Asda in trouble. Could the Gov step in?

soapsud

Member
Livestock Farmer
Location
Dorset
Like Morrisons, Asda is over-financialised.

Over a year ago I asked TFFers if nationalising a supermarket could benchmark (not fix nor baseline) farmgate prices. It wasn't a popular idea then.

Remember BHS, Debenhams, Woolworths?

Thoughts?

see @anzani post for link
 
Last edited:

robs1

Member
It's like Woolworths and a few others been in business a long time and borrowing to pay over inflated salaries, bonuses and dividends plus selling off sites and leasing them back, the clever people call it leverage, being a simple peasant I call it selling your breakfast to buy your dinner.
 

soapsud

Member
Livestock Farmer
Location
Dorset
Aldi and Lidl are taking up market share.
This is Labour's first test for their support for workers. If they do step in it'll be a variation on PFI. The lefties in the Labour party will start chuntering now.

Obviously HMG wouldn't nationalise Asda. That was just bait before bait 😆
 

Bald Rick

Moderator
Moderator
Location
Anglesey
Aldi and Lidl are taking up market share.
This is Labour's first test for their support for workers. If they do step in it'll be a variation on PFI. The lefties in the Labour party will start chuntering now.

Obviously HMG wouldn't nationalise Asda. That was just bait before bait 😆

No, that will be the pay deal that they agreed with the doctors. 21% is some benchmark when the train drivers are revolting .....
 

soapsud

Member
Livestock Farmer
Location
Dorset
No, that will be the pay deal that they agreed with the doctors. 21% is some benchmark when the train drivers are revolting .....
Good point. I'll try and say why I started this and why this is Ag related not Cess Pit territory.

Ag producers are price takers. Supermarket buyers determine market prices. Competition between them creates the market. If, as your wit above demos, Asda goes to the wall, then that's one less hat in the ring for farmgate prices and therefore one step closer to a food buying monopoly. Which means less keen prices for primary producers.

In short, it is in farmers' interests that the Big Six don't get reduced.
 

ColinV6

Member
I don’t do self check out, prefer to queue and deal with a real person.

That’s the issue. Everyone wants to use a proper checkout. Everyone is frustrated when they have to queue ages to wait for one of a handful of checkouts open, while about 10+ sit closed.

Self checkouts are fine for 3-4 items, a bunch of flowers and a card etc. For a basket full or trolley full then forget it.

“Please wait for assistance”
“Approval needed”
“Please place the item in bagging area”

It’s soul destroying!!
 

essex man

Member
Location
colchester
That’s the issue. Everyone wants to use a proper checkout. Everyone is frustrated when they have to queue ages to wait for one of a handful of checkouts open, while about 10+ sit closed.

Self checkouts are fine for 3-4 items, a bunch of flowers and a card etc. For a basket full or trolley full then forget it.

“Please wait for assistance”
“Approval needed”
“Please place the item in bagging area”

It’s soul destroying!!
You can go to Lidl and get served by a person.
 

ColinV6

Member
You can go to Lidl and get served by a person.

We sometimes do aldi as the food is superb but the way they scan stuff through at a million miles an hour gives me anxiety lol.

Then you have to fling it in the trolley and then go and repack it all.

Or just wait in the queue at Asda and browse TFF while you wait,

Or just send the wife :LOL:
 

Have you taken any land out of production from last autumn?

  • Yes

  • No

  • Don’t know


Results are only viewable after voting.

Fields to Fork Festival 2025 offers discounted tickets for the farming community.

  • 163
  • 0
The Fields to Fork Festival celebrating country life, good food and backing British farming is due to take over Whitebottom Farm, Manchester, on 3rd & 4th May 2025!

Set against the idyllic backdrop of Whitebottom Farm, the festival will be an unforgettable weekend of live music, award-winning chefs, and gourmet food and drink, all while supporting UK’s farmers and food producers. As a way to show appreciation for everyone in the farming community, discounted tickets are on offer for those working in the agricultural sectors.

Alexander McLaren, Founder of Fields to Fork Festival says “British produce and rural culture has never needed the spotlight more than it does today. This festival is our way of celebrating everything that makes...
Back
Top