Trailed vs Self Propelled Sprayer

Well all the evidence is that you don’t need to go to 200l/ha. On a small scale I use 100l for all applications. My own field comparisons of different volumes on the same day has never produced any differences. Potatoes or brussell bleeding sprouts may be different but spraying cereals isn’t rocket science.

Also in our hard water areas 100l gives better performance for a lot of products due to less cation lock up.
 
You only need flat fans with low boom height

Run 03 at 50cm, low drift if you insist. 025 at 25cm will give you 150l/ha at a good speed. Keep the volumes up to get the benefit of droplet size and coverage. 02 too prone to blocking imo

Whatever nozzles you use you will change your approach with a horsch

Thanks. Did you try 02s and have problems? With hard water I want to keep water volumes down for a lot of products. Would it work using the 03 nozzles at 50cm at the same time to get higher volumes where needed (although obviously couldn't do lower boom heights)?
 

Clive

Staff Member
Arable Farmer
Location
Lichfield
@Clive, as far as I can see Guardian Airs are not available in 80 degree format and therefore can't be used at 25cm spacings if lowering boom height down to 30cm. What am I missing?

We stoped using 25 cm height for most things - there is just no need it’s so good at 50 and x2 or x3 the nozzles / m we used to have - a real 50 all the way across the boom is remarkably low - Much lower than what you used to think 50cm was !

80deg choices are just too restrictive
 
We stoped using 25 cm height for most things - there is just no need it’s so good at 50 and x2 or x3 the nozzles / m we used to have - a real 50 all the way across the boom is remarkably low - Much lower than what you used to think 50cm was !

80deg choices are just too restrictive

I really am not expecting to give up on that advantage. It's part of the reason we got the thing. 56% reduction in drift from 50cm height down to 30cm is not to be sniffed at. Can't see what the problem is with yellow 02 80 degree flat fans? What was the point in spec'ing 25cm nozzle spacing if all you do is spray at 50cm?

I believe you get higher droplet speeds (and IIRC a lower range of droplet speeds too) with 80 degree nozzles compared to 110 degree ones. This is gives, to use an advanced driving phrase, a lower TED (Time Exposed to Danger) in addition to the reduced distance to the target.
 
Last edited:

Clive

Staff Member
Arable Farmer
Location
Lichfield
I really am not expecting to give up on that advantage. It's part of the reason we got the thing. 56% reduction in drift from 50cm height down to 30cm is not to be sniffed at. Can't see what the problem is with yellow 02 80 degree flat fans? What was the point in spec'ing 25cm nozzle spacing if all you do is spray at 50cm?

I believe you get higher droplet speeds (and IIRC a lower range of droplet speeds too) with 80 degree nozzles compared to 110 degree ones. This is gives, to use an advanced driving phrase, a lower TED (Time Exposed to Danger) in addition to the reduced distance to the target.

Wait until you use it a bit - I bet you change your mind !

The reason why 25cm is still an advantage at 50cm is that you can have twice (or even x3) the nozzles applying the same volume - the additional coverage that gives is remarkable and at a true 50cm height drift just isn’t an issue with the guardian air - flat fats are great but can be drifty

What I planned is not what we have ended up doing it’s such a game changing bit of kit

Still trying different combos however and remember I don’t use pre ems here, never spray bare soil, and don’t have black grass so maybe different priorities to you
 
Location
N Yorks
Thanks. Did you try 02s and have problems? With hard water I want to keep water volumes down for a lot of products. Would it work using the 03 nozzles at 50cm at the same time to get higher volumes where needed (although obviously couldn't do lower boom heights)?

No not really. At 150l/ha I can do 40ha on a tankful with a decent forward speed

I spray at 35-40cm above target and drift is minimal compared to 50-60cm. If you set the boom to lift 30-50cm at the end it is really noticeable when starting a run if windy till the boom gets down to work height

Flat fan 80degree nozzles. Why bother with any of these low drift nozzles when the whole boom is low drift, used as intended. Oh, and I have alternate nozzles pointing forward, meaning I cannot use the front space as it hits the alloy curtain

Only use the 50cm spacing for fertiliser nozzles
 
No not really. At 150l/ha I can do 40ha on a tankful with a decent forward speed

I spray at 35-40cm above target and drift is minimal compared to 50-60cm. If you set the boom to lift 30-50cm at the end it is really noticeable when starting a run if windy till the boom gets down to work height

Flat fan 80degree nozzles. Why bother with any of these low drift nozzles when the whole boom is low drift, used as intended. Oh, and I have alternate nozzles pointing forward, meaning I cannot use the front space as it hits the alloy curtain

Only use the 50cm spacing for fertiliser nozzles

So would you say that 80 degree flat fans at 30cm will be less drifty than something like a Guardian Air at 50cm? I was wondering about putting only backwards facing Defy nozzles on at 50cm for higher forward speed spraying with the backwards facing element of the nozzles doing that bit extra to counteract the forward speed to get a bit more penetration down into the crop. Not sure if that is a mad idea or not.

Also, any suggestions on the best flat fan choice? I guess an XR type one that can handle a wide range of pressures?
 
Last edited:

Billboy1

Member
Trying to compromise on tyre size here , would you consider 580 /42 tyres on tractor on a mounted 30m sprayer to wide for all year use think it’s about 4% of crop taken up ?
 
Trying to compromise on tyre size here , would you consider 580 /42 tyres on tractor on a mounted 30m sprayer to wide for all year use think it’s about 4% of crop taken up ?

I have gone for 580s (that's actual tyre width measured with a tape measure) on 36m. Will see how it goes and am prepared to get row crops. For us it's a heavy sprayer and I don't like the idea of really high pressures mainly for my back and slightly the field.
 
Location
N Yorks
So would you say that 80 degree flat fans at 30cm will be less drifty than something like a Guardian Air at 50cm? I was wondering about putting only backwards facing Defy nozzles on at 50cm for higher forward speed spraying with the backwards facing element of the nozzles doing that bit extra to counteract the forward speed to get a bit more penetration down into the crop. Not sure if that is a mad idea or not.

Also, any suggestions on the best flat fan choice? I guess an XR type one that can handle a wide range of pressures?
No. I'm saying I just wouldn't suggest any LD nozzle when 25cm spacing, lower boom height, the front curtain, 80deg nozzles all do the same job whilst still allowing a fine spray therefore good coverage of the target.

All air inclusion/LD nozzles end up compromising coverage because of the larger droplet size. When my sprayer was new we did some tests on different nozzles and settled on flat fan 025 80deg alternate forward and down. With a little assistance from my agronomist
 
Location
N Yorks
I have gone for 580s (that's actual tyre width measured with a tape measure) on 36m. Will see how it goes and am prepared to get row crops. For us it's a heavy sprayer and I don't like the idea of really high pressures mainly for my back and slightly the field.
That's what I did. I instantly regretted it over wider winter tyres and narrow row crops.

However time tells me it probably is a good compromise. Very little winter rutting and you wouldn't get away with much narrower to still be safe at 50k in the summer

If I was buying new again I would probably stick with the 580
 

SFI - What % were you taking out of production?

  • 0 %

    Votes: 113 38.4%
  • Up to 25%

    Votes: 112 38.1%
  • 25-50%

    Votes: 42 14.3%
  • 50-75%

    Votes: 6 2.0%
  • 75-100%

    Votes: 4 1.4%
  • 100% I’ve had enough of farming!

    Votes: 17 5.8%

May Event: The most profitable farm diversification strategy 2024 - Mobile Data Centres

  • 3,925
  • 59
With just a internet connection and a plug socket you too can join over 70 farms currently earning up to £1.27 ppkw ~ 201% ROI

Register Here: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/the-mo...2024-mobile-data-centres-tickets-871045770347

Tuesday, May 21 · 10am - 2pm GMT+1

Location: Village Hotel Bury, Rochdale Road, Bury, BL9 7BQ

The Farming Forum has teamed up with the award winning hardware manufacturer Easy Compute to bring you an educational talk about how AI and blockchain technology is helping farmers to diversify their land.

Over the past 7 years, Easy Compute have been working with farmers, agricultural businesses, and renewable energy farms all across the UK to help turn leftover space into mini data centres. With...
Top