The selectors do wear I'm afraid and the linkages wear and bend.
Another common problem is the roll
Pins on the bottom of the gear lever breaking
Yes a syncro issue i would sayWe had problems with selecting 2nd and 4th on a 5speed box, dealer changed linkage under cab, great improvement. Now seems to have got graunchy changing forward/reverse, I'm thinking syncro gone done
This is really helpful, thanks. I have been underneath and lubed up the linkage - that has helped the shifting generally , especially the range selector, which I've had to get both hands to previously!! First is still the problem though - it does feel like things just don't line up. Have to set her moving in 2nd, then drop her into 1st on the rock. The shuttle does crunch a bit here and there if I'm clumsey on the clutch (still on original clutch after 7600hrs of largely loader work! - I was worried when we bought her new as the clutch squaked from day one! It is juddery now though, so can't be much wear left on it.Start off by lubricating all the linkages, get someone in cab while you're underneath with an oil can. Lubricate the pivots and the lever pivot balls.
First gear is the first to suffer with stiff or sloppy linkages. After oiling them all stay underneath and study hiw first gear is selected, gear lever is going towards seat therefore linkage underneath is reversed and is going out towards the wheel. A pivot pin, 13mm and 17mm spanner may need nipping up.
I've never stripped one down and found worn selectors on the 1,2,3,4,5. Synchros tend to be worn on 4th gear as it's the one that takes the brunt when downshifting under load etc. I've also seen the gear levers bend towards the driver over time and therefore not getting enough travel. Study it hard before delving into the box
This is really helpful, thanks. I have been underneath and lubed up the linkage - that has helped the shifting generally , especially the range selector, which I've had to get both hands to previously!! First is still the problem though - it does feel like things just don't line up. Have to set her moving in 2nd, then drop her into 1st on the rock. The shuttle does crunch a bit here and there if I'm clumsey on the clutch (still on original clutch after 7600hrs of largely loader work! - I was worried when we bought her new as the clutch squaked from day one! It is juddery now though, so can't be much wear left on it.
4th gear lines up fine but has always been a pig to shift into - maybe the synchro has been damaged fom day one. Could never downshift from 5th under load without crunching, so have always dropped into 3rd instead - bit of a fiddle!!