Anyone hear Archie Norman Marks and Spencers on R4 this morning ?

JP1

Member
Livestock Farmer

Marks and Spencers wagons going to Northern Ireland typically have to have 3 booklets with 720 pages of documentation

M&S emply 30 vets currently not on food safety just form filling

Loads have been rejected / food to landfill just for forms filled in the wrong colour ink

Even butter has endless food chain documentation

Surely food packaging labelled "For sale in United Kingdom" and subsidiarity rules are the way forward ?
 

neilo

Member
Mixed Farmer
Location
Montgomeryshire
I’m not sure why we keep hearing about this ‘wrong colour ink’ business. It’s always been the case on export documentation, to try to prevent fraudulent copies being made. Customs agents have always been sticklers for paperwork too.

It might seem petty, but there’s no excuse for those 30 people that are supposedly solely filling forms in, to make that schoolboy error.
 

JP1

Member
Livestock Farmer
I’m not sure why we keep hearing about this ‘wrong colour ink’ business. It’s always been the case on export documentation, to try to prevent fraudulent copies being made. Customs agents have always been sticklers for paperwork too.

It might seem petty, but there’s no excuse for those 30 people that are supposedly solely filling forms in, to make that schoolboy error.
The error rate was a fraction of one per cent . If you're despatching a wagon with 720 pages and spot one error and copy one page I can see how it's done

Same with me exporting my bull to NI, it's still in my Country yet it's EU phyto sanitary guff. Got to stop. Don't like Cummings mentality but I think Lord Frost has got a point . This is craziness
 

Boysground

Member
Mixed Farmer
Location
Wiltshire
Chap who lives in my village is a self employed farm engineer. He does a fair bit of work for a company that exports tractors and machinery to Europe. The latest issue they have is incorrect paperwork for air con gas. It’s all nearly new kit so not the tyre of gas.

He is now being employed to remove the gas prior to export.

Bg
 
The error rate was a fraction of one per cent . If you're despatching a wagon with 720 pages and spot one error and copy one page I can see how it's done

Same with me exporting my bull to NI, it's still in my Country yet it's EU phyto sanitary guff. Got to stop. Don't like Cummings mentality but I think Lord Frost has got a point . This is craziness
Cattle have always been subject to export regs and paperwork etc. even though its the same country.

I know of lorry loads of cattle that came from Denmark, Holland and Germany over the past 10 years and the first place they had problems was the docks at Larne.
 

le bon paysan

Member
Livestock Farmer
Location
Limousin, France

Marks and Spencers wagons going to Northern Ireland typically have to have 3 booklets with 720 pages of documentation

M&S emply 30 vets currently not on food safety just form filling

Loads have been rejected / food to landfill just for forms filled in the wrong colour ink

Even butter has endless food chain documentation

Surely food packaging labelled "For sale in United Kingdom" and subsidiarity rules are the way forward ?
EU suggested packaging marked for sale and use in UK only, could have a big union jack as well.
Frost rejected it!
Ask why.
 

le bon paysan

Member
Livestock Farmer
Location
Limousin, France
I’m not sure why we keep hearing about this ‘wrong colour ink’ business. It’s always been the case on export documentation, to try to prevent fraudulent copies being made. Customs agents have always been sticklers for paperwork too.

It might seem petty, but there’s no excuse for those 30 people that are supposedly solely filling forms in, to make that schoolboy error.
All official forms here, hand filled, have to be black biro. Use blue and it's rejected.
 

Ashtree

Member
So ROI car industry due to new VAT rules arising from Brexit, now saying that importing used vehicles from UK is no longer sustainable. Increase in VAT and admin costs, too much to bear. I expect ROI is a rather important outlets for UK used car industry. With ROI dealers now switching to direct imports from Japan as a viable alternative, that too will take a hit.
 

cowboysupper

Member
Mixed Farmer
Gotta have a border somewhere. Where would you like it to be? M&S and the other s/markets have had plenty of time to realign their supply routes to Eire. Why have they not done so?
Leave means leave.

With respect, that's easy for you to say. The NI Protocol was a sticky plaster to 'get Brexit done.' NI is now left with all sorts of complications for many industries trying to do business with GB, even though we're part of the same country.

Used to take a few days for us to get machinery parts from GB into NI. Now it's weeks and some companies won't do business at all with NI because of the paperwork. We're left trying to get parts from local dealers (who also can't get parts quickly) and are increasing prices. The machinery dealers in RoI know this too and have jacked their prices accordingly.

If I want to buy livestock in GB, I have to wait 40 days after I've purchased it before it can travel to NI. If I wanted to take livestock to GB to sell at the pedigree sales and some of them don't sell, I'd have to find a home for them for 40 days to get them home again. It's ridiculous we have some of the best traceability in the world and yet the movement of livestock 32 miles across the Irish sea has become so much more complicated than it used to be, despite the fact we're all part of the same Kingdom!

The Protocol needs fixed urgently.
 

Y Fan Wen

Member
Location
N W Snowdonia
With respect, that's easy for you to say. The NI Protocol was a sticky plaster to 'get Brexit done.' NI is now left with all sorts of complications for many industries trying to do business with GB, even though we're part of the same country.

Used to take a few days for us to get machinery parts from GB into NI. Now it's weeks and some companies won't do business at all with NI because of the paperwork. We're left trying to get parts from local dealers (who also can't get parts quickly) and are increasing prices. The machinery dealers in RoI know this too and have jacked their prices accordingly.

If I want to buy livestock in GB, I have to wait 40 days after I've purchased it before it can travel to NI. If I wanted to take livestock to GB to sell at the pedigree sales and some of them don't sell, I'd have to find a home for them for 40 days to get them home again. It's ridiculous we have some of the best traceability in the world and yet the movement of livestock 32 miles across the Irish sea has become so much more complicated than it used to be, despite the fact we're all part of the same Kingdom!

The Protocol needs fixed urgently.
You have my complete sympathy especially as you voted so strongly remain. I don't believe the protocol can be fixed, because, somewhere, we have to have a border. Maybe the unionists should change to the other union? United Ireland anyone?
 

Ashtree

Member
With respect, that's easy for you to say. The NI Protocol was a sticky plaster to 'get Brexit done.' NI is now left with all sorts of complications for many industries trying to do business with GB, even though we're part of the same country.

Used to take a few days for us to get machinery parts from GB into NI. Now it's weeks and some companies won't do business at all with NI because of the paperwork. We're left trying to get parts from local dealers (who also can't get parts quickly) and are increasing prices. The machinery dealers in RoI know this too and have jacked their prices accordingly.

If I want to buy livestock in GB, I have to wait 40 days after I've purchased it before it can travel to NI. If I wanted to take livestock to GB to sell at the pedigree sales and some of them don't sell, I'd have to find a home for them for 40 days to get them home again. It's ridiculous we have some of the best traceability in the world and yet the movement of livestock 32 miles across the Irish sea has become so much more complicated than it used to be, despite the fact we're all part of the same Kingdom!

The Protocol needs fixed urgently.

The Protocol was agreed as a last resort, as UK ERG/DUP used their votes to reject any and all other alternatives.
The quickest, easiest way now to drastically improve how the Protocol works, is for UK to accept alignment with EU veterinary. UK has been concerned that solution, could potentially disrupt a free trade deal with USA. Paddy Biden has stepped in on that, and assured Boris that such a solution will not get in the way of a deal with USA.
 

BrianV

Member
Mixed Farmer
Location
Dartmoor

Marks and Spencers wagons going to Northern Ireland typically have to have 3 booklets with 720 pages of documentation

M&S emply 30 vets currently not on food safety just form filling

Loads have been rejected / food to landfill just for forms filled in the wrong colour ink

Even butter has endless food chain documentation

Surely food packaging labelled "For sale in United Kingdom" and subsidiarity rules are the way forward ?
Can someone explain to me why the very same rules are not being enforced on all EU good entering this country, why would the EU ever compromise when they have a free pass?
 
Northern Ireland was always going to be a major issue upon which Brexit fouled. None of the Brexiteers gave it much thought, however. The protocol was cobbled together in order that that the Belfast Agreement could be complied with and Britain leave the EU. I have every sympathy for folk over there suffering petty bureaucracy and businesses struggling to comply, and the EU being seen as unreasonable when they are merely enforcing a rulebook to which GB signed up. Why expect anything else?
 

cowboysupper

Member
Mixed Farmer
The Protocol was agreed as a last resort, as UK ERG/DUP used their votes to reject any and all other alternatives.
The quickest, easiest way now to drastically improve how the Protocol works, is for UK to accept alignment with EU veterinary. UK has been concerned that solution, could potentially disrupt a free trade deal with USA. Paddy Biden has stepped in on that, and assured Boris that such a solution will not get in the way of a deal with USA.

Can't disagree with that. The DUP are a bunch of self righteous muppet. Teresa May's proposal was a good proposition for NI, but I appreciate didn't suit the demands of those who wanted a harder Brexit.

There were always going to be winners and losers out of the process, but unfortunately I think NI has ended up in the losing camp up until now... Hopefully that can change in due course
 
Can't disagree with that. The DUP are a bunch of self righteous muppet. Teresa May's proposal was a good proposition for NI, but I appreciate didn't suit the demands of those who wanted a harder Brexit.

There were always going to be winners and losers out of the process, but unfortunately I think NI has ended up in the losing camp up until now... Hopefully that can change in due course
I suspect that longer term, your dual status may be of great benefit.
 

SFI - What % were you taking out of production?

  • 0 %

    Votes: 105 40.9%
  • Up to 25%

    Votes: 93 36.2%
  • 25-50%

    Votes: 39 15.2%
  • 50-75%

    Votes: 5 1.9%
  • 75-100%

    Votes: 3 1.2%
  • 100% I’ve had enough of farming!

    Votes: 12 4.7%

May Event: The most profitable farm diversification strategy 2024 - Mobile Data Centres

  • 1,671
  • 32
With just a internet connection and a plug socket you too can join over 70 farms currently earning up to £1.27 ppkw ~ 201% ROI

Register Here: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/the-mo...2024-mobile-data-centres-tickets-871045770347

Tuesday, May 21 · 10am - 2pm GMT+1

Location: Village Hotel Bury, Rochdale Road, Bury, BL9 7BQ

The Farming Forum has teamed up with the award winning hardware manufacturer Easy Compute to bring you an educational talk about how AI and blockchain technology is helping farmers to diversify their land.

Over the past 7 years, Easy Compute have been working with farmers, agricultural businesses, and renewable energy farms all across the UK to help turn leftover space into mini data centres. With...
Top