The next big cull

melted welly

Member
Arable Farmer
Location
DD9.
So, given the continuous pressure on meat production/consumption and despite all the noise and money thrown at trying to force a habit change to factory grown alternatives, the last year has shown an increased demand.

Lot of money tied up in these new products, next few years will be make or break for the concept to gain significant foothold.

How long until Pirbright or similar has another leak? That would be very convenient to the cause.

or is that tinfoil hat territory?
 

melted welly

Member
Arable Farmer
Location
DD9.
Easier to get a conspiracy up and running against something new, untested and unnatural than something than we've been eating since time began.
Get in first. (y) Play them at their on game. "The ultimate in factory farming", Frankenfoods etc.
Bloke on bbc the other day said they were safe as they only contained growth hormones.

Are they the same growth hormones that bbc had knickers in twist about in American beef?
 

Bald Rick

Moderator
Moderator
Location
Anglesey
Bloke on bbc the other day said they were safe as they only contained growth hormones.

Are they the same growth hormones that bbc had knickers in twist about in American beef?

1622199093797.jpeg
 

digger64

Member
So, given the continuous pressure on meat production/consumption and despite all the noise and money thrown at trying to force a habit change to factory grown alternatives, the last year has shown an increased demand.

Lot of money tied up in these new products, next few years will be make or break for the concept to gain significant foothold.

How long until Pirbright or similar has another leak? That would be very convenient to the cause.

or is that tinfoil hat territory?
dont think its a conspiracy , just depends on the market prices /currency value and the uk's low key customs policy - the more attractive imports are the greater the risk
 

GeorgeC1

Member
Easier to get a conspiracy up and running against something new, untested and unnatural than something than we've been eating since time began.
Get in first. (y) Play them at their on game. "The ultimate in factory farming", Frankenfoods etc.

No offence but modern animal and arable farming is hardly natural lol. It's just as modernised and industrialised as Factory grown meats.

The animals are Geneticially Modified via thousands of years of selective breeding and the landscape changed to plant wheat, barley, oats etc.
 

wrenbird

Member
Livestock Farmer
Location
HR2
GeorgeC1, do you understand what genetically modified means? Thousands of years of selective breeding does not make farm animals " genetically modified". There are no genetically modified farm animals. The only genetically modified food animal that has been approved for use in the human food chain is the AquAdvantage salmon in North America. It was approved 5 or 6 years ago, but I don't think it has been used commercially because of consumer resistance.
 

wrenbird

Member
Livestock Farmer
Location
HR2
Easier to get a conspiracy up and running against something new, untested and unnatural than something than we've been eating since time began.
Get in first. (y) Play them at their on game. "The ultimate in factory farming", Frankenfoods etc.
Did anyone see the programme on BBC1 on Thursday night,"What are we feeding our kids". It showed, quite shockingly, the effect eating ultra-processed food has on children. It also highlighted how much peoples shopping habits, and therefore their diets, have changed, particularly in the last 20 years or so.
Whereas shopping baskets used to contain ingredients that were taken home and prepared and cooked, the majority of groceries nowadays are ultra-processed junk.
Over 20% of primary school children are obese, so the presenter lived on a typical childs diet of ultra processed food for a month, and it was shocking to see the changes to his weight and health in such a short time. Most frightening was the changes to his brain after a month. These changes were permanent and what you would expect to see in a drug addict or an alcoholic to do with cravings and addiction.
Worth a watch on i-player.
 

GeorgeC1

Member
GeorgeC1, do you understand what genetically modified means? Thousands of years of selective breeding does not make farm animals " genetically modified". There are no genetically modified farm animals. The only genetically modified food animal that has been approved for use in the human food chain is the AquAdvantage salmon in North America. It was approved 5 or 6 years ago, but I don't think it has been used commercially because of consumer resistance.

Whilst it's Not CRISPER selective breeding for desirable traits (for Humans) does a similar thing, and as such are totally artificial.
 

Macsky

Member
Livestock Farmer
Location
Highland
No offence but modern animal and arable farming is hardly natural lol. It's just as modernised and industrialised as Factory grown meats.

The animals are Geneticially Modified via thousands of years of selective breeding and the landscape changed to plant wheat, barley, oats etc.
🎵🎶 I troll, I troll, it’s off to work I go, with a keyboard and a screen, it’s my propaganda machine, I troll, I troll, I troll, I troll. 🎵🎶
©️@macsky 2021
 

melted welly

Member
Arable Farmer
Location
DD9.
No offence but modern animal and arable farming is hardly natural lol. It's just as modernised and industrialised as Factory grown meats.

The animals are Geneticially Modified via thousands of years of selective breeding and the landscape changed to plant wheat, barley, oats etc.

Hold on there Attenborough, selective breeding is a bit different to genetically modified, and a world away from lab grown.

going by your logic there, an Arctic fox is a “genetically modified” version of a desert fox or vice verse. 🙄

landscape changed to farm food, yes, but you’ve kinda undermined your own point with that analogy on what is natural:

A. 10 acre field of grass enclosed by hedge and trees, grazed by cattle to provide a food ( the long term benefits of which are noted over millennia) by converting rain water and solar energy via plants into meat.

B. 10 acres of concrete, tarmac, steel, glass, and plastic, containing bioreactors which convert (no ones 100% sure what it is are they? So let’s call it “stuff”) “stuff” into moulds, or refine and process existing cheap protein products into different “stuff” that looks a bit like meat and aims to replace landscape A with landscape B. This is powered by electricity and mains water.

The difference between the produce of landscapes A and B are worlds apart, despite B doing its best to replicate A.

A is the product of millions, possible billions of interactions between plants, animals, soil, microbes, nematodes, worms, flies, weather, water. Produce of landscape A contains a little bit of all of these interactions to provide a source of food that has sustained and evolved life for millennia.

B is the product of taking “stuff” and trying to replicate A by throwing money and energy at it to produce something that can ultimately be mass produced in landscape B at lower cost, and sold for greater profit than A.

What is your vision of the future for food production? Is it one where it’s centred around mass production from a handful of massive corporations?
 

Will you help clear snow?

  • yes

    Votes: 68 32.1%
  • no

    Votes: 144 67.9%

The London Palladium event “BPR Seminar”

  • 9,296
  • 123
This is our next step following the London rally 🚜

BPR is not just a farming issue, it affects ALL business, it removes incentive to invest for growth

Join us @LondonPalladium on the 16th for beginning of UK business fight back👍

Back
Top