Vibrance duo

[ZXR17]

Anyone using it and getting results , good or bad ?

 

[snarling bee]

Waste of money.
(Tramline trial at neighbours)

 

[B'o'B]

I did a couple of split fields when it first came out. Not used it since.

 

[Northern territory]

Seen benefits on November drilled wheat. Not on emergence but thicker, stronger plants.

 

[B'o'B]

Seen benefits on November drilled wheat. Not on emergence but thicker, stronger plants.

Any thing when it came to yield?

 

[Northern territory]

Good question? Probably insignificant but if a comparison had any thinning then you might well do. I don’t think it holds it back at emergence like some other seed treatments do.

 

[ajd132]

I did use it for abit thinking it gave plants more vigour but now seen independent trials that show no yield benefit

 

[Ladybird]

Seen benefits on November drilled wheat. Not on emergence but thicker, stronger plants.

Would agree with this.
Especially in a direct drilled situation. Where we had a lot of late drilling this past autumn plants were vigorous and well established.

 

[Ladybird]

At £10 a Ha I think it’s money well spent

 

[ajd132]

At £10 a Ha I think it’s money well spent

I thought this too then saw the niab trials which showed no benefit. £10/ha soon adds up!

 

[deleted user 837354]

If it looks, smell and tastes like the proverbial, it's probably the proverbial.

 

[Gong Farmer]

I thought this too then saw the niab trials which showed no benefit. £10/ha soon adds up!

In anticipation, can no-one tag me for a comment? Thanks.

 

[Northern territory]

I thought this too then saw the niab trials which showed no benefit. £10/ha soon adds up!

just remember with trials it is usually done on a small plot basis with a 95% confidence level on statistics. This means it is very stringent on whether there is a benefit or not. Like I said if you are drilling in September, October there won’t be much of a benefit but in a later situation I think you will see one.

 

[deleted user 837354]

just remember with trials it is usually done on a small plot basis with a 95% confidence level on statistics. This means it is very stringent on whether there is a benefit or not. Like I said if you are drilling in September, October there won’t be much of a benefit but in a later situation I think you will see one.

Nothing a shot of manganese and magphos K in the autumn wouldn't sort.

 

[Farmer Bob]

When we’ve used it for later drilling there is a benefit. Establishment is so much better with more vigorous plants. I don’t care if there’s no yield benefit in trials, it works here and gets the plant off and growing which is priceless in a late year when it’s wet.

 

[Jinx]

As above, only on later drilled wheat where there's a noticeable improvement in speed of establishment. Some years this is more important than others, depending on how crap the weather is. I don't think it's necessary on early sown crops or where the weather is balmy.

 

[B'o'B]

To be fair it looks like people who are happy with vibrance duo are farming a lot further north than me and that’s a very different kettle of fish!

 

[T Hectares]

In anticipation, can no-one tag me for a comment? Thanks.

Sorry, how rude of us @Fromebridge