Only 112 of 50,000 UK applicants for fruit pickers take jobs amid farmers' fears over skills and application - Telegraph

GeorgeC1

Member
Here is the paywalled text



Efforts to recruit British fruit and veg pickers have been dealt a blow as it emerged only 112 people out of 50,000 applications have taken up roles.

Thousands who responded to the Government’s appeal for a new land army have dropped out as they have discovered the reality of the eight-hour a day job picking crops in all weathers potentially miles from home.

From the 50,000 applications expressing interest to the Alliance of Ethical Labour Providers, one of the main contract suppliers to farms, just 6,000 opted to complete the video interview for a role.

About 900 then explicitly rejected the roles the Alliance offered, with just 112 taking up the offer of the seasonal job on a UK farm.

According to the Alliance, the main reasons were candidates unable to do the full length of the contract, that the farm was too far away from their home, that they did not want to commute, that they had care responsibilities that prevented full-time work or only wanted part-time work.

The drop-out rate has alarmed farmers as they prepare for the summer picking season to start in earnest next month and comes as the Government has quietly launched its “Pick for Britain” website to help farms recruit the seasonal workers.

“I am quite worried that we have had thousands of people apply but when it comes to the nitty gritty, we will only get tens coming through,” said Greville Richards, managing director of Southern England Farms in west Cornwall.

“If there are good people out there who want to come, then we'll take them. It’s hard work and it’s long hours but it’s good money. It gets my back up when they say people are coming here on the cheap.

“They do earn their money, they work hard but what is concerning is that that is putting off a percentage of the British workers. That is what we are finding quite difficult.”

Mr Richards recruited up to 50 seasoned East European workers in February, but who have stayed to help through the summer, ensuring that he will have a “mix” of British and foreign workers. He offers a “piece” rate where workers can opt out of a daily pay rate to earn extra per head or per tray.

David Simmonds, managing director of Riviera Produce in Cornwall, expected a “high turnover” as people discovered how tough the job was with 5am starts, working in all weathers and a rate of picking that needed to be cost effective. “We need people who are productive,” he said.

He has 200 East Europeans who have worked through the winter but needs a further 200 British workers who will need to be trained up. “The Government's ‘Pick for Britain’ initiative is good and we are supportive but it is a very worrying time,” he said.

Britain needs up to 90,000 seasonal workers for the harvest with some farms previously relying on a 90 per cent East European workforce.

However, recruiters report UK applicants saying they cannot commit to 40 hours a week or can only spare a few weeks despite many roles lasting at least two months and some up to six months. Concordia, one of the three companies in the Alliance, has warned its prospective recruits: “For health and safety reasons it’s vital that workers are able to commit to the full terms of a contract to limit the number of new arrivals on farms over a picking season.”

Two weeks’ self-isolation before starting the contract is followed by at least two weeks of training before being placed in a team for the duration of the job. “Anyone who can’t work as part of a small team, or for the full length of the placement, increases the risk of infection to all those on the farm.”

G’s Fresh, one of the UK’s biggest salad growers, has continued to bring in Romanians and chartered two planes from Bucharest earlier this month for experienced pickers who can train and support their UK recruits.

It expects two thirds of its 2,500 seasonal workers to be British versus 90 per cent East european previously. By targeting local communities, it has recruited 500 British workers and Anthony Gardiner, its marketing director, said: “We are positive we can get the numbers we need.”

________________________________________________________

I'm not overly knowledgable of the industry but to me, that screams out that Fruit Farms need to be flexible imo, there's a massive workforce out there but a lot of it consists of 50 year old accountants who are furloughed and want to do some work in the sun a couple days a week, of course they'll get repulsed by long shifts and miles away from home in often nothing more then a caravan - of course they'll stay home.
 

toquark

Member
This coupled with some growers chartering planes from Romania last week has been a massive own goal. There was an opportunity to bridge the divide, get the public on side, and win a massive PR gain. But no.

The cat's out the bag now - they obviously don't WANT local labour.
 

bluebell

Member
what about the thousands of school kids, teenagers? thousands of students? or is that to simple instead of them having a jolley? travellering around the world for a year at parents cost? or going to majorca or other islands i cant spell for two weeks?
 

farmerdan7618

Member
Livestock Farmer
Location
Somerset
The reality is that unemployment has been low for the last few years, and the British people have not been there to do the jobs.

The British people are now there, but unemployment is still low as most are furloughed instead. The furlough scheme means employees need to be available to go back to their job in 48 hours from being given notice from their employer.

To ask people to commit to a full picking season simply isn't going to work. And in all reality, why do pickers need 2 weeks of training? Surely a one day induction could be adequate, after self isolating at home before starting the job.

Drop the full time committments, and I am sure there will be people to do the work.
 

toquark

Member
How badly do they want the crops lifted? Of course the nature of the potential employees isn't perfect, but nothing is just now. If i was facing 100% crop failure and someone offered even a 20% recovery I'd take it. Two weeks to train a fruit picker?! I did it as a lad and can tell you a couple of hours would suffice.
 

Werzle

Member
Location
Midlands
To my mind fruit farms and the organisations advertising the jobs have made hard work of getting uk workers onto farms, in reality they dont want uk workers and its a publicity stunt to force the government to alter rules after brexit. Why not have a online jobs board where people can see which of there local fruit farms need help and let them make contact directly. Complete smoke and mirror con imo
 

Rowland

Member
what about the thousands of school kids, teenagers? thousands of students? or is that to simple instead of them having a jolley? travellering around the world for a year at parents cost? or going to majorca or other islands i cant spell for two weeks?
Students will be doing online exams for the next few months after that they could I suppose
 

toquark

Member
To my mind fruit farms and the organisations advertising the jobs have made hard work of getting uk workers onto farms, in reality they dont want uk workers and its a publicity stunt to force the government to alter rules after brexit. Why not have a online jobs board where people can see which of there local fruit farms need help and let them make contact directly. Complete smoke and mirror con imo
That’s what it looks like. A publicity stunt which is likely to backfire.
 

Chrisw

Member
Arable Farmer
Location
Cornwall
2 of the 6 chartered planes were hired by G's. Lettuce and fresh veg growers, so not fruit growers alone, but then, G's have always put themselves first and couldn't care less about anyone else or the industry. I hope everyone boycotts them after this stunt!!
 

kiwi pom

Member
Location
canterbury NZ
what about the thousands of school kids, teenagers? thousands of students? or is that to simple instead of them having a jolley? travellering around the world for a year at parents cost? or going to majorca or other islands i cant spell for two weeks?

I don't suppose they can hire school kids and students probably cant commit to the full season, so wont be offered the job.
If there's no DECENT accommodation and people live too far away or don't own a car they're not going to take the job either and as these jobs will certainly be 6 days a week possibly 7 people may not be able to take them as they have family commitments. Childcare is not open on the weekends.

I've commented on these threads before and asked how many TFF members would Put their hands up and do the job. None so far.
 

kiwi pom

Member
Location
canterbury NZ
Here we go again, everyone is an expert on how to recruit fruit pickers, how easy it is to pick fruit and who should do the picking. All this despite not having the faintest idea of how to do the job, what it involves and having absolutely no experience whatsoever other than seeing a punnet of strawberries in a shop .

You don't need to be an expert to figure out why people cant/wont take the job though.
Must commit to the full season.
Must live nearby or move into shared accommodation (the quality of which is rarely shown). No public transport either.
Must work 6 or 7 days a week so basically have no family commitments
As you say its hard, skilled work, so not everyone can do it.
Its not a fulltime job so people have to find work at other times of the year because it doesn't pay well enough to live on.

Basically companies are being as inflexible as possible because they have a good thing going with foreign workers and don't want to change. Which is fair enough, I'd be the same but just own it and say locals are too much hassle.
 

toquark

Member
Basically companies are being as inflexible as possible because they have a good thing going with foreign workers and don't want to change. Which is fair enough, I'd be the same but just own it and say locals are too much hassle.
Exactly. I don’t have any real issue with them employing foreign labour as they do plug a skills gap.

They can’t moan about the lack of labour and then turn their noses up at tens of thousands offering their services in exceptional circumstances.
 

GeorgeC1

Member
You don't need to be an expert to figure out why people cant/wont take the job though.
Must commit to the full season.
Must live nearby or move into shared accommodation (the quality of which is rarely shown). No public transport either.
Must work 6 or 7 days a week so basically have no family commitments
As you say its hard, skilled work, so not everyone can do it.
Its not a fulltime job so people have to find work at other times of the year because it doesn't pay well enough to live on.

Basically companies are being as inflexible as possible because they have a good thing going with foreign workers and don't want to change. Which is fair enough, I'd be the same but just own it and say locals are too much hassle.

My only real brush with Agricultural sector is when I worked with horses but I been on farms and stables where they prefer to bring in Bulgarians (I'm being literal here, not ignorant) for the picking season and they would share the accomodation with us or be in a caravan site nearby, they don't really like hiring locals for the farming side of the business because it's a hassle to find people who want to work 6 1/2 days a week for below NMW in real terms in a shitty accomodation.
 

Bongodog

Member
I live in what was once a major fruit growing area, most of the pickers were mums who did 9 to 3 to fit in with the school day and students during the summer holidays. The big growers don't want that, they want an onsite workforce living in ex seaside caravans available for 5am starts 7 days a week.
 

kiwi pom

Member
Location
canterbury NZ
I live in what was once a major fruit growing area, most of the pickers were mums who did 9 to 3 to fit in with the school day and students during the summer holidays. The big growers don't want that, they want an onsite workforce living in ex seaside caravans available for 5am starts 7 days a week.

Unfortunately business dictates that things need to be more intensive now. A good group of pickers from overseas will be way faster than the team of mums ever was.
When you recruit from abroad you get the keenest and most motivated that have good reason to do the job. These European countries will have their own fair share of lazy buggers that don't want to work.
The good ones are poached by countries like the UK that can pay more or provide a better/safer lifestyle than they would get at home.
 

Will you help clear snow?

  • yes

    Votes: 73 32.2%
  • no

    Votes: 154 67.8%

The London Palladium event “BPR Seminar”

  • 16,582
  • 250
This is our next step following the London rally 🚜

BPR is not just a farming issue, it affects ALL business, it removes incentive to invest for growth

Join us @LondonPalladium on the 16th for beginning of UK business fight back👍

Back
Top