• Welcome to The Farming Forum!

    As part of this update, we have made a change to the login and registration process. If you are experiences any problems, please email [email protected] with the details so we can resolve any issues.

No-Till Potatoes

York

Member
Location
D-Berlin
John is it (he by the look on his face) a Norfolk?
Forget the potatoes...they are not an indigenous crop to Europe. I think the nearest anybody can get to no-till potatoes is planting them into an over-wintered cover crop they have done it in Germany and Switzerland.. Potatoes and OSR fall into the same category IMO. .best avoided.
also on the plate ;-)
I follow the Dutch approach. We like them only in a long cut "stick" version. roundish or mashed = a no go, not a potatoe.
York-Th.
 

martian

DD Moderator
Moderator
Location
N Herts
A quick update on how they are doing. We planted three sets of four rows, two sets got a dob of mycorhizal innoculant. These look far better than the control strip
DSC00928.JPG

It looks like the RTK lost signal at this point. You can see on the left where badgers, or some other creatures, have been snuffling under the straw. This next picture is without the innoculant
DSC00930.JPG

We haven't had more than a drop or two of rain here for a while and it is pretty dry now in places under the straw. The fungi are certainly helping. For interest this last pic is some black oats we drilled in the rest of the field as cover. Looks like we might be able to combine them, the seed will come in handy for cover cropping. It's had zero inputs so far, beyond a bit of dung near the potato rows
DSC00932.JPG
 

martian

DD Moderator
Moderator
Location
N Herts
The plan was to harvest them with a machine. I must admit I know not much about spuds, but I imagine you want them in rows for that.
 

RushesToo

Member
Location
Fingringhoe
Martian - genius, what a fantastic experiment. Hope that you have lot's of offspring to harvest for pocket money top ups and that they taste good when served.
Great stuff :)
 

martian

DD Moderator
Moderator
Location
N Herts
Now we've had four inches of rain, a further update
DSC00933.JPG

That's the control plot, whilst the next snap is with mycorrhizal innoculant
DSC00934.JPG

Which is quite a difference, though down the other end of the field the difference is less noticable where the FYM was plastered on a bit deeper.
Pull the straw away (it -the straw- is surprisingly dry in the middle, the rain passes through it and soaks the ground) and you see the potatoes spreading out over the surface of the soil
DSC00936.JPG
DSC00937.JPG

This last picture gives some idea of how black oats look next to some modern machinery, to give you an idea of scale. (The dog had long since gone)
 

martian

DD Moderator
Moderator
Location
N Herts
Forget the potatoes, the real news looks like that inoculant. Is it from RH's guys?
Yes, they are still doing some research on it, but this looks impressive. When they did some on conventional spuds, I think they found much improved rooting, but no great yield increase. Maybe you could cut irrigation requirements?
 

dontknowanything

Member
Innovate UK
Location
Cambridge
Yes, they are still doing some research on it, but this looks impressive. When they did some on conventional spuds, I think they found much improved rooting, but no great yield increase. Maybe you could cut irrigation requirements?
Ah yes, the old Umostart scenario.

Look how much more the roots weigh, extra leaf area, better establishment blah blah blah

Oh, you want to know about the yield... Hmm, isn't it a nice day today?
 

Simon Chiles

DD Moderator
Moderator
Ah yes, the old Umostart scenario.

Look how much more the roots weigh, extra leaf area, better establishment blah blah blah

Oh, you want to know about the yield... Hmm, isn't it a nice day today?

I've some trial plots ( of a few acres ) of the same mycorrhizal in several fields of triticale, three different rates in a field of soya and some that we added to some vetch to see if the nurse crop of mustard had any effect on the population. To be fair the medium that it is in isn't suitable for accurate large scale mechanical application but they have found some other mediums that I have tested on a small scale that look much better. This will enable us to do more trials.
Someone said to me that he was surprised that I was so convinced that it would work. My reply was that mycorrhizal fungi have been around for millions of years so this was hardly anything new, the bit that I am unsure about is our ability to manage it to our advantage.
 

martian

DD Moderator
Moderator
Location
N Herts
Well we harvested most of them today. Grading them quite hard we about filled two potato boxes with crisp quality spuds. There's a lot lying on the ground and some rows still undisturbed. I was astonished by the quantity to be honest. Harvested manually (thanks for asking: I can hardly move), nearly all the spuds lay on the soil surface in the interface between straw and soil, so came up quite clean after half an inch of rain yesterday. Quite a few slug damaged, a few mouse nibbled and the odd slightly green one. Definitely the only way to grow tatties in the veg patch, complete doddle compared to digging.

The innoculant seemed to work well, but not cut and dried result, much variety up and down rows. This due to, amongst other possible reasons: thickness of FYM base, waterlogging, thickness of straw (in some places found dry ground under straw, mostly ground is a super SOM rich rotted mulch full of worms and numerous creatures and billions of slug eggs), type of straw (barley much less rotted than wheat, not necessarily better, but cleaner spuds) and the phase of the moon. So not very scientific.

Will post snaps once I work out how to get them off phone...
 

RushesToo

Member
Location
Fingringhoe
Well we harvested most of them today. Grading them quite hard we about filled two potato boxes with crisp quality spuds. There's a lot lying on the ground and some rows still undisturbed. I was astonished by the quantity to be honest. Harvested manually (thanks for asking: I can hardly move), nearly all the spuds lay on the soil surface in the interface between straw and soil, so came up quite clean after half an inch of rain yesterday. Quite a few slug damaged, a few mouse nibbled and the odd slightly green one. Definitely the only way to grow tatties in the veg patch, complete doddle compared to digging.

The innoculant seemed to work well, but not cut and dried result, much variety up and down rows. This due to, amongst other possible reasons: thickness of FYM base, waterlogging, thickness of straw (in some places found dry ground under straw, mostly ground is a super SOM rich rotted mulch full of worms and numerous creatures and billions of slug eggs), type of straw (barley much less rotted than wheat, not necessarily better, but cleaner spuds) and the phase of the moon. So not very scientific.

Will post snaps once I work out how to get them off phone...
Thank you for keeping this up - a slow burn blog. Really enjoyable.
 

Simon Chiles

DD Moderator
Moderator
Well we harvested most of them today. Grading them quite hard we about filled two potato boxes with crisp quality spuds. There's a lot lying on the ground and some rows still undisturbed. I was astonished by the quantity to be honest. Harvested manually (thanks for asking: I can hardly move), nearly all the spuds lay on the soil surface in the interface between straw and soil, so came up quite clean after half an inch of rain yesterday. Quite a few slug damaged, a few mouse nibbled and the odd slightly green one. Definitely the only way to grow tatties in the veg patch, complete doddle compared to digging.

The innoculant seemed to work well, but not cut and dried result, much variety up and down rows. This due to, amongst other possible reasons: thickness of FYM base, waterlogging, thickness of straw (in some places found dry ground under straw, mostly ground is a super SOM rich rotted mulch full of worms and numerous creatures and billions of slug eggs), type of straw (barley much less rotted than wheat, not necessarily better, but cleaner spuds) and the phase of the moon. So not very scientific.

Will post snaps once I work out how to get them off phone...

I did try and get you off the hook with a very important phone call but you had already bunked off early chasing cattle.
Re the photos, it's no use asking hop along he's only just got an iPhone himself, best to ask a teenager. Good luck explaining to them about TFF, they'll probably think you've lost the plot. Just call it Facebook for Farmers!
 

martian

DD Moderator
Moderator
Location
N Herts
I did try and get you off the hook with a very important phone call but you had already bunked off early chasing cattle.
Re the photos, it's no use asking hop along he's only just got an iPhone himself, best to ask a teenager. Good luck explaining to them about TFF, they'll probably think you've lost the plot. Just call it Facebook for Farmers!
Sorry not to ring you back. Once I'd established it was a nuisance call...
 

Lewis821

Member
Mixed Farmer
Location
norfolk
But they use a machine to remove the straw, sweep whatever is left with a type of roadbrush on the front of the harvester , the amount of straw that goes through the harvester is usually zero
 

How is your SFI 24 application progressing?

  • havn't been invited to apply

    Votes: 34 35.4%
  • have been invited to apply

    Votes: 19 19.8%
  • applied but not yet accepted

    Votes: 30 31.3%
  • agreement up and running

    Votes: 13 13.5%

Webinar: Expanded Sustainable Farming Incentive offer 2024 -26th Sept

  • 3,124
  • 51
On Thursday 26th September, we’re holding a webinar for farmers to go through the guidance, actions and detail for the expanded Sustainable Farming Incentive (SFI) offer. This was planned for end of May, but had to be delayed due to the general election. We apologise about that.

Farming and Countryside Programme Director, Janet Hughes will be joined by policy leads working on SFI, and colleagues from the Rural Payment Agency and Catchment Sensitive Farming.

This webinar will be...
Back
Top