Historic right of way to farm + camping

patrickr321

Member
Horticulture
Hi

I wonder if anyone can offer any advice or has had a similar experience to us. We moved to our farm in 2021 and are active farmers on our holding in Pembrokeshire: sheep, cattle, haymaking, and a new horticultural enterprise growing soft fruit. When we bought the farm, we knew that we had an acquired Right of Way to use the track to the farm - effectively an easement. Shortly after moving in, we set up a very small campsite (3 pitches) to diversify our agricultural activities. As we set up through an exemption organisation - the Greener Camping Club - we didn’t need planning and the whole thing was set up by them using Permitted Development. All the structures have to be temporary and moveable. Our intended operating season was May to September.

We announced our plans to neighbours but we didn’t discuss the Right of Way with the neighbour who owns the land that the track goes over - mainly because our solicitor said we should never discuss the track! We thought they’d be aware that the track was on their deeds but it turns out they weren’t. So there was no official complaint made at the time. So we started to welcome campers for the best part of 2 seasons. Last season we had 13 visitors in total - so it’s hardly a big operation.

This Spring, however, the neighbour realised that they own the track. They first of all asked us to remove the sign to our property, which is effectively on their land. This we did. We then received a letter stating that, although they do not have a problem with us having a small campsite, they will not allow campers to drive down “their” track - period. This was due, so they said, to the increased traffic driving past their house. They do not have a problem with walkers, cyclists or people arriving on horseback!

The technical issue here is that the track has been used for 100+ years for agricultural purposes. So there is no threat to our continued use. It could be construed, however, that campsite visitors have not been part of this historic use. My argument is that we are simply adding an element to our agricultural business - as many farms are. The fields are still used for agriculture. If we were setting up a golf club or holiday resort, I would understand that this would be a change of use.

Have I got a point or not? Ignoring their complaint is not really an option as they are confrontational people and we don’t want to ruin someone’s holiday with an argument at the end of the track!

Any thoughts, advice, feedback, similar experiences would be great. We've had an initial chat with a solicitor but they want to charge us £700 just to do some initial digging. Couple of other points: we maintain the track and the neighbour does not use the track to access their land - it simply runs between 2 of their fields. It's also a bridleway.

Thanks
 

box

Member
Livestock Farmer
Location
NZ
Here's my 2 cents:

1: Doing something like that and not telling the neighbour first is a dick move, considering access would effectively be via the neighbour's property (ignore the right of way for now).

2: Your solicitor is an arrogant sh*t stirring dick head, for first providing poor advice and now offering his services at an extortionate rate to rectify the very situation he created.

3: I'm no lawyer, but I guess you need to find out the rules and conditions of the right of way/easement to ascertain who can use it. I assume you're profiting from the campsite? Or is it free?
 

solo

Member
Location
worcestershire
I have a similar access track/bridleway to a field which clearly states in the deeds that the access track is for "agricultural purposes". It was bought with this knowledge and is used according to this deed. If I wished to use it for a non agricultural activity, then I would expect to negotiate with the track owner to allow permitted access for other purposes. It could be set up as simple as limited to 10 days a year with a time restriction by negotiation for example. This would have been easier before aggravating the track owner however.
 

Derrick Hughes

Member
Location
Ceredigion
I on a track we own they are not allowed to start a business that increases the traffic other than farming , when on farm bulk tanks were instaled a heavy tanker started using it , which i expect was in their rights , they cant even touch the track to repair it without permission, I suppose in our case it would be is camping part of an agricultural activity
 
Last edited:

TheTallGuy

Member
Location
Cambridgeshire
If it's a formal easement then it will depend on the wording used and should only require half an hour from a solicitor to say one way or another, if, on the other hand it's an "acquired right" then it's not so straight forward and will cost a lot of money to decide & could go either way. The best option is to try and negotiate with the track owner & to do so with humility. Whilst you see it as adding an element to your agricultural business, camping itself is not agricultural, nor is the access a case of a landowner accessing their land. As it's slso a bridleway they would have no grounds for having an issue with horses, cyclists or pedestrians.

Thirteen visitors per year might not seem much, but if they're there for a few days and come and go a couple of times a day it soon adds up.
 

Hill Ground

Member
Livestock Farmer
Location
Bucks
Not asking for a full financial breakdown, but how much does the camping add to your business? How long would it take for the campsite to pay off the solicitors fees alone? May not be worth the hassle?
 

Johnnyboxer

Member
Location
Yorkshire
I don't think it is a public right of way, just a private one to the OP's farm. We own a track that our neighbours have to use to get to their 2 smallholdings.
He mentioned it’s a bridleway, in post #1…. so must be a public ROW ( it’s the very last sentence on the post, if you re-read post #1)

Is it just a Bridleway or did it have higher public access status at any time, for vehicular use (agricultural or otherwise)

That is crucial
 
Last edited:

Nearly

Member
Location
North of York
Not asking for a full financial breakdown, but how much does the camping add to your business? How long would it take for the campsite to pay off the solicitors fees alone? May not be worth the hassle?
Might not be worth it for current non-ag business but there's always the next idea.
It needs sorting, probably with a different solicitor or face to face with neighbour.

I know of one row of cottages where access was 'residents only' then they objected to the farmer's normal farming activities.
He decided to enforce the 'residents only' restriction.
No post office, no Amazon vans, no guests and no tradesmen.
 

Wooly

Member
Mixed Farmer
Location
Romney Marsh
I have an access track going across some of my land, that my neighbour uses to get to his land.........he has rights to use it for agriculture purposes only. He wants to buy the track so his land can be used for non ag uses.
 

Exfarmer

Member
Location
Bury St Edmunds
Hi

I wonder if anyone can offer any advice or has had a similar experience to us. We moved to our farm in 2021 and are active farmers on our holding in Pembrokeshire: sheep, cattle, haymaking, and a new horticultural enterprise growing soft fruit. When we bought the farm, we knew that we had an acquired Right of Way to use the track to the farm - effectively an easement. Shortly after moving in, we set up a very small campsite (3 pitches) to diversify our agricultural activities. As we set up through an exemption organisation - the Greener Camping Club - we didn’t need planning and the whole thing was set up by them using Permitted Development. All the structures have to be temporary and moveable. Our intended operating season was May to September.

We announced our plans to neighbours but we didn’t discuss the Right of Way with the neighbour who owns the land that the track goes over - mainly because our solicitor said we should never discuss the track! We thought they’d be aware that the track was on their deeds but it turns out they weren’t. So there was no official complaint made at the time. So we started to welcome campers for the best part of 2 seasons. Last season we had 13 visitors in total - so it’s hardly a big operation.

This Spring, however, the neighbour realised that they own the track. They first of all asked us to remove the sign to our property, which is effectively on their land. This we did. We then received a letter stating that, although they do not have a problem with us having a small campsite, they will not allow campers to drive down “their” track - period. This was due, so they said, to the increased traffic driving past their house. They do not have a problem with walkers, cyclists or people arriving on horseback!

The technical issue here is that the track has been used for 100+ years for agricultural purposes. So there is no threat to our continued use. It could be construed, however, that campsite visitors have not been part of this historic use. My argument is that we are simply adding an element to our agricultural business - as many farms are. The fields are still used for agriculture. If we were setting up a golf club or holiday resort, I would understand that this would be a change of use.

Have I got a point or not? Ignoring their complaint is not really an option as they are confrontational people and we don’t want to ruin someone’s holiday with an argument at the end of the track!

Any thoughts, advice, feedback, similar experiences would be great. We've had an initial chat with a solicitor but they want to charge us £700 just to do some initial digging. Couple of other points: we maintain the track and the neighbour does not use the track to access their land - it simply runs between 2 of their fields. It's also a bridleway.

Thanks
I am afraid you probably have no right to use this for such purposes. We had a similar right of way many yearsc ago, giving access to a previous victorian owner over a field we had purchased. The grandchildren ( decently ) informed us that they were going to start making use of this right, which was 3/4s of a mile . We realised they would probably want to use motor vehicles particularly as their children were partial to motorbikes of all sorts. Thankfully we were able to check our deeds and the grandfather thought he had covered everything when he had put in the sale, access with all manner of horse and horse drawn implements and carriages.
luckily horses were not the lads thing and we never did see or hear anything more.
I would suggest you go and speak to your neighbour and see if you can sort it amicably, a large bottle of wine/ scotch may help, before you resort to the solicitors
 

Dry Rot

Member
Livestock Farmer
I have a similar access but don't encourage visitors of any kind.:happy: I am fully aware that my neighbour owns the land and I have an easement for farming. However, when I came here, I came with a lot of my own dogs and the planners thought it would be a good idea if I applied for planning permission for a kennels, which I did, as "someone is bound to complain'. I clearly remember a remark that having pp meant that it was accepted that I'd get visitors (i.e. the assumption was 'boarding kennels') and that would help establish\ a right of access for others. I don't know whether that is true but it might be an angle worth exploring.
 

Will you help clear snow?

  • yes

    Votes: 73 32.2%
  • no

    Votes: 154 67.8%

The London Palladium event “BPR Seminar”

  • 16,461
  • 249
This is our next step following the London rally 🚜

BPR is not just a farming issue, it affects ALL business, it removes incentive to invest for growth

Join us @LondonPalladium on the 16th for beginning of UK business fight back👍

Back
Top