Suspended from Red Tractor

all these "don't do it" 'just lie" posts......................... come on guys grow a pair, get some integrity and stop being bullied by this blackmail scheme

Sounds nice Clive but its too far gone. Problem with RT is they are judge, jury and executioner in this sort of thing. I don't agree with it because I find a lot of their excess's flagrant but farmers don't have any representation on the board so we're stuck, they need to grow their brand each year by making up new rules or finding issues that aren't really important.
 

Neuson510k

Member
Location
North Coast
i'm not missing the point, I know how to play their silly and pointless game and have done many times in the past - there are mice in my bloody farmhouse and always will be probably - what do they expect us to do ? destroy every rodent in the land ? ..................bet the public (our customers) would love that

There are not realistic, there will always be a low level of rodents on any farm and Im not going to lie and pretend otherwise to support some bullpoo box ticking protection racket


It's about time someone stood up to this stupidity

Yes but you have to get in the mindset of the FARCE

You got a Non-Compliance that's all.

You decide to write a strongly worded letter or heated phone call...to some office staff member who has a mortgage to pay, a range rover on the tick and has to save up for new tyres.. Why would they care?? There just following the procedure with a farmer that has a non-compliance. They are probably fully aware that the whole thing is a farce. But the box needs ticked.

Your not lying, you may put another bait box down.
 
they will see this thread I'm sure

trouble is do the give a shite as long as we keep paying the protection racket money ?

Nope. Red Tractor is about growing a brand. Its nothing to do with produce quality etc. its purely about promoting a generic brand. There's a stable income for them and the assurance sector is growing so much its not far off being considered a profession by those in the bubble
 

PSQ

Member
Arable Farmer
all these "don't do it" 'just lie" posts......................... come on guys grow a pair, get some integrity and stop being bullied by this blackmail scheme

Sorry, but as a cereal grower I DONT WANT FAECES IN MY BREAKFAST, and neither do the general public.

RT is designed to give create confidence in ALL OF OUR products, by establishing a standard for fit and proper produce for the human food chain.

You failed to meet that standard. Not by much, but you failed.

You can either rant about it, or sort it out.
 

nick...

Member
Arable Farmer
Location
south norfolk
I sympathise with you but they got us by the rubbish and they know it too.farmers would never stick together and tell em to shove their scheme up their arses.crop assurance inspection here this week which i despise.nice chap turns up and drinks my coffee and eats my biscuits and looks at everything that has cost money to do,for no real benefit and then get sent a bill for the privellage of it.really pisses me of but have to do it
Nick...
 
Sorry, but as a cereal grower I DONT WANT FAECES IN MY BREAKFAST, and neither do the general public.

RT is designed to give create confidence in ALL OF OUR products, by establishing a standard for fit and proper produce for the human food chain.

You failed to meet that standard. Not by much, but you failed.

You can either rant about it, or sort it out.

He wasn't objecting to the rejection by the miller though was he? Even though it was possibly disproportionate in this case.
 

Jackov Altraids

Member
Livestock Farmer
Location
Devon
The answer would be simple if we could trust everyone just to stop paying.
In reality, we need to talk to buyers to secure a non RT market for all who are willing to sign a contract of responsibility to the same effect.
I was going to suggest a farmer owned and run scheme but I don't think that would work in practice.
 

pgtips

Member
We all knew when FA came in it would make honest men liars.However, I say get stuck into them if you feel you have a case. The letter was probably standard issue and they need telling the full facts as you have explained them on here. I had an issue when they wanted me to light up the area for milk collection in case of a nighttime collection which was never going to happen.I got stuck in and when I eventually got hold of the part time employee the matter was soon resolved. It will take a bit of time and energy but you feel a lot better than just rolling over like most people are recommending. Keep us posted.
 

Fuzzy

Member
Arable Farmer
Location
Bedfordshire
Are these people for real - this stupidity has to stop

So after after storing 10's of thousands of grain this season in our farm / commercial stores, last week we deliver the last load of milling wheat, as we all know as practical farmers the last load form a store involves some sweeping down etc

1 (yes ONE) mouse dropping found ! so load rejected for milling, this is the ONLY rejection we have had all year so a very small % of our crop wheat crop ALL of which has gone to gp1 quality markets,

NO issue with the merchant, we discussed bringing back to clean, (not that ONE mouse dropping hardly justifies ) but we are fortunate to have modern facility to do so or re direct to a feed whet home (are chickens REALLY that picky ?)

Haulage and workload considered we decided it was best to redirect to a feed home - disappointing but not the end of the world, merchant as disappointed as us I think and just as annoyed by the pettyness of RT

NOW THE RIDICULOUS

A letter arrives yesterday from Red Tractor saying we are suspended from the scheme until we write to them explaining what we are going to do about our rodent problem.

I could write back and tell them how sorry we are and how we will change our policies etc. I'm sure a bit of bullpoo along those lines would satisfy them despite the fact it would change nothing and I would in reality do nothing different at all. Doing so would simply make me dishonest when there is nothing better or more that I can realistically do, there is no problem. The problem is their completely unrealistic and frankly ludicrous idea that any farm has no mice on it whatsoever

We don't NOT have a rodent problem, our storage facility is second to none IMO, we pass assurance with no uncompliances most years, and are not only red tractor assured but assured as a 3rd party store and testing lab under the way more robust GTAS scheme, we have a regular baiting policy and records , its very rare we see a mouse and I have never seen a rat in our yard. Bait points are plentiful, toped up regularly and are well located, modern buildings are sealed as well as any building can be, realistically there is nothing more that could be done to keep any rodent issues to a minimum here

I will be writing to tell them I intend to do nothing, there schemes is ridiculous, do they seriously expect there to be no mice at all on a farmyard ? Can ANY farm serious claim they have ZERO mice ever ?

Something needs to be done about these idiots, they are not being realistic here, if a modern multimillion £ storage facility like we have here can't satisfy them god only knows what will

What's the solution ? we have added this layer of extra cost to our business that has turned most farmers into liars to satisfy their unrealistic expectations, all so we can "compete" with grain and meat imported from markets where they don't even store stuff indoors quite often !
What about the droppings they did not find?
What happened to the mouse !!
Is it dead or alive ?
Time to call in the mouse police?

When we empty out our store the last sweepings get incinerated !!!
 

Clive

Staff Member
Arable Farmer
Location
Lichfield
What about the droppings they did not find?
What happened to the mouse !!
Is it dead or alive ?
Time to call in the mouse police?

When we empty out our store the last sweepings get incinerated !!!

maybe I should call in a hellfire drone strike ? its the only way too be sure


In fact I may email NSF to tell them thats the corrective action I will take !
 

colhonk

Member
Arable Farmer
Location
Darlington
I agree with Clive. I have not fully rejoined this year yet.On my small plot it is costing £`s an acre for nothing.I will join Clive`s alternate scheme.Does it actually say in rt rules that store must be 100% secure? On the VERY rare times the oh makes me go shopping, sometimes ask shoppers if they buy because of the rt logo, those that deign to answer have no idea what I`m on about,never heard of it,not bothered where their food comes from as long as it is cheap. The others are foreigners and don`t give a ........These rt lot need to do a survey with no fancy banners or logo`s or any other signs (in normal shops) and they will then get a proper survey result. BUT. They will not because they already know the answer.
 

Clive

Staff Member
Arable Farmer
Location
Lichfield
Sorry, but as a cereal grower I DONT WANT FAECES IN MY BREAKFAST, and neither do the general public.

RT is designed to give create confidence in ALL OF OUR products, by establishing a standard for fit and proper produce for the human food chain.

You failed to meet that standard. Not by much, but you failed.

You can either rant about it, or sort it out.

i have no objection to the rejection - it happens and off it went to become a chickens breakfast at £20 a tonne less instead of being yours - quite rightly so !

My objection is to being suspended from the scheme until I'm prepared to lie and say I will do something different from my perfectly good (and approved by NSF) procedure we have in place, we don't have a rodent problem here, not even close, despite these best possible efforts we do have a few mice as does every grain store and farm in the UK
 

Filthyfarmer

Member
Mixed Farmer
Location
Hertfordshire
Did the mill retest the load or was it rejected on that one sample with the one mouse turd? and when the load was tipped you could hand on heart say the sample was clean enough?

If the answer is yes, I would be looking for another mill !!

[edit] If the answer is no to the second question, probably should have gone through the cleaner especially as it was a clear up load
 
Last edited:

Kidds

Member
Horticulture
As a consumer I want to know there will be no mouse crap in my bread.
If I toured every hospital in the country and found one single mouse dropping I would want to know what they were going to do about it.

Yes you are right the rules are getting extreme but mouse dropping was found and as a very high standard producer you surely want to consider how it happened and what you might be able to do to stop it happening again. It can't possibly be the first time you have had to humour a jobsworth surely.
Besides, you are the one with mouse shite in your product. :D
 
all these "don't do it" 'just lie" posts......................... come on guys grow a pair, get some integrity and stop being bullied by this blackmail scheme
Oh aye I'm with you on the big pair side, and I'm sure you don't actually mean that I have no integrity-none taken.
I have had my nuts squeezed twice but maybe you are wealthy enough to afford a fight, I wasn't .
Good luck to you, it is after all your decision to make.
 

SFI - What % were you taking out of production?

  • 0 %

    Votes: 113 38.4%
  • Up to 25%

    Votes: 112 38.1%
  • 25-50%

    Votes: 42 14.3%
  • 50-75%

    Votes: 6 2.0%
  • 75-100%

    Votes: 4 1.4%
  • 100% I’ve had enough of farming!

    Votes: 17 5.8%

Expanded and improved Sustainable Farming Incentive offer for farmers published

  • 53
  • 0
Expanded Sustainable Farming Incentive offer from July will give the sector a clear path forward and boost farm business resilience.

From: Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs and The Rt Hon Sir Mark Spencer MP Published21 May 2024

s300_Farmland_with_farmFarmland_with_farmhouse_and_grazing_cattle_in_the_UK_Farm_scene__diversification__grazing__rural__beef_GettyImages-165174232.jpg

Full details of the expanded and improved Sustainable Farming Incentive (SFI) offer available to farmers from July have been published by the...
Top