Baling Hay
Member
I think the sort of comment that riles people is when farmers ask people like Gabe Brown about how or whether CA/no-till might work where they live. The answer comes back, "Do you have soil?", which rather patronisingly suggests that this is a system that can be rolled out in a universal manner across the entire planet. To me this seems like a vast oversimplification and the hugely varying climates and soil types around the world mean that every solution is going to be bespoke.
I think Gabe Brown probably can't imagine having soils not dry out. He wants all this trash on the surface to prevent the soils from drying out. Such a difference in soil type and rainfall.