Beef / Lamb & Pig Price Tracker

Location
Devon
You are talking utter rubbish @Sid ..

Every other industry regardless of sector are all saying the same thing and that they have no choice but to pass on the recent input inflation seen to their customers or they will be out of business..

So quite why you think sheep farmers should now sell lambs well below the cost of production so people can eat cheaply is utter stupidity and quite frankly a race to the bottom and the sheep industry would end up like the poor pig industry now is if sheep farmers thought like you!


Current farmgate inflation for inputs is up 28% at least on 12 months ago ( according to Andersons the accountants ) so how the hell are sheep ( or indeed any farming sector ) farmers meant to just absorb that input inflation unless farmgate prices for sheep rise pro rata??

And there will certainly be no such thing as cheap root/kale crops this year either!!

And Sid if you really believe what you say and the sheep sector should be happy to absorb the 28% farmgate input inflation then why do you not practice what you are telling the rest of us to do and start a thread/ campaign to have farmgate milk prices set at no more than 30ppl and well below the current COP to help the poor consumers?? ( of course if you started such a thread in the dairy section the dairy farmers in there would laugh you off the forum after telling you to get real and they cannot absorb 28% input price inflation and sell milk at 30ppl....
 

Purli R

Member
1649898988628.png
 

Werzle

Member
Location
Midlands
You are talking utter rubbish @Sid ..

Every other industry regardless of sector are all saying the same thing and that they have no choice but to pass on the recent input inflation seen to their customers or they will be out of business..

So quite why you think sheep farmers should now sell lambs well below the cost of production so people can eat cheaply is utter stupidity and quite frankly a race to the bottom and the sheep industry would end up like the poor pig industry now is if sheep farmers thought like you!


Current farmgate inflation for inputs is up 28% at least on 12 months ago ( according to Andersons the accountants ) so how the hell are sheep ( or indeed any farming sector ) farmers meant to just absorb that input inflation unless farmgate prices for sheep rise pro rata??

And there will certainly be no such thing as cheap root/kale crops this year either!!

And Sid if you really believe what you say and the sheep sector should be happy to absorb the 28% farmgate input inflation then why do you not practice what you are telling the rest of us to do and start a thread/ campaign to have farmgate milk prices set at no more than 30ppl and well below the current COP to help the poor consumers?? ( of course if you started such a thread in the dairy section the dairy farmers in there would laugh you off the forum after telling you to get real and they cannot absorb 28% input price inflation and sell milk at 30ppl....
Watching the news yesterday the countrys only jukebox maker said the microchip to go in them had risen from just under £4 to £89!!!
 

Sid

Member
Livestock Farmer
Location
South Molton
You are talking utter rubbish @Sid ..

Every other industry regardless of sector are all saying the same thing and that they have no choice but to pass on the recent input inflation seen to their customers or they will be out of business..

So quite why you think sheep farmers should now sell lambs well below the cost of production so people can eat cheaply is utter stupidity and quite frankly a race to the bottom and the sheep industry would end up like the poor pig industry now is if sheep farmers thought like you!


Current farmgate inflation for inputs is up 28% at least on 12 months ago ( according to Andersons the accountants ) so how the hell are sheep ( or indeed any farming sector ) farmers meant to just absorb that input inflation unless farmgate prices for sheep rise pro rata??

And there will certainly be no such thing as cheap root/kale crops this year either!!

And Sid if you really believe what you say and the sheep sector should be happy to absorb the 28% farmgate input inflation then why do you not practice what you are telling the rest of us to do and start a thread/ campaign to have farmgate milk prices set at no more than 30ppl and well below the current COP to help the poor consumers?? ( of course if you started such a thread in the dairy section the dairy farmers in there would laugh you off the forum after telling you to get real and they cannot absorb 28% input price inflation and sell milk at 30ppl....
Farmers has historically been price takers.
That has/will change only due to supply being tight.
There have been plenty of occasions over the years where all commodities have been below the COP supported by the EU schemes.

As I said previously, you can have a COP of £200/lamb or 50p/l milk but if the consumer won't put their hand in their pocket as you rightly say your out of business. Has happened in the dairy sector and others and it probably will again.

But the difference between milk and lamb, I'll repeat it for you again, is that milk and bread are seen as staples in the shopping basket. Auto pilot pick up and go. Don't see that with a £20 leg of lamb!

Happy to see any sector absorb a 28% rise in input cost. Of course not but you also have to be realistic, will all those cost be found from the market, who knows, that's for the market to decide.
So when your up buying your lorry loads store cattle to put in your finishing unit remember those producers will have had increased costs this winter and bid up well on their cattle, about 30% more than last year should cover it and give then some margin to be able to buy that leg of lamb 👍

Home grown feed, kale/root crops will nearly always be cheaper than bought in feed.

Trouble is with many millions out of work and no Government help how will they be able to afford to buy expensive lamb/beef when cheaper alternatives can be easily found??

What we really need is for chicken meat to become very expensive over the next few months!

You have already said yourself beef and lamb is expensive.....and its not got cheaper

So is it expensive or not? And can the consumer afford it?
 

Sid

Member
Livestock Farmer
Location
South Molton
You are talking utter rubbish @Sid ..

Every other industry regardless of sector are all saying the same thing and that they have no choice but to pass on the recent input inflation seen to their customers or they will be out of business..

So quite why you think sheep farmers should now sell lambs well below the cost of production so people can eat cheaply is utter stupidity and quite frankly a race to the bottom and the sheep industry would end up like the poor pig industry now is if sheep farmers thought like you!


Current farmgate inflation for inputs is up 28% at least on 12 months ago ( according to Andersons the accountants ) so how the hell are sheep ( or indeed any farming sector ) farmers meant to just absorb that input inflation unless farmgate prices for sheep rise pro rata??

And there will certainly be no such thing as cheap root/kale crops this year either!!

And Sid if you really believe what you say and the sheep sector should be happy to absorb the 28% farmgate input inflation then why do you not practice what you are telling the rest of us to do and start a thread/ campaign to have farmgate milk prices set at no more than 30ppl and well below the current COP to help the poor consumers?? ( of course if you started such a thread in the dairy section the dairy farmers in there would laugh you off the forum after telling you to get real and they cannot absorb 28% input price inflation and sell milk at 30ppl....

I suggest you look back through the data and highlight the years to me where lowland livestock has been above COP and given a decent return on capital in the last 25 years?

Food is going to become more of a priority in household spending, begrudgingly.
 

Henarar

Member
Livestock Farmer
Location
Somerset
Farmers has historically been price takers.
That has/will change only due to supply being tight.
There have been plenty of occasions over the years where all commodities have been below the COP supported by the EU schemes.

As I said previously, you can have a COP of £200/lamb or 50p/l milk but if the consumer won't put their hand in their pocket as you rightly say your out of business. Has happened in the dairy sector and others and it probably will again.

But the difference between milk and lamb, I'll repeat it for you again, is that milk and bread are seen as staples in the shopping basket. Auto pilot pick up and go. Don't see that with a £20 leg of lamb!

Happy to see any sector absorb a 28% rise in input cost. Of course not but you also have to be realistic, will all those cost be found from the market, who knows, that's for the market to decide.
So when your up buying your lorry loads store cattle to put in your finishing unit remember those producers will have had increased costs this winter and bid up well on their cattle, about 30% more than last year should cover it and give then some margin to be able to buy that leg of lamb 👍

Home grown feed, kale/root crops will nearly always be cheaper than bought in feed.



You have already said yourself beef and lamb is expensive.....and its not got cheaper

So is it expensive or not? And can the consumer afford it?
Lamb is not expensive
No idea where folk get this from
 

SFI - What % were you taking out of production?

  • 0 %

    Votes: 105 40.4%
  • Up to 25%

    Votes: 95 36.5%
  • 25-50%

    Votes: 39 15.0%
  • 50-75%

    Votes: 5 1.9%
  • 75-100%

    Votes: 3 1.2%
  • 100% I’ve had enough of farming!

    Votes: 13 5.0%

May Event: The most profitable farm diversification strategy 2024 - Mobile Data Centres

  • 1,830
  • 32
With just a internet connection and a plug socket you too can join over 70 farms currently earning up to £1.27 ppkw ~ 201% ROI

Register Here: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/the-mo...2024-mobile-data-centres-tickets-871045770347

Tuesday, May 21 · 10am - 2pm GMT+1

Location: Village Hotel Bury, Rochdale Road, Bury, BL9 7BQ

The Farming Forum has teamed up with the award winning hardware manufacturer Easy Compute to bring you an educational talk about how AI and blockchain technology is helping farmers to diversify their land.

Over the past 7 years, Easy Compute have been working with farmers, agricultural businesses, and renewable energy farms all across the UK to help turn leftover space into mini data centres. With...
Top