Anton Coaker: Mr Gove and his crusade

JP1

Member
Livestock Farmer
My goodness, but since he was put in post I’m struggling to get my head around Michael Gove’s endless flow of policy/consultation announcements. They seem to be daily at the minute.

I’ve already mentioned his complex and slightly…er…contradictory plans to reform agriculture post Brexit, improving our environmental credentials and animal welfare standards, while simultaneously producing ever more, and notably cheaper food.

gove.jpg


And you might well have heard something about ‘banning woodburners’ a couple of weeks ago, and the creation of new National Parks over the weekend. What might’ve passed you by, hidden in other stuff, was a consultation on ammonia- which implies he’s going to massively clamp down on how farmers spread slurry. I’m beginning to fear I might be missing others, with their coming so thick and fast.

To deal with some of the latest plethora then. Most of it comes from the ‘Clean Air Strategy 2018’, and to get beneath the skin of it you need to backtrack. For some time we’ve been sailing toward a litigious mire, with urban authorities becoming increasingly aware of how many lives are foreshortened by what might be taken as failures to control air pollution…and it won’t just be town halls that are aware of this. London mayor Sadiq Khan has been making noises about it, and pressing for ways to improve the capitals air quality, for some time. Included are his blank assertions that all diesel engines should be banned. And now Mr Gove is giving him the tools with which to bring this to pass.

Using clever new software, the two of them are going to calculate when air quality falls below a certain point, and to then locally implement a ban on, amongst other things, anything burning coal, wood burning stoves –although whether this includes all of the recently installed heavily subsidised woodchip boilers is unclear- and, of course, diesel engines.

This might sound superficially very sensible, but it’s a pretty big bit of news when you look around. Never mind all the taxis, delivery trucks, and most of the buses, pretty much every single barge/ferry/tug plying the Thames chugs along with an oil burner in its guts turning the prop. And all of the excavators and cranes busily building all those shiny new buildings? Yup, all powered by diesel Sadiq old chap. Low lying communities- such as most of London- also inevitably have issues making water and sewage run where they need to, and you can probably guess what drives many of the pumps that do this unseen but rather important service.

It gets better. Move out of London, and venture up the East coast. It is eminently possible that a smoggy day in Leeds or Wakefield, might prompt those municipal authorities to demand the enormous ‘co-fired’ Drax power station is shut down, should an easterly breeze off the Humber carry the smitch upstream. And anyway, back to the capital, where do the exhaust fumes from all those planes taking off from an increased Heathrow go? Or don’t they count? The bureaucracy this will invoke is going to be immense, as will be the upheaval.

On balance, a few suburban logburners aren’t going to make much difference, and given their very short carbon loop I would’ve thought they’d be exempt.

Oh, and in an especially sweet bit of irony, while reading about tractor engines –as farmers are won't- I noted that one highly lauded flagship British manufacturing company still makes big ole 6 cylinder diesel engines which are, presumably, ‘non-compliant’. But it’s OK, as they only go to ‘less regulated markets’ overseas.

Anyway, Mr Gove doubtless thinks he’s a fabulously forrard thinking little bunny, but at some point he’ll get reined in - although you’ve got to wonder if the PM is giving him some space to occupy himself to keep him out of her face while she’s grappling with Brexit. And as he announces ever more radical policies, he’s finding they increasingly contradict each other. I daresay his version of that Yes Minister character ‘Sir Humphrey’ must have his work cut out.

It does bother me that the real problems are being left unaddressed. It’s all very well plotting an exciting vibrant new course, but the ship is already run aground. He needs to sort out the unbelievable Departmental mess in hand before he re-invents the wheel. I’ve previously tried to illustrate how bad it is, so we’ll try some empathy. Ask how many of his frontline staff are struggling with work related stress? I bet it’s an embarrassingly large percentage….I mean, how can they face going to work each morning when it’s such a shambles?

Then, if you still want to make Britain greener Mike, you need to start working on the root cause….the human population explosion problem.


——————————————————

Anton's articles are syndicated exclusively by TFF by kind permission of the author and WMN.

Anton also writes regularly for the Dartmoor Magazine and the NFU

He has published two books; the second "The Complete Bullocks" is still in print

http://www.anton-coaker.co.uk/book.htm
 

Wastexprt

Member
BASIS
The waste sector is under continual consultation bombardment at the moment, and typically the consultation proposals are directly implemented.

The ammonia emissions from agriculture is a biggy. A very big biggy, with some very short implementation dates. There will be financial assistance under the heading of 'public money for public goods', i.e. there is money, but there is a cost attached.

The latest set of Regulations to hit is the Medium Combustion Plant Directive, directly implemented from the EU Directive, with added UK gold plating. The EA are predicting 30 000 permit applications to cover this introduction. Red Tape Challenge?? I haven't seen less regulation since it was rolled out, just more.
 

primmiemoo

Member
Location
Devon
I'm :scratchhead: as to how to spread fym from its covered heaps (or sheds as I call them) onto grassland without being required to wreck said sward by ploughing it under and releasing Nitrogenous compounds into the atmosphere in so doing.

Should I shove tarps over the fields until the worms have done their bit?
Would that comply with required incorporation implied by Mr Gove's plans?
Where do I source a 20 acre tarp, let alone a 30 acre one?

:scratchhead:,

Devon.
 
I'm :scratchhead: as to how to spread fym from its covered heaps (or sheds as I call them) onto grassland without being required to wreck said sward by ploughing it under and releasing Nitrogenous compounds into the atmosphere in so doing.

Should I shove tarps over the fields until the worms have done their bit?
Would that comply with required incorporation implied by Mr Gove's plans?
Where do I source a 20 acre tarp, let alone a 30 acre one?

:scratchhead:,

Devon.
I think the incorporation applied to bare soils/stubble not grassland.

OTOH, as a not too big farmer I may not be able to finish spreading a stubble field in a day, especially if something comes up, cow calving, heifers break out, tractor breaks down etc etc never mind plough it in, it could easily take 3or 4 days to muck and plough a field in between routine farming. I guess under these proposals farmers such as myself will have to put such work out to contractors adding more cost to our business, that or say sod it.
 
Last edited:

joe soapy

Member
Location
devon
Go back a couple of centries, all the duke of Bedford modernized farms had a central covered dung yard, Except the one at Kilworthy, that was a prototype suspended floor cattle building
all the supports, floors and troughs made of granit, well worth a look if traveling near Tavistock
 

SFI - What % were you taking out of production?

  • 0 %

    Votes: 105 40.9%
  • Up to 25%

    Votes: 93 36.2%
  • 25-50%

    Votes: 39 15.2%
  • 50-75%

    Votes: 5 1.9%
  • 75-100%

    Votes: 3 1.2%
  • 100% I’ve had enough of farming!

    Votes: 12 4.7%

May Event: The most profitable farm diversification strategy 2024 - Mobile Data Centres

  • 1,684
  • 32
With just a internet connection and a plug socket you too can join over 70 farms currently earning up to £1.27 ppkw ~ 201% ROI

Register Here: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/the-mo...2024-mobile-data-centres-tickets-871045770347

Tuesday, May 21 · 10am - 2pm GMT+1

Location: Village Hotel Bury, Rochdale Road, Bury, BL9 7BQ

The Farming Forum has teamed up with the award winning hardware manufacturer Easy Compute to bring you an educational talk about how AI and blockchain technology is helping farmers to diversify their land.

Over the past 7 years, Easy Compute have been working with farmers, agricultural businesses, and renewable energy farms all across the UK to help turn leftover space into mini data centres. With...
Top