped storing spuds in them, it soaks into porous surfaces

the solution might be to seal insulation with a paint layer and concrete with a sealant maybe
?

I may be wrong, but I am sure I read in one of the bits of bumf I came across searching for the above, that this was a no-no too:unsure:
 

Brisel

Member
Arable Farmer
Location
Midlands
Perhaps I was being a bit flippant. Why is this appearing now? Has CIPC been found in grain?

I may be wrong, but I am sure I read in one of the bits of bumf I came across searching for the above, that this was a no-no too:unsure:

Correct. Bitumen based sealants are a particular no-no especially in oilseed rape.
 

SFI - What % were you taking out of production?

  • 0 %

    Votes: 112 38.2%
  • Up to 25%

    Votes: 112 38.2%
  • 25-50%

    Votes: 42 14.3%
  • 50-75%

    Votes: 6 2.0%
  • 75-100%

    Votes: 4 1.4%
  • 100% I’ve had enough of farming!

    Votes: 17 5.8%

May Event: The most profitable farm diversification strategy 2024 - Mobile Data Centres

  • 3,666
  • 59
With just a internet connection and a plug socket you too can join over 70 farms currently earning up to £1.27 ppkw ~ 201% ROI

Register Here: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/the-mo...2024-mobile-data-centres-tickets-871045770347

Tuesday, May 21 · 10am - 2pm GMT+1

Location: Village Hotel Bury, Rochdale Road, Bury, BL9 7BQ

The Farming Forum has teamed up with the award winning hardware manufacturer Easy Compute to bring you an educational talk about how AI and blockchain technology is helping farmers to diversify their land.

Over the past 7 years, Easy Compute have been working with farmers, agricultural businesses, and renewable energy farms all across the UK to help turn leftover space into mini data centres. With...
Top