Expectation's of relief milkers

jersey lou79

Member
Location
Shropshire
What do people expect of their relief milkers?
We're paying £45 per milking.
Start 5.30am finish 8.30
Start 3.30pm finish by 6
We fetch cows and close them up and help with wash down
We want to start earlier both milking so we actually get to finish by 5.30ish instead of generally a 6.30+ finish after closing cows up but some staff are moaning. We also want to get staff to occasional fetch cows in / close up
Is this unreasonable to ask on these wages / times ??
 

bitwrx

Member
I'd want £25-30/hr for relief milking. Think about it: early start and/or late finish. Effectively a split shift, so double commuting. Presumably self employed, so need to pay for holiday, sick, pension etc. It's not an unskilled job either, if done well.

On the other hand, I don't relief milk, and expect that if I looked around for work, I wouldn't find any takers for my terms. But I'd probably find plenty of people who can't get good relief staff. Go figure, as they say.
 

Milkcow365

Member
Location
Sw Scotland
What do people expect of their relief milkers?
We're paying £45 per milking.
Start 5.30am finish 8.30
Start 3.30pm finish by 6
We fetch cows and close them up and help with wash down
We want to start earlier both milking so we actually get to finish by 5.30ish instead of generally a 6.30+ finish after closing cows up but some staff are moaning. We also want to get staff to occasional fetch cows in / close up
Is this unreasonable to ask on these wages / times ??
Self employed ?
 

jersey lou79

Member
Location
Shropshire
I'd want £25-30/hr for relief milking. Think about it: early start and/or late finish. Effectively a split shift, so double commuting. Presumably self employed, so need to pay for holiday, sick, pension etc. It's not an unskilled job either, if done well.

On the other hand, I don't relief milk, and expect that if I looked around for work, I wouldn't find any takers for my terms. But I'd probably find plenty of people who can't get good relief staff. Go figure, as they say.
6pm isn't really a late finish when they have had from 9am to 3pm as free time.
 

jersey lou79

Member
Location
Shropshire
I don’t relief milk but if I did I’d want 35£ /hr for a Saturday or Sunday.

6pm is a late finish. Regardless of time off during the day.
You'd be a long time looking for work in north Shropshire then @ £35 / hour, I don't know any farms offering that money even for night ( 3xday) weekend milkings

Most of my friends working standard office jobs work 9-6
 

Nearly

Member
Location
North of York
6pm isn't really a late finish when they have had from 9am to 3pm as free time.
You'd be a long time looking for work in north Shropshire then @ £35 / hour, I don't know any farms offering that money even for night ( 3xday) weekend milkings

Most of my friends working standard office jobs work 9-6
9am to 3pm is no use for getting anything else done .
Relief milking needs to be double money compared to full days.
Been there.
 

bitwrx

Member
6pm isn't really a late finish when they have had from 9am to 3pm as free time.
Not exactly useful time though is it?
Everyone else you know is working, so no socialising. Someone else has had to get the kids ready for school, and pick them up. So _they_ can't have a full time job, leaving the relief milker to earn a 'full time' wage. The time between milkings is not long enough to do a full shift elsewhere, especially when travel time is taken into account, so not easy tinwork in with other employment.

The best you can hope for is someone local who is underemployed on their own (non-dairy) farm and can work it round their own daily routine. Which, incidentally, is the position I am in. You just have to induce them to turn up when you need them... For me, £25-30/hr would do it.

(Oh BTW, I used to work in an office. 40h a week, 25 days plus BHs off every year. Flexitime, starting anytime between 7 and 9:30. Good pension, opportunity to buy extra leave and dental/health insurance etc. All work gear provided if I was needed on site, and no hassle of being 'self-employed'.
My gross salary was equivalent to just shy of £25 per hour worked. Against that, £90 a day working split shifts doesn't look great does it?)
 

vantage

Member
Livestock Farmer
Location
Pembs
You'd be a long time looking for work in north Shropshire then @ £35 / hour, I don't know any farms offering that money even for night ( 3xday) weekend milkings
Most of my friends working standard office jobs work 9-6
Pretty much the same here. Not everyone is on office hours, many work shifts, then weekends are just the same as any other day.
9am to 3pm is no use for getting anything else done .
Relief milking needs to be double money compared to full days.
Been there.
True. Then the employer needs two separate milkers so the problem doesn’t arise.
 

Whitepeak

Member
Livestock Farmer
What do people expect of their relief milkers?
We're paying £45 per milking.
Start 5.30am finish 8.30
Start 3.30pm finish by 6
We fetch cows and close them up and help with wash down
We want to start earlier both milking so we actually get to finish by 5.30ish instead of generally a 6.30+ finish after closing cows up but some staff are moaning. We also want to get staff to occasional fetch cows in / close up
Is this unreasonable to ask on these wages / times ??
I do night milkings, typically 8-11.30pm includes setup, wash down, fetching groups, doing beds, pushing up feed and checking calving cows (also calve and feed calf if req). Always 2 of us there. All this for £40, which I am regularly told on here is not enough.
 
I used to do night milkings, 8pm to 11.30pm, we got cows in and washed out/locked up after, all for £35 a shift. Did it twice a week for a couple of months but at £10/hr and my husband was getting £12/hr doing daytime milking and gfw it really wasn't worth the lack of sleep! I have no issue with doing the whole job, not just milking the cows, as long as a sensible wage is paid.
 

jersey lou79

Member
Location
Shropshire
Pretty much the same here. Not everyone is on office hours, many work shifts, then weekends are just the same as any other day.

True. Then the employer needs two separate milkers so the problem doesn’t arise.
Agreed.
My original post was actually about what work people expect their workers to do but has got high jacked about wages regardless of the fact that I actually pay higher than majority of farmers around here.
 
I do night milkings, typically 8-11.30pm includes setup, wash down, fetching groups, doing beds, pushing up feed and checking calving cows (also calve and feed calf if req). Always 2 of us there. All this for £40, which I am regularly told on here is not enough.

It's enough if you're happy with it and enjoy the work.


There are a lot of dreamers on here and threads about wages seem to draw them all out.
 

Have you taken any land out of production from last autumn?

  • Yes

  • No

  • Don’t know


Results are only viewable after voting.

Fields to Fork Festival 2025 offers discounted tickets for the farming community.

  • 1,850
  • 1
The Fields to Fork Festival celebrating country life, good food and backing British farming is due to take over Whitebottom Farm, Manchester, on 3rd & 4th May 2025!

Set against the idyllic backdrop of Whitebottom Farm, the festival will be an unforgettable weekend of live music, award-winning chefs, and gourmet food and drink, all while supporting UK’s farmers and food producers. As a way to show appreciation for everyone in the farming community, discounted tickets are on offer for those working in the agricultural sectors.

Alexander McLaren, Founder of Fields to Fork Festival says “British produce and rural culture has never needed the spotlight more than it does today. This festival is our way of celebrating everything that makes...
Back
Top