sfi you can now apply

4course

Member
Location
north yorks
Hardly an example for purely livestock farmers to follow though
im not a purely arable farmer , I made this perfectly clear in my post so why the riposte, but ive a couple of friends who are and are now actively looking into the possibilities that similar actions could deliver for them .
 

4course

Member
Location
north yorks
Good man, fair play.

Kelt? Is that a Yorkshire term or a typo

I have no temporary grass so I haven't looked close at the grass winter bird option.. You plan to follow second cut silage with winter bird food and then a spring crop?

Enjoy the pre-black grass era... Having been smug for years I discovered it can get hold surprisingly quickly when you are reliant on contractors...
The winter bird food is mostly on pp that has been" improved" with the addition of ryegrass is reasonably productive on a 2 cut so without taking a 3rd which ive found more or less costs the same/ bale( in fact more) as what we can buy haylage in for so if left to go to seed after 2nd cut with no fertilizer then topped as early as possible in spring will fulfill the aims and leave us £/acre .Mindst we dont graze these particular fields over winter in our present system . The temp grass will be enhanced with a legume addition to comply as will some pp , its amazing how much has come into the crop if not cut late this year or hard grazed in our on farm trial patch , and then go into a combinable autumn crop. Its only the stubble turnips or similar that will go into a spring crop after ww and then will more than be likely temp grass or if we have enough grass could be beans .
 

aangus

Member
Location
cumbria
Is it possible to claim the herbal lay payment on PP if it has been over seeded/direct drilled with a herbal seed mixture? told today that it needed to be arable land only
 

EJS

Member
Mixed Farmer
Location
Ashford, Kent
Is it possible to claim the herbal lay payment on PP if it has been over seeded/direct drilled with a herbal seed mixture? told today that it needed to be arable land only
I'd agree try it but pretty sure you can't. Not even sure now how you can change pp to arable if ploughed up. Can you just change land cover? Will this change land use classification? Could try changing pp to tg01 on cover and see if it works - unlikely I guess
 

redsloe

Member
Location
Cornwall
im not a purely arable farmer , I made this perfectly clear in my post so why the riposte, but ive a couple of friends who are and are now actively looking into the possibilities that similar actions could deliver for them .
I've done exactly the same application as you have by the looks of it. Comes to a little more than the 2023 BPS payment. I'm 2/3rds grass too. Waiting on the digital signature bi apparently.
 

Hindsight

Member
Location
Lincolnshire
Is it possible to claim the herbal lay payment on PP if it has been over seeded/direct drilled with a herbal seed mixture? told today that it needed to be arable land only

Look at the guidance book - have copied it below for you. The guidance is easy to read. And for this question provides a definitive answer.



Where you can do this action​

You can do this action on eligible agricultural land located below the moorland line. The table below sets out what land is eligible for SAM3.

Eligible land for SAM3​

Eligible land typeEligible land use codeCompatible land cover
Arable land, including temporary grasslandArable crops, Leguminous and nitrogen-fixing crops, FA01 and TG01
Improved permanent grasslandPG01Permanent grassland
The glossary explains what we mean by land types, land use codes and compatible land covers.
 

Hindsight

Member
Location
Lincolnshire
I'd agree try it but pretty sure you can't. Not even sure now how you can change pp to arable if ploughed up. Can you just change land cover? Will this change land use classification? Could try changing pp to tg01 on cover and see if it works - unlikely I guess

To change land cover from Permanent Pasture to Arable need to submit an RLE1 with the request and go to land use on RPA website and update the current land use to an arable land use if it is shown as PG01.
 

Badshot

Member
Location
Kent
To change land cover from Permanent Pasture to Arable need to submit an RLE1 with the request and go to land use on RPA website and update the current land use to an arable land use if it is shown as PG01.
I've been wondering about the requirement to notify of removal of PP, wasn't it a european cross compliance reg. Cross compliance ends in January, so is it necessary, or just bide your time and wait for CC to be a thing of the past?
Interested as neighbours are mostly grass and would like to reseed to herbal leys if they can.
 

e3120

Member
Mixed Farmer
Location
Northumberland
I've been wondering about the requirement to notify of removal of PP, wasn't it a european cross compliance reg. Cross compliance ends in January, so is it necessary, or just bide your time and wait for CC to be a thing of the past?
Interested as neighbours are mostly grass and would like to reseed to herbal leys if they can.
Would only be a concern if they were 'proper' permanent pastures that hadn't been touched for decades. If there is evidence of 'improvement' (lime, fert, chem) and they're just leys > 5 years old, fire away.

I would say that if you can sensibly reseed it, it's doubtful that you would need an EIA.
 

Barleycorn

Member
BASE UK Member
Location
Hampshire
So I've spent the best part of this week with bloody SFI. We have 108 parcels, and at the moment 19 of them have the message 'Some of the land uses on the parcel are not compatible with the land cover on the parcel'. All my land use codes were accepted for BPS, but not it seems SFI. I have learnt a few tricks, any parcel with NA02 (non agricultural use) were rejected, but OK if I removed that. Also it won't accept parcels with nothing on them, so I've added i metre of hedge evaluation which did the trick. It seems that you've got to apply SFI to all your land parcels else you can't go on to the next bit. The helpline is useless, they promised a call back within two days, and I never heard from them. I expect they are fairly busy with this fiasco! My CS agent doesn't do SFI, so I am really stuck!
 
So I've spent the best part of this week with bloody SFI. We have 108 parcels, and at the moment 19 of them have the message 'Some of the land uses on the parcel are not compatible with the land cover on the parcel'. All my land use codes were accepted for BPS, but not it seems SFI. I have learnt a few tricks, any parcel with NA02 (non agricultural use) were rejected, but OK if I removed that. Also it won't accept parcels with nothing on them, so I've added i metre of hedge evaluation which did the trick. It seems that you've got to apply SFI to all your land parcels else you can't go on to the next bit. The helpline is useless, they promised a call back within two days, and I never heard from them. I expect they are fairly busy with this fiasco! My CS agent doesn't do SFI, so I am really stuck!
i cleared the issues you had by changing the land use
the problem is the system does not give an indication of what is the issue on each parcel

once you have them sorted the sfi application system gets easier

deciding what actions and how and where to implement them is the hard bit
 

Badshot

Member
Location
Kent
So I've spent the best part of this week with bloody SFI. We have 108 parcels, and at the moment 19 of them have the message 'Some of the land uses on the parcel are not compatible with the land cover on the parcel'. All my land use codes were accepted for BPS, but not it seems SFI. I have learnt a few tricks, any parcel with NA02 (non agricultural use) were rejected, but OK if I removed that. Also it won't accept parcels with nothing on them, so I've added i metre of hedge evaluation which did the trick. It seems that you've got to apply SFI to all your land parcels else you can't go on to the next bit. The helpline is useless, they promised a call back within two days, and I never heard from them. I expect they are fairly busy with this fiasco! My CS agent doesn't do SFI, so I am really stuck!
It's possibly an issue that's easily solved.

Some aims are whole parcel aims, so if there's discrepancies between the bps and SFI you have to make them match.
 

farmerm

Member
Location
Shropshire
So I've spent the best part of this week with bloody SFI. We have 108 parcels, and at the moment 19 of them have the message 'Some of the land uses on the parcel are not compatible with the land cover on the parcel'. All my land use codes were accepted for BPS, but not it seems SFI. I have learnt a few tricks, any parcel with NA02 (non agricultural use) were rejected, but OK if I removed that. Also it won't accept parcels with nothing on them, so I've added i metre of hedge evaluation which did the trick. It seems that you've got to apply SFI to all your land parcels else you can't go on to the next bit. The helpline is useless, they promised a call back within two days, and I never heard from them. I expect they are fairly busy with this fiasco! My CS agent doesn't do SFI, so I am really stuck!
The system gets upset if any none BPS eligible land use is assigned to the parcel. I still need to resolve a couple where the parcel boundary goes to the brook and includes bits of wood/scrub. 4ha parcel that is 3.95ha arable and 0.05ha WO1, computer says nooo. I could just change the WO1 to an arable code and it would work but then I would be claiming against ineligible land...
 
The system gets upset if any none BPS eligible land use is assigned to the parcel. I still need to resolve a couple where the parcel boundary goes to the brook and includes bits of wood/scrub. 4ha parcel that is 3.95ha arable and 0.05ha WO1, computer says nooo. I could just change the WO1 to an arable code and it would work but then I would be claiming against ineligible land...
you can only claim the 3.95 by changing the area on the application

i just changed the land use codes to one that worked
quicker than phoning up or rle1s

if you dont over claim there will be no fine
 

farmerm

Member
Location
Shropshire
you can only claim the 3.95 by changing the area on the application

i just changed the land use codes to one that worked
quicker than phoning up or rle1s

if you dont over claim there will be no fine
What about whole parcel options? Sam1, num1, ipm1, ipm4 claims would be against 4ha despite only 3.95ha being eligible and thus an overclaim, would it not?
 
What about whole parcel options? Sam1, num1, ipm1, ipm4 claims would be against 4ha despite only 3.95ha being eligible and thus an overclaim, would it not?
I used the area area the system threw up usually it did not include ineligible parts
but if it did the small over claim can be adjusted by Rpa or at declaration
I am not over worried about the 0.05 bits that may cause an over claim
there are no fines that multiply up
if the over claime comes to £ 100 on a £ 10000 or more claim it’s now worth the time dissecting it out

my 2023 stewardship plus Sfi plus delinked payment comes to more than the stewardship and full bps in 2020

Imho if farmers take on board the Sfi and make it work for them there will not be enough money in 2026 to pay for it


trying to second guess defra Rpa and not applying what you are entitled to claim will reduce your income
some farmers did that when direct payments first came in the 1990s before that the payments were for headage and tonnage after we joined the eu before that there were area based grants , deficiency payment area payments and capital grants
 

farmerm

Member
Location
Shropshire
I used the area area the system threw up usually it did not include ineligible parts
but if it did the small over claim can be adjusted by Rpa or at declaration
I am not over worried about the 0.05 bits that may cause an over claim
there are no fines that multiply up
if the over claime comes to £ 100 on a £ 10000 or more claim it’s now worth the time dissecting it out

my 2023 stewardship plus Sfi plus delinked payment comes to more than the stewardship and full bps in 2020

Imho if farmers take on board the Sfi and make it work for them there will not be enough money in 2026 to pay for it


trying to second guess defra Rpa and not applying what you are entitled to claim will reduce your income
some farmers did that when direct payments first came in the 1990s before that the payments were for headage and tonnage after we joined the eu before that there were area based grants , deficiency payment area payments and capital grants
frankly it really needs to come to more than BPS 2020... inflation has taken 20% in real terms and the costs and income foregone swallow up between 50% and 100% of the payment rate for most options...
 

4course

Member
Location
north yorks
The RPA blog news update that came in to my emails yesterday says just over 1000 farmers signed up and another 300 applicant s in progress .By my reckoning hardly 2% of the 78000 bps claimants in the first 3 months i.e. farmers are so far joined up to the scheme or are actively pursuing an application to join .
I dont see a lot of enthusiasm out there for that number to increase dramatically over the winter.
 

SFI - What % were you taking out of production?

  • 0 %

    Votes: 109 38.5%
  • Up to 25%

    Votes: 107 37.8%
  • 25-50%

    Votes: 41 14.5%
  • 50-75%

    Votes: 6 2.1%
  • 75-100%

    Votes: 4 1.4%
  • 100% I’ve had enough of farming!

    Votes: 16 5.7%

May Event: The most profitable farm diversification strategy 2024 - Mobile Data Centres

  • 2,929
  • 49
With just a internet connection and a plug socket you too can join over 70 farms currently earning up to £1.27 ppkw ~ 201% ROI

Register Here: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/the-mo...2024-mobile-data-centres-tickets-871045770347

Tuesday, May 21 · 10am - 2pm GMT+1

Location: Village Hotel Bury, Rochdale Road, Bury, BL9 7BQ

The Farming Forum has teamed up with the award winning hardware manufacturer Easy Compute to bring you an educational talk about how AI and blockchain technology is helping farmers to diversify their land.

Over the past 7 years, Easy Compute have been working with farmers, agricultural businesses, and renewable energy farms all across the UK to help turn leftover space into mini data centres. With...
Top